RichardDay

Joined: 19th May 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

RichardDay
Having had a 16-45 for several years, initially on my istD, then K10D and then my current K20D, I have a real soft spot for this lens as I think that at it's current new price (which is about the same I paid for mine a few years ago! :shock it's a gem in the range. But I found the 45mm long end a limitation as I was cropping a lot of my shots taken at 45mm and that didn't help the quality that much! But overall I'm happy that I made the change to a DA 17-70.

I agree with Mhuni about the DA 17-70, if you get a good one , it's an excellent performer through it's whole range, but I have to be honest, my first one was a very poor copy and I "personally" know of quite a few that were similar and that would make me very wary of buying a s/h one unless I had the chance to test it beforehand. In fact this actually applies to any s/h lens unless I personally know its history, or the seller guarantees complete satisfaction.

At the current new pricing, I would now think twice about paying the extra £200+ for it over the 16-45, but it is a better built lens with a much more useful range and excellent bokeh.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 14/11/2009 - 20:13

RichardDay
nathanever82 wrote:
Ok, so if I use CS4, and ACR to convert my DNG's from the K7, which came after CS4. Do I have to update the colour profile for my DNG files from the K7?
The latest version of ACR (5.5) that works with Bridge/CS4 supports the K-7, you should have "Camera Standard" profile available in the choices offered, as well as "Embedded" and "Adobe Standard" if you open a camera generated (native) DNG.

For K-7 PEF's you will only have "Adobe Standard" and "Camera Standard"

Just make sure that you keep ACR updated - link

The K-x isn't currently supported, so probably just offers "Beta" with PEF files (as in LR3 beta). I don't have any K-x camera generated DNG files to check with, but I suspect that "Embedded" would be available as the profile should be contained in the DNG format, AFAIK only Adobe use the DNG embedded data with their Raw converters, other converters use separate sidecar files.

You can see the list of supported cameras here: link

Comment by RichardDay posted on Best raw conversion software? at 13/11/2009 - 12:34

RichardDay
MattMatic wrote:
Just to add to this thread:
I downloaded and tried DxO Optics Pro 6 as this promised better noise control.
Yuck! I took a fairly high ISO image from the K20D and it looked like utter mush - all smeary and horrible. Compared it with Silkypix Developer Studio Pro and that brought out so much more detail while still reducing the noise. The difference was unbelievable!

Saved me £70 as well

Matt
Totally agree with you there! UGH!

Been playing with LR v3 beta as well, still seems rather limited in comparison with SP Pro, but the IQ is pretty good now. But it lacks many useful tools that I regularly use in Silkypix Pro, plus some of the tools it does posses are clumsy in operation compared with SP Pro, the one that readily comes to mind is the CA correction facility, nothing compares with the SP eyedropper tool!

LR's only advantage as far as I can see is it's cataloguing ability (as SP Pro now has the ability to do non destructive editing and print directly with correct printing profiles), but then I use IDimager which is superb and can load any collection directly into SP when required. But if SP Pro didn't exist, I think it would be my preferred choice.

Haven't tried Bibble 5 beta yet, but the last versions kept crashing and the output IQ wasn't to my taste either.

Even though there is still room for improvement in SP Pro , IMHO it's definitely the leader of the pack at the moment.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Best raw conversion software? at 13/11/2009 - 12:10

RichardDay
SRS have new K20D's for £569 with 2 yr warranty and free P&P for forum members - link

Also, I've just had a word with Asahi Photo and they can do some repairs on K10D's, it depends on the problem, some repairs require special jigs and test equipment which is very expensive, which they don't have, but they are prepared to look and quote.

Also, with regard to any SDM failures out of warranty. They have done a few now and can replace failed motors for around the £65 mark.

Hope this helps.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Pentax Physiology at 12/11/2009 - 16:28

RichardDay
bladerunneruk wrote:


talking yourself into buying another lens, nooo !!!

I do rate the 16-45 having used it for a about two years, for many of the same reasons as yourself Richard (7 is great for candids !) wobbly barrel was always a bit disconcerting though.

Come to think of it the 24-90 I have is similarly 'loose?' build qual and web reports of 24-90 do seem to suggest it's build quality isn't top notch, so that's what I expected. It seems a bit hit and miss wrt IQ of pics I get which is what bugs me, I'm not sure I can trust it to get te job done, hence the angst. Perhaps I should go all scientific with it and give it the test chart treatment

I'm just hoping I could avoid buying 2 new lenses, fill the 45-60 gap with some overlap to the 60-250, and use it indoors for family and nieces&nephews in motion, hence the dilemma.

Thanks for taking the time to post.

PS how's that 60-250 working out for you, I remember the test pics when you got it ?
Yes, the 16-45 is a bit wobbly, but mine always stayed the same over many thousands of shots and 4 years of use.

The 24-90 is also a "loose" construction. I compared Steve Jacobs with my FA 28-105 f3.2-4.5 (which was also loose, but a bit less) and the latter was a bit more contrasty (which I liked) but the 24-90 was sharper overall and also across the frame. I suspect that yours needs a look at by Asahi Photo. Hopefully they would be able to fix it, Steve took his there recently for servicing, but they couldn't help it was knackered, so it's done for, apparently they weren't built that well.

I prefer the 17-70 for the usual reasons (bokeh, reach overlap etc.,) to partner with my 60-250 (yes, I'm very happy with it! ), I just wish it had the same IQ as the 60-250. I think that some ED glass, and stretched to 16mm would make it perfect, but I shudder to think how much more it would cost with Pentax's new (Rip-off?) pricing strategy!

