Aitch53

Joined: 30th August 2013

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Aitch53
bforbes wrote:
derek897 wrote:
I'm not adverse to flipping an image if it works better, but I wouldn't flip this one.
Might be just me but I prefer the unflipped one.
johnha wrote:
I prefer the original 'top' image, although in this case they both work as the bottom one could have been taken from the other side of the gate.

Composition is such a personal thing, but the best book I've seen on it is 'The Image' by Michael Freeman.
It must be personal, as I prefer the second. If it was determined subconsciously would we all pick the same?
Just to make things more complicated, could it also depend on which one you see first?

Or even, how recently you read a book on composition?

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Composition Question(s) at 01/03/2018 - 13:27

Aitch53
As I said, I'm right-handed and prefer #2.

Also, I'm right eye dominant, if that makes a difference.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Composition Question(s) at 01/03/2018 - 13:00

Aitch53
Depends what mood you want. As JohnR said, #1 is wistful, whereas #2 has a slight air of menace. Which one do you want?

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Eye Contact at 01/03/2018 - 12:37

Aitch53
I prefer #2, but the image set me thinking along more general lines, so I've started a thread.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Two takes on the same image at 01/03/2018 - 08:53

Aitch53
I’ve just been looking at womble’s ‘Two takes on the same image’ images/thread and it set me to thinking. I like the image, but…

Something about it niggled. Then I realised what - in my opinion, the image looks better flipped. That way the lead-in lines seem to flow better. This in turn set me thinking about composition and learned behaviour.

I am English and English is my native language. In English we learn to read left-to-right, which presumably feeds into the concepts of composition we learn. However, I’m also right-handed and I’ve also noticed that some younger children who are left handed try to write right-to-left.

So, a couple of questions:

1. Are there any members of the board whose native language reads right-to-left (or bottom-to-top)? And does it affect how the leading lines in an image work best for them?
2. Any left-handers who feel something/anything similar?

Or is it just me?

Oh, and I'm not dissing womble or his image/composition, just using it as an example.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Composition Question(s) at 01/03/2018 - 08:51

Aitch53
Algernon wrote:
Very well written and all perfectly true. I've never understood why people have always been so dismissive of Pentax...
They weren't always...
Comment Image


from 1979

Comment by Aitch53 posted on My rant: 100 years (-1) or why I care for those who remain silent at 27/02/2018 - 21:49

Aitch53
I think the 'No returns accepted' isn't a good sign either.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Nothing dodgy about this at 26/02/2018 - 13:41

Aitch53
My LF1 is always in my jacket pocket.

Yeah, I know, not Pentax. Unfortunately, there is no Pentax equivalent. C'est la vie.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on The Martians Have Landed! at 25/02/2018 - 12:58

Aitch53
Can't help thinking Pentax missed a bit off a chance there with the KP.

Make it more symmetrical and have a larger (optional extra) grip, with built in shutter release ( and maybe a control wheel) available in left or right-hand options, connection sockets on the front of the body and there you go - the option of a left-handed camera!

That would have caused a bit of a stir.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Left handed DSLR ? at 24/02/2018 - 16:41

Aitch53
womble wrote:
Seems he had a liking for the black versions!
It always struck me as odd that they were gloss black and not matt.

Presumably the point of black bodies was to make them less conspicuous, but the gloss black still reflected enough light to produce tell-tale flashes; though possibly not as much as silver bodies.

Comment by Aitch53 posted on Times Obituary at 24/02/2018 - 13:51

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo