McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I meant by 'RAW data' just the original unedited, pre-processed data captured by the camera. I assume this could, if implemented, be converted and stored for retrieval into a RAW container? Instead it is used by the processor to edit and output a video file, like .avi / .mpeg.

I absolutely do take your good words for it Steve, and you've given some really helpful explanation about it, thanks I shall certainly start trying to shoot with more neutral settings, and see how Sony Movie Studio Platinum 13 can work the files.

Comment by McGregNi posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 24/12/2014 - 00:19

McGregNi
I'll go for this long distance view from the Purbeck Hills, early morning back in August, looking towards Poole Harbour and Studland Bay, with the Bournemouth shoreline to the far right..... Lovely to be there, but I was very pleased with this result.



Comment Image

Comment by McGregNi posted on Post your favourite photo taken this year :) at 24/12/2014 - 00:11

McGregNi
Thanks Steve ... what I'm confused about is, if the additional saturation (ie more colour) was not added to the output file from the camera (having been captured and recorded and stored within the RAW), how can external software 'add' more saturation and produce a better quality result than if that added saturation had originated directly from the RAW data?

Are you saying its just because the additional processing demand on the camera will cause its quality to degrade?

Comment by McGregNi posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 22:38

McGregNi
Well, its there if you ever need it, and I doubt it added much to your cost.

Comment by McGregNi posted on How many photographers use video function on DSLR at 23/12/2014 - 22:17

McGregNi
Hmm, not sure if you could fit in all the sewage pipes with just a phone !

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 22:14

McGregNi
I thought that was a mirrorless ILC, not a dedicated video device?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Why video on a DSLR? at 23/12/2014 - 22:11

McGregNi
Its great to see a thread dealing with details and specifics of the video features and technicalities, so thanks to the OP for raising it, and thanks for putting in the effort to look into things in depth.

Just one question, I noted that early on you mentioned your preferred 'neutral' custom image settings for video ( and Steve Ledger also said he used similar) ... you said this was because better results and quality could be extracted if these aspects (contrast, high key, saturation etc) were later edited in software on a computer. But you also said that the video output file formats are sort of equivalent to photo JPEGs ... ie, compressed, processed files, with these characteristics sort of 'burnt in'.

Now, we wouldn't ideally want to make significant changes to a JPEG with computer editing ... we'd really want to get that right on the camera ideally, because the camera processor is the only place that gets a stab with the 'RAW' data. So surely it is also the case with video output ... the camera processor is the only place that uses the RAW video data, so surely editing adjustments are best placed to occur right there in the camera, rather than burned in and then further adjusted outside?

In the case of saturation, is this not more the case? I mean, why would NOT saturating an .avi or .mpeg in the camera, producing a neutral toned output, lead to better colour quality by adding saturation to that output later on a computer?

Comment by McGregNi posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 22:09

McGregNi
A dedicated video camera that output the recorded quality of my Pentax camera, with the IQ available from the lenses I can put on it, would cost some very serious cash!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Why video on a DSLR? at 23/12/2014 - 21:59

McGregNi
Video is an essential aspect of my DSLR .... I expect it and would look at video functions, control options and accessory support related to video, before buying another DSLR. This is not because I am any sort of serious 'videographer' or film-maker, but simply because I am a serious amateur photographer who likes to record important family times, both in stills images and video, when I'm out and about with them all. Because I value high quality in digital photographs, so I value high quality HD video, and can appreciate the output that our cameras are capable of.

But I don't have four hands, nor capacity to carry extra bags and equipment, nor the time to switch between devices when I'm with the family ... I need to be able to switch instantly between taking images and video recordings, as appropriate to whats happening. These needs can only be met by a single device, and my DSLR provides by far the best portability, versatility and quality for these combined purposes. So high quality video is an essential component on my DSLR, for me.

Comment by McGregNi posted on How many photographers use video function on DSLR at 23/12/2014 - 21:55

McGregNi
Blythman wrote:
Thanks for additional feedback folks. Much appreciated. No need to explain yourself Nigel, we all have opinions. ....
No, not explaining ... I was aiming to persuade other people to share my opinion

Comment by McGregNi posted on Cambois beach at 23/12/2014 - 21:46

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo