All Forum Comments
Comment by McGregNi posted on When reality (apparently) isn't enough at 02/02/2015 - 14:09
Comment by McGregNi posted on Three Little Corgi's with three BIG beverages at 02/02/2015 - 13:55
....
It is, to my mind, significantly different to most editing and processing routines -- not perhaps in principle but certainly in degree. It is surely one thing to accentuate the appearance of clouds (to take a mundane example), quite another the import an 'improved' sky.
I guess others will find it hard to agree with this viewpoint......
1) that which COULD have been captured by the camera at the time (ie by taking different exposures, or using filter techniques, slow shutter times, or lens optical effects) and
2) that image content that could NOT have been captured by the camera (ie places where the camera and photographer had never been, or had only been to at different times, or where different objects and elements were not together in the same arrangement at one time)
For No 1) I would say that any image editing and adjustment part of normal and expected processing work (eg any blending of exposures, levels, contrast, colour optimisations) ... and this stuff would not demand any sort of explanation or 'honesty' from the photographer. It is part of parcel of normal expected image optimising work.
For No 2) then clearly it should reasonably be expected that the creator would be honest and describe the processes and it would be understood that the output is more a form of 'digital art' with photographic material than an actual 'photograph'
And to extend this rules and definition .... No1 above would be called a Photograph ... No2 would not.
Now surely that is fair and must be adopted as a general standard?
Comment by McGregNi posted on When reality (apparently) isn't enough at 02/02/2015 - 12:35
Comment by McGregNi posted on When reality (apparently) isn't enough at 02/02/2015 - 09:40
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Sensor Cleaning Kit O-ICK1 at 02/02/2015 - 08:14
Also, is it window light from the right side only, our is there any fill - in also?
Comment by McGregNi posted on Three Little Corgi's with three BIG beverages at 01/02/2015 - 19:16
Comment by McGregNi posted on One Lens to travel? at 01/02/2015 - 19:11
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Sensor Cleaning Kit O-ICK1 at 01/02/2015 - 17:51
No, it's not 'A' photograph, but rather a digital art creation with the component source material coming from photographs , and it is in the style of advertising imagery. If it is for that purpose, or an artistic reproduction of that style for artistic commentary, then it is successful. But it would not compete with or stand valid comparison with a ' photograph' of child in a front lit poppy field, as that would be something completely different.
Comment by McGregNi posted on When reality (apparently) isn't enough at 01/02/2015 - 17:44
link
I've been reading through a few forum threads about sensor cleaning. Clearly there's different opinions on the techniques and type of equipment best used. The Pentax kit has generally been regarded as expensive, but effective. Most of the discussions are about good cheaper alternatives. I decided to play safe and go for the manufacturer's recommended option! The discount made it a little easier though !
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Sensor Cleaning Kit O-ICK1 at 01/02/2015 - 11:39


Regarding centrality, then something that is integral to the photo, say a fairground carousal ... Now in most places that would not be permanent, but I would be unlikely to clone it out because by its very nature it is likely to have centrality to the image.
So, in summary ... I will happily clone out non-permanent objects that do not have centrality interest. Those definitions and criteria make up my analysis and final decision.