Due to the increased barrel distortion, you lose a slight amount of FOV when you correct for it, and coupled with the loss of that all important 1mm, I'm looking more seriously at getting a wider lens, so I haven't avoided the need/desire for another lens . I would prefer a DA 12-24, but at £899 compared with the Tamron 10-24 at £359, I suspect I will get the Tamron if I can find a very good copy, I tried four on a D90 locally and one was a cracker, so they do exist! I just have to find one in Pentax mount, so it's off to SRS soon, probably next month.

Comment by RichardDay posted on the usual quandry at 11/11/2009 - 19:31

RichardDay
Okay, But it feels lighter! My mind's made up, please don't confuse me with any facts!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Pentax smc DA 16-45mm , should I sell? at 11/11/2009 - 14:24

RichardDay
iceblinker wrote:
The image quality of the Tamron 70-300 and Pentax 55-300 is very similar according to www.photozone.de. Please let us know if you find otherwise.
I've had both and preferred the 55-300 by a large margin. Reasons below

1. Extension down to 55mm makes an enormous difference.
2. Much better colour and overall IQ, it has that Pentax "pop" wheras the Tamron is rather flat and muddy and needs much more work in PP to get a really nice result.
3. As everyone acknowledges, no PF, CA I can live with but PF is a PITA.
4. Smaller and lighter, it's a great travel lens.
5. Nicely made.
6. The benefit of the so called "macro mode" of the Tamron is outweighed by the drawbacks.

As about everyone has said, sell the Sigma and Tamron and get the DA 55-300, seriously, it's easily the next best lens if you can't afford the DA*60-250.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Pentax smc DA 16-45mm , should I sell? at 11/11/2009 - 12:35

RichardDay
I would recommend that you stay with the DA 16-45 as the current price of the 17-70 is too much IMO.

I had the 16-45 (a very nice one) and bought a very good copy of a 17-70 after testing a couple of samples (as always! :wink.

Upon reflection it was a sideways move as I do miss the wide end of the 16-45 at times, plus the barrel distortion and CA of the 17-70 at 17mm is slightly worse, but the 17-70 is much sharper at 45mm.

Don't diss the 16-45, I still think that overall it's the best bet, but do go along to your friendly retailer and ensure that you get a decent copy that has no centering or focussing issues, it usually very easy to see on the review screen at x11.

I've tried a few samples of the Siggy 17-70, the Tamron 17-50 and the DA*16-50 (which is superb from 24mm up). I would rather have the 16-45 out of them all for various different reasons.

1. It's fairly light
2. It has very fast screw drive AF (I'm not that worried about SDM, but??? :roll
3. Quickshift manual focus overide.
4. I like the large zoom ring and small focus ring, unlike the DA*16-50.
5. 67mm filter, same as my 60-250.
6. Best wide end of any wide to medium zoom lens.
7. I actually quite like the reverse zoom action!

In fact, I've almost convinced myself to get another one soon, as I think it's a classic piece of Pentax glass.

Comment by RichardDay posted on the usual quandry at 11/11/2009 - 12:21

RichardDay
Father Ted wrote:
Hmmm..I'm looking at a CISS which claims to be for my printer, which is also an "All-in-one". I asked the question about ink lines as the scanner closes down over the print heads and has a slight overlap down the sides. The CISS company say this is ok as the tubes are only 3mm dia. and will fit.

This is the printer
http://www.epson.co.uk/Printers-and-All-In-Ones/Inkjet/Epson-Stylus-DX9400F

and this is the CISS
http://continuous-ink-system.co.uk/DX9400F_Ciss-continuous_ink_flow_system_for_E...

Any advice or tips on these would be gratefully received.
Hmmm, not too sure. My PX700W is similar in construction and there is definitely no room for the feed pipes. But if they guarantee it will work, then allright!

By the way, the DX9400F is not classified by Epson as a Photoprinter as it only uses 4 inks, the 6 ink and above printers are classified as Photoprinters. It will certainly produce reasonable prints, but not anywhere as good a 6+ ink machine.

Comment by RichardDay posted on DIY Printing at 09/11/2009 - 18:45

RichardDay
Father Ted wrote:
One thing mentioned about cartridge prices..I've recently discovered Continuous Ink Supply Systems ( CISS ).

Looking at getting one for my new Epson. The initial outlay is about £40,but that includes 100ml of ink. Ongoing running costs claim to be equivalent to about 50p per cartridge.
Even including the initial outlay, it claims the running caosts equate to 84p per cartridge.
Fotospeed have about the best CISS, I've used one on an Epson R300 for around 3 years with no real problems, I also had it profiled by them and that made a big difference.

Unfortunately, my R300 died recently and I bought an Epson PX700W "all in one" photo printer as a replacement for it and an older Epson "all in one" that also threw it's legs into the air. The bad news was that I cannot use a CISS with the new printer as you cannot get access to the ink tanks with the lid closed, I suspect that this was deliberate by Epson!

As I don't print many shots these days, so my ink usage has diminished dramatically, but I still do a few occasionally. I now use a local or on line photo lab for family prints and for quality or large prints I use DS Colour Labs (DSCL) as recommended by some fellow forum members.

Comment by RichardDay posted on DIY Printing at 09/11/2009 - 12:08

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo