RichardDay

Joined: 19th May 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

RichardDay
Pentax 10-17 every time, it's the best FE out there.

EDIT - It will not overlap your Sigma 10-20, it has a completely different usage and FOV, even if you defish a 17mm shot, it's about equal to a 14mm rectilinear, at 10mm (not de-fished) it covers a 180 deg FOV, the Sigma at 10mm cover around 108 deg, that's a huge difference.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Jumping on the Fisheye at 16/10/2009 - 15:44

RichardDay
Currently, at new prices, the sharpest would probably be the Sigma 50mm f2.8 macro, as far as zooms are concerned, I suspect it would be DA 16-45 as mentioned by Dave, which is actually a very fine lens.

Sadly there is very little left at under £300 new, those days have now gone.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Sharpest lens under £300. at 14/10/2009 - 21:55

RichardDay
No, not for me, I find that "Silence is Golden"

There is far too much "background" noise in the world, music shouldn't be reduced to that level, it should be enjoyed with your full attention at it's original volume levels, preferably live, but at the very least, well reproduced by quality gear, you wouldn't accept anything less with your photography, would you?

The only activity that could possibly be considered symbiotic with listening to music is enjoying a drink!

Having background "musick" is a horrible modern disease.

Rant over!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Background Music at 14/10/2009 - 17:33

RichardDay
Steve

I agree with you, but I know Peter and I value his views, however brief. As he is the publisher of Pentax User, maybe he could shed some more light on the matter?

Anyway, no matter, I shall evaluate a few samples myself to see what they're like. You well know the sagas we've both had with regard to lenses!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 13/10/2009 - 10:18

RichardDay
Thanks Dave

The wait for both the grandchildren and the lens was well worthwhile!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Some DA*60-250 shots (of our grandchildren) at 12/10/2009 - 20:20

RichardDay
Rather than rabbit on about gear, I thought I'd post some shots.

Took these yesterday of our grandchildren when son #2 and daughter in law visited. All with K20D and DA*60-250, all are cropped from larger images.

This is Ewan, the youngest.

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


This is his big brother Sam.

Comment Image


Comment Image

Comment by RichardDay posted on Some DA*60-250 shots (of our grandchildren) at 12/10/2009 - 18:22

RichardDay
Lance B wrote:
I often wonder the value of doing an f25 or f22 shot when diffraction becomes an issue.
I do agree Lance, a shot at f8 (approx optimal aperture) on a flat plane subject would have been very useful, but I think Peter was trying to compare them both with max DOF, nevertheless even at those very small apertures both lenses held up very well.

At around 1/3 the current cost of the DA 12-24, the Tamron does seem a reasonable option. As you know I don't believe now't but my own eyes when it comes to lenses, so I will be making a trip to see Chris in the near future!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 12/10/2009 - 10:30

RichardDay
The FA 100 f2.8 macro is probably one of the best macro lenses Pentax made apart from the fabulously rare and top performing FA*200 f4 macro link.

Unlike the D-FA 50 macro, which is the same optical design as the FA 50 macro, the D-FA 100 macro is not the same as the FA 100 macro.

You can see the performance difference between them in the Photozone reviews:

FA 100 macro link and the D-FA 100 macro link

I believe the D-FA 100 is a Tokina design and the Tokina 50 macro is the Pentax design, part of the design co-operation between the two companies prior Hoya.

If I had the choice between them, I would get the FA every time, it's a classic. Out of interest, what did you pay for it?

Comment by RichardDay posted on Pentax SMCP FA 100mm f/2.8 at 11/10/2009 - 19:43

RichardDay
womble wrote:
RichardDay wrote:

I don't "need" more than the 17-70 in most circumstances, certainly not enough to spend 12-24 money (even the Samsung at £450 'ish), but it would be nice to have something centred around 14mm which I find a very workable F/L for quick wide shots...
Why not get a DA 14mm or DA 15mm Ltd then? The 12-24 is a big lens, the Ltd very small.

K.
Almost pulled the trigger for a s/h DA14 that sold on ebay for £280 if I remember rightly, but I'm really a zoom man and like the range from 12 to 24mm.

That's why the Tamron appeals and it's within my mental budget if I sell on a few items to help fund it. I could raise around £200 from some unused items and I'm prepared to put another £150 max towards it. Any more and it's not worth it to me, I'd rather make do. I'm forced by economic restraints to be a practising tightwad!

The DA 15 appeals slightly as the flare resistance is exceptional and it's very small, plus it's exceedingly expensive, but I'd use it so little that I think I'd rather go back and buy a Zenitar, which I sold on as it was so close to the DA 16-45 at 16mm that I rarely used it.

I once had the dream of having a stack of pancakes, i.e. 15, 21, 40 & 70, but after having worked with the latter 3 for a few months, I decided that it was actually more of a bad dream, as collectively they were no smaller or lighter than a decent zoom and considerably more expensive and far less flexible. For me, primes are out, except for true macros and dedicated long telephotos of 300mm and over.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 11/10/2009 - 12:31

RichardDay
I used to with my *istD and FA*24 as I found the F/L ideal for general walkabout usage. However when I bought my DA16-45 the 24 fell into disuse and I eventually sold it last year.

I still quite often go out with only one lens on my K20D and that's a zoom, currently the DA 17-70 which I really like.

I've had many primes, FA*24, FA 28, FA35, FA*300 f4.5, DA 21, DA 40, DA 70, Zenitar 16mm, Peleng 8mm and Hartblei T&S 90mm, but quite frankly I just can't be bothered with them except for macro and dedicated long telephoto work. The only prime I now have left is my trusty and much loved FA 50 f2.8 macro.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Dicipline. at 11/10/2009 - 12:19

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo