McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Its true, but the point about it being the photographer sidetracks the issue I feel. You could have Joe Cornish, David Noton etc etc going out with a compact camera, and you might reasonably expect very nice results ... but, ultimately, there will be very real limitations as to the application that those images could be put to, and in deed very real limitations as to what detail and dynamic range they could reproduce, because of the limitations of lens and accessory support that the compact camera can provide.

Given the two cameras in the same locations and situations, our Joe Cornish and David Noton etc would produce a higher quality result with a high end, large sized sensor camera (and system).

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 21:39

McGregNi
I use video frequently .... often in conjunction with stills shooting when out with the family. I love the flexibility of flicking between video and stills with a turn of the mode dial.

Comment by McGregNi posted on How many photographers use video function on DSLR at 23/12/2014 - 17:06

McGregNi
swarf wrote:
I voted 'Never', although to be completely honest I have played with it 3 or 4 times. If I wanted a video camera I would have brought one - they're cheap enough.

Phil
I feel if you bought a 'cheap video camera' then you'll miss a lot in quality terms .... frankly, my K7 with high quality lens and stereo mic is capable of excellent results, better than a cheap video camera IMO.

DSLRs can be excellent video tools, especially when coupled with wide aperture lenses creating DOF effects ... also there is an increasing range of accessory add-ons to support high quality video recording.

Comment by McGregNi posted on How many photographers use video function on DSLR at 23/12/2014 - 17:04

McGregNi
I was thinking about the never-ending debate over 'the megapixel race', and the argument that the additional megapixels on the K3 had not lead to gains in certain areas of IQ, as compared to the K5II ... higher ISO noise and Dynamic Range performance are the ones mostly referred to.

Could we expect a 50mp FF sized sensor to rival a 40mp 645 size one in these IQ aspects ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 15:31

McGregNi
What makes more sense would be a customisable video function button ... I mean one switch that's dedicated, by default, to quickly activating video mode (useful for those who switch between photos and videos), but allow the switch to be customised for a variety of other functions (eg, switching between two pre-defined focus point arrays, or AA filter simulator on/off, or spot/matrix metering switching) ... the kind of things that every photographer might choose as an option. This way the hardwear is being paid for, but actually used, by everyone.

Comment by McGregNi posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 15:23

McGregNi
Forget it ... its not going to happen. The market simply demands quality HD video now in any serious camera. Pentax would be rubbished if they removed it, and frankly the production costs of building two side by side models would outweigh any savings of not having video features. In fact, I think its been argued that the video functionalities add very little real cost to making the cameras.

There's no way you guys are going to save £100 by getting a camera without video.

Comment by McGregNi posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 15:14

McGregNi
Isn't that just yet another smaller sensor (smaller than the 645) cramming more pixels on board ... why would that lead to comparable performance?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 15:08

McGregNi
That's a valid viewpoint and fear, if you limit the potential purchasers to the group of people who already are happy with a K3 or a 645d/z, (which Ricoh may well be doing ...) . But the potential opens up, surely, if you consider those who are not completely satisfied with the best that aps-c can offer, but for whom the 645 is overkill (or not flexible enough) ... Those people, if they can afford it, are choosing the competitors 'FF' offerings ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 14:00

McGregNi
He remains tight -lipped about future development ... Lets hope their just planning to spring a surprise with FF The obvious interpretation of his wafflings about it is that they don't think there's the market for it Lets hope its all a cruel trick.

One good clear positive message is about the sharing of technologies both upwards and downwards in the range, eg the K-S1 has the AA filter simulator, that was introduced not that long ago on the top end K3 ... That makes increasing value in newer products over time.

For being ' head of marketing' I would have thought he would have a stronger sales pitch, and a slicker delivery ... Surely a guy like him has to stand up regularly and give high powered presentations and really convince others? Did he actually list the focal range available as from 14 to 300 mm?? Did he just forget some lenses?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Interview Ricoh's John Carlson (Pentax) at 23/12/2014 - 11:08

McGregNi
I'm quite happy to be the 'odd one' here! Not least because it has got others looking and thinking about the compo. I did offer up a balanced view, listing all the positives first (colour, exposure etc) .... and I am pleased that clearly the layout works for everyone else Well done for that Alan!

I keep looking, but I cannot shift my initial discomfort with the first one. I can't understand how anyone could see this 'pipe' as a 'balancing' factor to the quite puny elements in the far right distance?? As it is , I find it placed rather bizarrely , clinging to the left edge, not knowing if its foreground or what .... (at least, it doesn't seem to take that particular compositional role). And its too far away for the viewer to get any sort of 'in ya face' impact of detail (which would be another obvious use for it).

However, a choice was made, and its a popular one! Such a powerful object in a scene can only stimulate ideas for all the alternative ways to use it, and I find this image pushes that need to the forefront.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Cambois beach at 22/12/2014 - 20:03

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo