All Forum Comments
Comment by RobL posted on Forum member "robbiec"? at 16/05/2017 - 00:07
Ps as a rule I always get an address before ordering anything online, and check it out on Google Streetview. Also pay with credit card so the bank can deal with problems and refund fraudulent payments (the bank is the purchaser, not you).
Comment by RobL posted on Forum member "robbiec"? at 15/05/2017 - 23:46
Comment by RobL posted on Which DSLR to buy? at 15/05/2017 - 23:22
I have a few points to make and then I am going to end my posts to this topic.
First, all the comments on my original version of Heavenly Shades of Night Are Falling were very positive, as all the persons who posted them would agree. Mag07, though he liked the photo, suggested that he detected a very slight curving in some of the buildings' profiles. Nocturnal corrected Mag07 by saying there were not curves, just slightly converging lines, and that he liked that effect. I however, after a very close examination, found what my fellow PUsers were talking about and decided to take Mag07's advice to make adjustments in LR, and indicated that in a post, openly and HONESTLY.
Then, openly and HONESTLY, I started this forum topic, asking how I could replace the original photo with the adjusted one and still retain the comments. I fail to see what is unfair or dishonest in wanting to retain positive comments. Of course I would have alerted users to the nature of the adjustment because I wanted them to know I improved the photo, thanks to Mag07. If I had instead just uploaded the revised image without touching the first one, I would have achieved the same goal, except that now I would have two images that I was positive would look identical to the vast majority of viewers. Also, I believed PU allows photo updates, because they have a Photo Update button. I am a new member (January 2917), and had no inkling I was doing something unfair or DISHONEST. I still don't "get it".
Will somebody please explain in detail what I did that was unfair? Note that John Riley, who first brought the issue up, used the word "potentially".
And will somebody please tell me if it is even possible to retain comments?
Comment by RobL posted on Gallery Help Please at 13/05/2017 - 16:42
Comment by RobL posted on Gallery Help Please at 13/05/2017 - 08:16
Comment by RobL posted on Latest Pentax rumours at 12/05/2017 - 19:42
Comment by RobL posted on Higher prices again. at 07/05/2017 - 13:44
Wex are selling the K1 for £1799.
Comment by RobL posted on Higher prices again. at 06/05/2017 - 22:46
Comment by RobL posted on Higher prices again. at 06/05/2017 - 20:53
Comment by RobL posted on Joined then got burgled at 02/05/2017 - 09:03


You can't normally pay for a private sale with a credit card unless the seller is a dealer of some sort. Sales through here usually involve PayPal or a bank transfer.