McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I can only echo that Will ... In almost every way I see my F35-70 as an ' upgrade' to my DA 18-55 AL WR (of course with the combined focal lengths it's also an extension to the kit lens).

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 03/02/2015 - 16:00

McGregNi
Would the limiting factor with film era prints not have been more the film itself, rather than lens design technicalities? I do accept that very high resolution and large digital sensors might be unforgiving of lower quality old glass. Clearly we all have to choose carefully. I myself have raised many times my own hopes for using my modest collection of old (and new) FF lenses oh a future Pentax body ... But I realise this may be a forlorn hope ..(sure is sounding more and more like it now!

But the reality is, I won't be able to afford the camera PLUS a new collection of FF modern digital optimised lenses, not at once certainly. So I'll have to make the most of what I've got. What I've got packs a lot of punch for the money .. The question is, would it be better to use the old glass for all its great qualities on a FF body and deal with the aberrations where needed, or keep limiting their use to a much lesser sensor like the K7?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 03/02/2015 - 14:16

McGregNi
VividArt wrote:


I do believe that the lenses I tried were flawed. I do see your logical view of work flow, the questions are good, but please lets get past the "user error" part and get on with it

Regards, JMD
That's fine, we can only go by what you write. I admit I am still puzzled though, because you said the problem was saturation, but you keep mentioning camera settings (MTF, aperture, ISO, shutter speed) that will not influence saturation to any significant degree (perhaps extreme high ISO might reduce saturation a little). Metering may have a little impact, for example, a little underexposure can increase saturation for certain subjects, and macro would fit into that category.

But in general none of these settings would have the effect on saturation you're worried about. That's the reason the questioning might seem aimed a bit low . In any case, I love saturation, so I doubt I would complain if my macros were too colourful

Comment by McGregNi posted on 50 mm macro 2.8 and 100 mm wr macro over saturating at 03/02/2015 - 09:35

McGregNi
I could only go based on what you first wrote .... there was little information frankly apart from the reference to MTF and other settings. So what a few of us have said is logical really .... now you have said you shoot RAW , so in fact what relevance has the camera Natural Setting got, or indeed any camera custom settings? You mentioned 'Natural setting' so exploring the other custom controls (especially saturation is the obvious suggestion) .... but you're shooting RAW anyway! The colour problems could therefore come from the RAW processing side as well then.

I never intend to offend, only help .... if you really want quality advice then why not just work with us to narrow it down?

Comment by McGregNi posted on 50 mm macro 2.8 and 100 mm wr macro over saturating at 03/02/2015 - 08:31

McGregNi
A working professional will have different requirements to enthusiasts for many situations ... and different budgets as well. I can well see that the latest coatings and AF technologies will be important to those who need the fastest and most reliable performance, particularly in more dynamic people oriented work.

But really, when I asked about whether light convergence was a worry, I mean that the effects of it (with older lenses) will not be the primary concern or interest to anyone when choosing and comparing. We all look at the overall results, resolution and sharpness being one of the main factors, as well as 'contrast' matters and physical handling / weight issues, and autofocus performance. Those are the things you see discussed endlessly on forum threads about lenses ... including professionals.

Daroni, you speak a lot about image quality matters in relation to old lenses, but you are not very specific about what exactly are the problems you worry about. I've mentioned purple fringing and contrast in backlighting with my 28mm .... but these are limited problems in limited situations. The vast majority of CA problems I've encountered, both with old film-era glass and modern ones, can be dealt with successfully with minimal PP effort ... or they're insignificant at any normal viewing size so not worth bothering about.

If its not these small matters that you are making such a fuss about, what exactly is it? Can you show comparative examples of old and new glass with the same scene? Most of us love and appreciate the qualities of the old lenses we treasure, both for the high amounts of IQ and bang per buck they deliver.

I accept Gary's point above from the view of a professional who has to get through hundreds of shots every week maybe, and can't be worrying about processing and removing any small abberations. But I suspect that for most pros the main concerns will be for reliability, handling, sharpness, AF performance ... much like the rest of us .... and they won't care what era the lens is from so long as it delivers those things as needed.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 03/02/2015 - 08:20

McGregNi
VividArt wrote:
...

I spent quite a bit of time with the 50mm, every shot was over saturated. The camera was set to natural, mtf (tried all settings) and no other internal processing. Eventually I just got rid of it. The colors were just wrong. The same experience with the 100mm WR, colors way off. Is it me or have others had the same experience? I have had this experience with tamron lenses as well. JMD
I do find this strange .... are you sure you are looking at things from the right angle? You mention 2 Pentax lenses as well Tamron lenses as having the saturation and colour issues ... is it really likely to be the lenses that are the issue?

You mention settings ... MTF and 'tried all settings' . MTF in the program line will simply give you an optimal aperture setting in P mode ... this will not affect colours or saturation. What other settings have you tried? You mentioned a custom image preset of natural, which makes sense if you don't want too saturated. Can you confirm all the other custom sliders were at zero?

I'm assuming you were happy with all other aspects of the macro lens performance ? If so, I cannot understand why you would get rid of lenses as a solution .... did you consider reducing the saturation a little using the custom image saturation control? And have you checked some images on different monitors? You'll need to address all these issues before you can resolve any concerns about colours and saturation.

Comment by McGregNi posted on 50 mm macro 2.8 and 100 mm wr macro over saturating at 03/02/2015 - 07:59

McGregNi
I don't think a lens is capable of being ' oversaturated' by definition .... Nor unsaturated. That is the result of the camera sensor and processing really.

Comment by McGregNi posted on 50 mm macro 2.8 and 100 mm wr macro over saturating at 03/02/2015 - 05:31

McGregNi
Sure Gary, but I'm thinking when you say modern lenses for press work, you mean speed and accuracy, you're not really worrying about the angles that light rays hit the sensor are you?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 02/02/2015 - 19:15

McGregNi
A little bit of a mixed bag .... still working through photographs from my Dorset trip last summer, and here I have made a little selection of typical marine based subjects from around the Poole Harbour & Studland bay areas.

All with the K7 and lenses as detailed with each photo .....


1) Old Harry Rocks , DA 18-55mm AL WR

Comment Image





2) Boat Life in Poole Harbour 1, SMC M75-150mm f4

Comment Image





3) Knoll Beach, Studland Bay, Samyang 14mm f2.8 UMC ED IF

Comment Image





4) Boat Life in Poole Harbour 2, SMC M75-150mm f4

Comment Image





5) Boat Life in Poole Harbour 3, SMC M75-150mm f4

Comment Image





6) The Cathedral Rock, SMC M75-150mm f4

Comment Image





7) The Pinnacle & Cathedral from Handfast Point, SMC M75-150mm

Comment Image


Hope they are enjoyable and spread a little ray of sunlight into our winter (UK at least!)

Comment by McGregNi posted on Some Marine Scenes at 02/02/2015 - 17:10

McGregNi
I think that, again, any serious photographer, including a Pro wedding or any other type , will simply look at the usefulness, reputation, cost and then actual image output in making any lens choice. If an old film era lens delivers the goods for professional work then it will get used. PP work will be needed for lenses of all ages, it may just be different things, whether a little more CA removal for one or a little more distortion correction for another.

Where I can see an obvious benefit for a professional, or indeed anyone shooting in bulk generally, is where modern digital optimised lens offer in-camera auto corrections for CA and distortion. This will cut down on PP work and is very practical, and not available on older lenses in general. But then again, it only applies to camera Jpegs, so again, maybe not significant for professionals?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can we use a film camera lens (conventional) on a digital SLR where a telecentric lens is optimal (current) at 02/02/2015 - 15:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo