McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
It might prove an effective technique I feel with this .... I'd be looking for maybe around 2 stops underexposure on the ambient. There's not much trouble to flash-light this subject as he's all on his own, so there shouldn't be any shadow problems, although I guess some sort of diffuser on the flash head would help.

I like the 2nd one very much as there's more power in the face through it being more in the light and front -on. You've done very well with the OOF effect, it's just that that bright and colourful background is a real challenge!

Comment by McGregNi posted on In his face at 28/02/2015 - 04:00

McGregNi
Its a compelling subject, and the narrow depth of field is appropriate. Unfortunately the very bight and complex OOF background on the right acts only as a major distraction. It pulls attention away from the face, which is also not helped by being mostly in shadow.

I think this either needed a different shooting angle with only sea in behind, or if not possible then I think technically its a classic case where some HSS flash would do the trick, with the background brightness pulled right down with underexposure, and the flash lighting the face ... this should also even out the contrast on the face. Its an idea perhaps worth trying if you get another chance .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on In his face at 28/02/2015 - 01:53

McGregNi
As I said earlier, the indications from the exif data that Steve showed on the other thread were that EC was at 0, and metering mode was multipattern. The photographer has not indicated that he has made any user adjustments for his shots ... Indeed, his aim appears to be to take advantage of the fully automatic aspects of the K3.

Assuming that EC is at 0, there is one custom setting which could affect the exposure and that is like a master brightness control ... On the K7 it has a half black, half white circle, and takes quite a drastic effect on global brightness .... Worth checking all the custom image settings Bruce. The exif showed all these at zero, but I was surprised by this as I thought each master preset had a set of particular individual slider default settings ... The preset in the case of the tabletop image was 'landscape', and again, the photographer has never said if he has ever made any changes at all to any of these settings.

Looking at the images on the gallery, they all contain significant areas of what would have been very bright sky ... Is it possible that Bruce has been including a lot of sky when he's half-pressing and getting the metering, but then moves down to the dark ground to take the shot, and the exposure value is staying low as for the sky ... ? Bruce, how are you physically moving when taking the shots ... Is it possible you're pointing the camera upwards first, then down to take the actual shot?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 26/02/2015 - 03:10

McGregNi
Ah, didn't spot that mistake earlier .... It was a K50 , sorry.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Upgrading at 25/02/2015 - 22:31

McGregNi
I do think there are significant gains from the newer technologies ... Certainly the Prime Processors have come on a lot since the time of the KR, and this has advantages not only in JPEG image processing sophistications but also in shooting speeds as everything is processed quicker and the camera won't freeze so early during bursts.

Peterkr made a strong case for the upgrade earlier with some good points about practicalities .... Anything that encourages more time out using a camera and experimenting will lead to better photos! With the deals available , especially when bundled with a nice new lens (as Peter took advantage of) it's a win win situation ...

Autofocus and the quietness of operation has improved a lot also ...I picked up a K0 last year in a shop and took a few shots with the attached 18-55, and was impressed at the faster focussing and quieter operation over my K7.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Upgrading at 25/02/2015 - 21:19

McGregNi
Actually, I'd be happy with a very limited and Pentax specific range of cameras settings data. This is exactly what PDCU offers, but a much smaller, handier dedicated viewing tool would be even better.

Nobody needs to read any thread if they're not interested ... That's the great choice we have. But its good to know there's plenty of interest there in the background ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax DSLR EXIF Data in Different Programmes at 25/02/2015 - 19:27

McGregNi
SteveLedger wrote:
McGregNi wrote:
I think its good for us Pentax Users to use the actual Pentax camera terms ...
I think you're going to have to bit a bit more flexible along with the rest of us, Nigel as we can't all use PDCU exif simply because that software is not supplied with all Pentax models.
But again I must stress, the EXIFtool extracts 'verbatim' only what is present in the image file itself.
I understand that not everyone can use PDCU, and anyway, it's hardly efficient to start it up just to check image metadata! I really think we need a dedicated and handy Pentax specific metadata viewer that can read and nicely present ALL our camera data and exact settings.

No, I'm not trying to get everyone to use PDCU ...I just mean that for a common understanding we ideally want to use the actual camera setting value references ...eg ' your high contrast setting was at minus 2 .... I'd try much higher there, perhaps plus 2 ...'

As it stands we end up with these genetic and odd references to things like 'hard', or ' 'normal'' (for exposure mode whatever that means!), and this is a confusing way to share understanding of our camera settings ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 25/02/2015 - 19:08

McGregNi
I'm glad you've joined the debate ! Yes, as you've shown here, this exif issue IS complex .... It was my realisation of this that made me promote the discussion here amongst Pentax photographers . It's a discussion and raising of questions, more so than a research exercise, which is not my interest.

My interest is in gaining a general understanding of where we have to be cautious about the validity of this information, especially when trying to interpret it with a view to improved camera operation.

What I have seen so far is a very unclear picture. It seems that an ' extraction' tool , as Steve has shown' contains the most detail, although there needs to be specialised knowledge I think about which items to use. Third party editing software has to be treated carefully I feel, as I am not seeing any of these programs presenting a complete and accurate record of our Pentax DSLR settings ... Certainly when we start seeing all these references like ' hard', 'high' or ' 'normal'' , we have to be very suspicious of their actual meaning in terms of our camera settings.

Bye the way, when I referred to 0 as the centre, I mean it is the centre position of the camera control sliders, and then are minus 4 and plus 4 positions either side of this centre 0. The advantage I find of PDCU (if available for your camera) is that it exactly presents every data field in this exact same format, so this makes it very easy to quickly take in and understand what was set on the camera. I wish we had a dedicated Pentax information tool that would do this for all of our cameras ... The nice thing is it strips out all the extra unneeded detail and confusing contradictions, making it a most practical tool to support image settings understanding.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax DSLR EXIF Data in Different Programmes at 25/02/2015 - 18:47

McGregNi
I think its good for us Pentax Users to use the actual Pentax camera terms ...

Looking at the exif data from the original tabletop shot, (data posted in the other 'exif' thread), this shows exposure compensation as 0 and metering mode as ' multi-pattern'. I must say though with all the close focussing on different exif viewers, I'm finding any apart from PDCU to be presenting a rather confusing and contradictory picture .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 25/02/2015 - 08:57

McGregNi
One other thing I see in the data from the K3 shot, there are two different ISO figures ...1600 in the exif section , and 2500 in the MakerNotes section ..... What does that mean??

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax DSLR EXIF Data in Different Programmes at 25/02/2015 - 08:51

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo