All Forum Comments
Comment by McGregNi posted on New Pentax FF ..image released on PhotoRumors? at 05/02/2015 - 09:07
I do emphasise though that it is in limited, backlit conditions, that I've seen this though ... not generally a problem. I do accept the point about critical, technical subjects and higher magnifications. You do mention large crops, and I'm never really doing that .... I would have thought most general photography is generally framed up fairly accurately at capture .... I find I rarely crop more than 15% of my image area.
Most of the commentary here has been of the view that these matters are not significant for general photography ... not enough to outweigh all the other positives to using these old lenses, and this is the view I take also. I think each lens will have to be weighed up individually, matched both to a particular camera, photographers output needs, and subject / genre. IN general though I expect the vast majority of Pentax users will keep valuing their special film-era glass and finding excellent uses for it.
I do also believe that CA is still an issue on many modern lenses as well, and we have to choose carefully regardless of the age of the design. For example, my (fairly) modern Tamron AF70-300 Di LD is well known for purple fringing. (I don't know if it is tele-centric, but it does have modern coatings and optical design). I have found I can control it easily though and remove noticeable artefacts.
Finally Daroni ... remember that I have been asking about processed and 'corrected' images from these lenses ... you don't refer to processing techniques and you don't mention whether these issues at higher output sizes are visible only when not corrected in processing .... I would always apply removal techniques (or reduction) to obvious CA before anyway .... if this is successful is it not the case that it would really remove things enough that they are nothing to worry about even for critical applications at large output?
I've been examining this and asking for image analysis on my other thread .... link .... here I've put links to some images on the PU gallery, all taken with FF film era lenses, for examination. I'm asking if they display any of the defects we are concerned about, and whether these shots would suffer with these lenses if the new FF body was used ....??? Daroni, I'd be very grateful if you could take a look and see what you think.
Thanks for the invite for the conversation ... lets see what can be resolved here, and I may well be speaking to you!
Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 05/02/2015 - 08:47
A Full Frame digital camera will have the same mount as the current aps-c models, so the compatibility continues .... that's something that is great about Pentax!
There are differences in the mount and lens technologies over the years (K, KAF, KAF 2 etc) and these are to do with various electronic contacts that added extra functions over the years. But the oldest film era K lenses will still work on all (D)SLR bodies, with some reduced metering functionality in the case of the oldest lenses. This situation will be the same for the new FF SLR.
In fact we are all waiting with baited breath to see what the image quality from old film-era lenses will be like once we get them onto a new FF body .... a matter subject to great debate right here on PU!!
The film - era lenses will project their full image circle onto the FF sensor, therefore revealing the outer edges of the glass's performance, which has all been not visible on the aps-c cameras as the sensor is smaller than the image circle projected onto the sensor .... that is what is meant by 'crop' in this case.
Comment by McGregNi posted on full frame with old lenses at 05/02/2015 - 07:45
Comment by McGregNi posted on New Pentax FF ..image released on PhotoRumors? at 05/02/2015 - 06:36
My Pentax SR has always done wondrous things ... I've recently been able to shoot with my new Tamron (FF lens!) at 300 mm, handheld, in dim daylight at ISO 400 (still good quality on the K7) getting great sharp shots at 1/100th sec ... Very pleased with that!
Comment by McGregNi posted on The Unicorn is ready to be set free (FF)! at 05/02/2015 - 06:29
Comment by McGregNi posted on New Pentax FF ..image released on PhotoRumors? at 05/02/2015 - 06:19
There's nothing yet to suggest from the image that this will be anything apart from a traditional Pentax - styled DSLR, continuing the styling and feature developments on from the K3 /645z models. We'd expect slightly bigger than K3. So not a mirrorless or retro style (I'm glad!).
I assume the crop-mode would require a viewfinder magnification adjustment? Is that all that would be needed, a control to switch the magnification for the different lens image circles ... Is that a practical thing ? I assume it would have to be a manual user operated switch ....
Exciting times (and expensive ones? ) ahead! Now, I'd better get my microscope out and start looking at those images from my FF lenses carefully!
