McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
OK, so now for some Pixel Cross Talk !

I think its long been known and understood that modern lenses, like our DA range, are somehow 'optimised' for the digital sensors that they are designed to work with, and thanks Daroni for providing that informative document which really details the science behind it. It explains some of the issue relating to colour rendition and fringing that we often see when using older lenses.

I'd be cautious though in trying to draw too strong and definite conclusions though .... I find your 'rules' above about not using any wide angles, but only telephotos, as really counter-productive and unhelpful overall. We don't choose and use lenses based exclusively on scientific factors, we base our choice on a range of common sense and practical considerations ...

Not the least is the cost / performance ratio! Many older lenses deliver such a massive bang per buck today that to dis-regard them would be ridiculous and short sighted. I have no doubt that both my SMC A 28 and 50mm primes, and my SMC F35-70, will display some of the negative characteristics referred to in that document, when used on a DSLR. I am aware of small amounts of fringing in normal lighting, and higher amounts in backlighting where contrast is also affected ..... but the sheer quality, visual impact, sharpness and pleasure of using them, plus the huge amounts of all this they deliver for the price, vastly outweighs my concerns over the fringing or any colour issues.

In practice the only lens where I've had trouble correcting a colour issue is with the A28mm in strong backlighting conditions with the light directed mainly into the lens ... here I've had purple / yellowy tones that have proved hard to correct. But in all other conditions this and the other film era lenses perform beautifully, and I'd be mad to not use them.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 01/02/2015 - 10:18

McGregNi
I'd get a K3, the Tamron and the converter, and sell the K5.... Absolutely no doubt about it! That's plenty of future proofing with that sensor, plus the converter will have uses on other lenses in the future. More compact as well than carrying the two telezooms.

Comment by McGregNi posted on dilemma at 31/01/2015 - 21:31

McGregNi
I'm sure you'll enjoy using it once getting used to it ...I have the newer autofocus version (f35-70) and that is a cracking little lens. The custom setting in the camera menu is to allow the camera to fire with a lens without an A setting or an A lens not set to A. The default is to prevent the camera firing when the lens is not on A in order to avoid exposure errors by an unwary user, as auto-exposure will not work.

In your case, with your lens set to A, all should be fine, and you can control aperture from your normal e-dial. The camera will meter normally as it receives aperture information from the lens. Good luck and let us know how it goes ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on One Lens to travel? at 31/01/2015 - 19:53

McGregNi
Ok, so just to confirm, is it the SMC A 35-70 as in your earlier post, or a 17-35 as you mention just above?

Once it is locked in place then it should work without further custom settings.... Check that the aperture ring is firmly set to the A position ... There's sometimes a click -lock to hold this position. Now you should have aperture control from the camera e-dial.

Comment by McGregNi posted on One Lens to travel? at 31/01/2015 - 15:24

McGregNi
You may be limiting your options with your 'professional' restriction. Do you not want to talk with talented or experienced amateurs? Perhaps if you asked for specific Pentax or photography advice you would get good input from people with a wide range of experiences and knowledge?

Comment by McGregNi posted on I want to speak to professional photographer at 31/01/2015 - 13:33

McGregNi
In your earlier post you specified the lens from ebay as being an 'SMC Pentax A f3.5-4.5 35-70' ... If this is correct and what you in fact have actually received, then it IS a k-mount lens ... The A designation refers to its model as having an aperture ring with an 'A' position for auto exposure control from the camera. So it is an A series Pentax lens, which is fully compatable with all Pentax DSLR's ..... It is manual focus though.

Have you actually tried it on your camera?

Comment by McGregNi posted on One Lens to travel? at 31/01/2015 - 13:21

McGregNi
I have never found colour cast issues with the Cokin P system, so I'd be happy to recommend it for a good value ND grad and CP solution. Not sure if you'll get big enough for the ultra-wide with Cokin though ....

In my most recent landscape experience with the 14mm Samyang (which can't take filters) I have found I manage fine with a software polariser effect (Sagelight 4.0) and shooting exposures for sky and ground to be blended in Photoshop. But I accept for longer focal lengths that glass filters would offer a high quality solution.

The issue with polarisers at very wide angles is uneven brightness across a big sky which is very tricky to balance in processing. I find my software filter effect very easy and precisely adjustable.

Comment by McGregNi posted on A question for the landscape photographers or anyone using Flters at 31/01/2015 - 13:04

McGregNi
You can use the timer, yes, bit there's something more satisfying about having the control in your hand, something physically connecting you at the moment of capture.

Even though I might fine focus using live view, I tend to switch back to viewfinder mode to take the actual shots (don't need to actually look into the viewfinder then of course, I look over the camera into the scene). This is a good approach if shooting a number of exposures as it saves battery power ... Once focused up you don't need live view any more. Then I use the first press of the remote to raise the mirror (mirror up mode) , pause, deep breath , then another press to capture.

Comment by McGregNi posted on A question for the landscape photographers or anyone using Flters at 30/01/2015 - 17:12

McGregNi
Yes, add the Tamron AF70-300 Di LD macro to those available in KAF mount that cover a FF image circle ... So they are ready and waiting for your new FF Pentax camera!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Why are 3rd party manufactures turning away from Pentax ? at 30/01/2015 - 16:51

McGregNi
Excellent advice Jules avoid those too dark overly filtered storm clouds!

Comment by McGregNi posted on A question for the landscape photographers or anyone using Flters at 30/01/2015 - 15:56

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo