All Forum Comments
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 10/10/2009 - 17:53
Stefan, a DA* 11-16 is unlikely to be much better than the 12-24, nor much smaller, and it would lose the useful 8mm at the top end. Why would you want it?
G
I had the Sigma 10-20 (two of them) and was forever changing back to my DA 16-45 for the more convenient focal range, even for street and architectural work (not to mention the better IQ which is what concerns me about the Tamron). Unfortunately the DA 12-24 or even the Samsung are now too rich for my pocket v. usage.
I'm forever kicking myself that I didn't buy a Samsung 12-24 when I saw one in our local Currys for £199 a while back.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 10/10/2009 - 15:58
This from DPreview Richard
Comparison to other wideangle zooms we've tested recently suggests the Sigma's class-leading days may be numbered. On APS-C, it simply can't match the biting central sharpness of the Tamron 10-24mm F3.5-4.5 Di-II in the 10-18mm range (for which, we suspect, users will mainly be buying this type of lens), and has more problematic distortion characteristics.
However when you compare it with the results from the Tokina (Pentax) 12-24, the divergence is much larger, especially at the optimum aperture of around f8 where the 12-24 hovers close to the Nyquist limits across almost the whole frame, wheras the Tamron and especially the Sigma fall down quite badly.
From Peter's tests, it would appear that the Tamron is much closer to the Pentax in many respects and maybe even better in some areas. :
Anyway, I will trot over to SRS at some time to see if it's a worthy addition to my bag.
I don't "need" more than the 17-70 in most circumstances, certainly not enough to spend 12-24 money (even the Samsung at £450 'ish), but it would be nice to have something centred around 14mm which I find a very workable F/L for quick wide shots (I usually prefer to stitch several shots when I have the time to compose). I have considered the DA 10-17 as I quite like the lack of perspective stretch distortion and the creative effects obtainable from a fish eye, but de-fishing, even at the longer end where it's less damaging, reduces the IQ sufficiently to be unattractive.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 10/10/2009 - 11:38
AP also ran a good review of this lens.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 09/10/2009 - 22:11
DPreview also has a positive review up about the 10-24, it isn't a bad lens all in all, certainly since it's one of the cheapest wide angle lenses.
My interpretation is that DPReview rated the IQ of the Tamron somewhat lower than the Sigma 10-20 and significantly worse than the Tokina 12-24. From Pete's review I wouldn't have said that was the case.
I had 2 copies of the Sigma 10-20 and found them much as DPR describes them in relation to a Pentax DA 12-24 that I'd borrowed and didn't keep them as the 12-24 was very much better.
From Pete's review it would seem that the copy of the Tamron he had is at least as good, if not better, than the DA 12-24 he has. If this is truly the case then I'm really interested in the Tamron, especially as now the Pentax is astronomically expensive.
I guess I will have to take a trip to SRS and try a few (I will need to find a really good one :wink.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 09/10/2009 - 22:10
Does anyone else have any thoughts, or experience, that the Tamron is a very fine lens if you get a good one?
I've also heard that the chaps at SRS tend to recommend this lens as well.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Tamron 10-24 ePHOTOzine review by Pete Bargh at 09/10/2009 - 21:17
Hi - Update on the attempted repair to my 50-135 DA*
Joe Virgil (Pentax USA) responded today to my voice mail and is tracking down the lens to try and get it back by the 13th
I can ask no more than that
Thanks Mr Day and thanks Pentax USA (Joe Virgil)
Fingers crossed.
Comment by RichardDay posted on SDM issues? A straw poll. at 08/10/2009 - 19:12
I use them all the time for 18x12 inch lustre prints, can't fault them for print quality or price - they get my recommendation
Simon
I notice that you offer prints larger than 18x12 inch on your website, do you use them for these prints, or do you use another supplier?
I haven't used them for the larger sizes as they use inkjet printers above 18x12 - I did discuss this with them & was told that the inkjet prints wouldn't be quite the quality of the smaller prints.
I've used a company called TOGSPRINT for the larger prints, a little bit more expensive but very good quality and excellent service
hope this helps
Simon
Comment by RichardDay posted on Has anyone used DSCL (Fujifilm) on-line printing at 07/10/2009 - 22:10
I use them all the time for 18x12 inch lustre prints, can't fault them for print quality or price - they get my recommendation
Simon
I notice that you offer prints larger than 18x12 inch on your website, do you use them for these prints, or do you use another supplier?
Comment by RichardDay posted on Has anyone used DSCL (Fujifilm) on-line printing at 07/10/2009 - 21:45
I use them all the time for 18x12 inch lustre prints, can't fault them for print quality or price - they get my recommendation
Simon
I'm looking forward to seeing the results.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Has anyone used DSCL (Fujifilm) on-line printing at 07/10/2009 - 21:09


Anyway, the range is too small for me as I found 10-20 a nuisance and reverted back to the 16-45 a lot of the time. Having used a 12-24 and found the coverage to 24mm made all the difference and reduced lens swapping to a very large degree, it's for this reason that I'm interested in the Tamron. I just hope that it's IQ doesn't dissapoint.
I've been reading some user reports from people who have had both the Sigma and the Tamron and there is a gereral concencus that the Tamron is the better of the two, but the Pentax/Tokina definitely is regarded as the best, apart from maybe flare and CA, it's just such a pity that it's risen so much in price.
Fingers crossed that I will find the Tamron satisfactory.