Comment by McGregNi posted on New Pentax FF ..image released on PhotoRumors? at 05/02/2015 - 05:50
As someone who has specifically acquired some film-era lenses, both for use now and thinking towards a future FF body, I have been really interested in this topic. Whilst I have been very happy at the performance of these lenses on the K7, the question has always been there about whether they will also perform well on a FF body .... both because the edges of the lenses will be used (on aps-c it is obviously a cropped view) and the question of lens deficiencies being 'shown up' under the full glare of a higher resolution / bigger sensor ... (this is the kind of issue that is being discussed in Daroni's thread - things like CA and colour rendition).
I have argued (along with some others) that these issues are not significant when weighed against the other great positive aspects of using the beautiful old lenses. But, putting them onto a new FF body is another matter, and it remains to be seen ....
But I would love to have some expert opinion and an idea what to expect .... don't want my hopes to be dashed when I realise that once I've got the body then I'll need to spend thousands more on new lenses. So I've got a selection of my images taken with my old lenses ... these are all images that I'm pleased with and feel the IQ was great, at least with the K7.
Could I ask you all to take a look (some may be familiar) at these images .... I've linked to PU gallery files for the best view .... and have a close look. I'd love to know the answer to two questions.... would these shots have any obvious optical issues if taken on a FF camera where the edge of the glass is in fact being used (bearing in mind the apertures are mostly fairly stopped down) ... and looking at what you can see, is it likely that other image degradations will show up and become an issue were these shots taken on FF (assuming the same processing and optimisation as I have done) ??
If you think there would be problems, is it likely to be so much that I'd definitely need new FF lenses ?? Or is it likely to be acceptable and involve just some extra or changed processing approaches ??
The lenses are of course my 80's M and A series ones, the F 35-70, plus the 70's Tamron Adaptall .... (all very budget really!)
Here's the images ... very grateful any thoughts on these lens technical IQ matters ....
link
link
link
link
link
link
link
link
link
Thanks for having a look and any comments on the IQ aspects and the matters I raised earlier.
Comment by McGregNi posted on Film Era Lenses - Image Assessments Please at 04/02/2015 - 18:26
My main question now though is related to the 'size of output' issue. Daroni, you are quite right in your points about the majority of image outputs now .... yes, the mass of images are only ever seen on Smartphone screens now, and then even us enthusiasts will see most of our images only on a computer monitor.
Am I right then in understanding that you are saying that the lens deficiencies you are concerned about (those that are inherent in older film era designs) would generally only be noticeable on larger quality prints, say for exhibition. Or do you feel that would be significant (with high resolution sensors) even when viewed at a good size on a decent monitor?
I ask, because I am really interested in processing and image optimising, and I try and carefully remove the effects of any CA or fringing, and correct any colour issues if needed. My own experience with large prints (quite a number on my walls at 75x100 cm) is that I simply don't see anything more on the prints than I do on the computer (using the same file as that sent to the printer). The only time I am aware of CA (mostly purple / blue fringing for me) is by zooming in to 200+% and peering closely along fine edges and the like. Usually a pull down down on the magenta channel and a compensating rise on the luminance slider deals with it (the after-effects can usually just be noticed) ..... Its now gone as far as I am concerned.
But when printing these images to 75x100mm as well, there is no exaggeration or magnification of these after-effects that I can see .... the images, from normal viewing distance, look exactly the same as on the monitor (slightly softer usually). So it is hard for me to understand really that this type of lens deficiency is really significant in a large printed form either (assuming good processing of course). Or am I missing something else ? Are there other types of issue that older 'non-telecentric' designs will cause that will be become obvious at 75x100cm?
Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 04/02/2015 - 14:25
Comment by McGregNi posted on Learn to use flash by the weekend? at 03/02/2015 - 17:35


Now, with a FF body, that presumably will be the same .... the magnification will be set to give us 100% of the image in the actual frame. But, put an aps-c lens onto the FF body .... the viewfinder is the same ..... surely because the aps-c lens projects a smaller image circle, will we not in fact see the vignetting and dark areas around the edges in the viewfinder ? And does this issue not mean that with those aps-c lenses the viewfinder magnification has to 'zoom' in a bit in order to correctly fill the viewfinder with the reduced image frame (100% view of the 'cropped' frame) ?