McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I spotted this, a very interesting interview conducted by Dave Etchells on the Imaging-Resource website. It is very upbeat, and also gives far more insight into the 'strategy' behind the planning and release of recent models than we usully get. A good read for all Pentax users ....

(Apologies if its been posted before and I've missed it)

..... imaging-resource news ....link

Comment by McGregNi posted on Mr. Kasunobu Saiki from Ricoh, Interview at 05/03/2015 - 21:07

McGregNi
There's plenty of good ideas to try .... Personally I'd advise, to start with, try and avoid any tricky scene that might demand bracketing ... Keep it simple to something in clear even light, no sky, keep the camera pointed straight into the scene , no exposure compensation, just click and see what the camera makes of it. In P mode with multi-pattern metering set we should get a good result.

Post the image Bruce with a description of how you took the shot and confirm the basic settings for us.

If it seems that the camera might need a test of its metering performance, then the white wall shot as Alan suggested it's a great idea ... There's been so many variables and confusion over how your images have been taken and with what settings, that I don't think there's yet any firm reason to suspect any metering fault.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K3...new thread...is it just me?...looks like.. at 05/03/2015 - 12:21

McGregNi
Yes it's pre-production. I'd expect the final version to be a bit less plasticky.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax FF First Look? at 04/03/2015 - 19:18

McGregNi
I do think you've set yourself quite a challenge Bruce ... the K3 is a difficult choice of machine if you want to learn about the fundamentals of photography shooting techniques. But then again, it does give every possiblility you might want to explore ....

I appreciate that the discussion on exif data was very detailed, and that is why I specificially deverted it off onto a different thread. But it was not 'off-topic' to your question .... we were trying to understand what custom image settings you were using in the absense of any input from yourself.

You didn't respond previously to my points about metering, so I'll say it again .... most of the images you've posted are very challenging in terms of their contrast and dynamic range. They mostly all have large areas of great brightness. If the camera light meter is seeing a lot of this very bright light (for example if you were pointing the camera upwards a little so that a lot of that light was being seen driectly by the camera) then this will result in the underexposure you're having.

In order to eliminate this possibility, I'd try to shoot a few frames of the exact same scene, firstly pointing the camera upwards to the brightness, then pointing it downwards to the darker areas for the next shot. The exposures should be quite different for each. Tell us what you did and post the results here. (When you press and hold the shutter button halfway to focus its probable that the exposure is being held as well).

Its great that you're keeping on trying ... we all here want people to get great results from their Pentax cameras. You've made the odd few comments, like this one
BruceStrachan wrote:
.... I took´all the advice switched off pretty much everything and have went to manual WB, and it seems my K3 is ok but needs an extra 2 or 3 stops on WB to provide good results.
.....
which suggest you are misunderstanding some fundamental aspects of the camera operations, and my advice would be to get a good book on digital / DSLR photography and get stuck into it .... the time spent doing that will be extremely rewarding.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K3...new thread...is it just me?...looks like.. at 04/03/2015 - 16:06

McGregNi
Yes, I think that is the highest you would need. In fact even 200 would be fine for up to medium sizes.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Setting the DPI at 04/03/2015 - 11:15

McGregNi
I'm only an occasional jpeg shooter , sometimes from a workflow point of view I find it convenient ...(I regard it as a type of efficient batch processing) . But when I do use the option, as everyone knows, I always advocate taking very firm and positive control through the custom image settings .

When I do this by pulling the sliders around I find there is really quite a lot of control, easily enough to produce punch and print-ready output ... I'd say that plus 4 on the sharpness slider, and plus 2 or 3 on the fine sharpness' ones will give us something ready to print.

There's every possibility that out DSLR jpeg output can be made into ' point and shoot''.

Comment by McGregNi posted on To trade or not to trade at 03/03/2015 - 15:35

McGregNi
Out of interest, do any of the Pentax smaller sensor models also share this more aggressive jpeg processing character and provide that punchier, print ready output? (I'm thinking of the Q series, MX1, X5 for example ) .... Or do they share a sort of common Pentax style of output, like the DSLRs, and need further work on a computer, or at least more direct control via the custom settings if that's preferred ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on To trade or not to trade at 03/03/2015 - 13:58

McGregNi
So you see it as essentially about the cameras image processing characteristics, really about the internal software .... And I think you're also implying that the default starting points of these compact camera processing characteristics is more aggressive so as to be really ' print ready' ... Presumably this contrasts with our DSLRs where the default , middle position '0' settings for jpeg processing are much less aggressive, more attuned to output we would then fine tune more on a computer ..... ?

This is presumably the cause of some confusion with newer DSLR users who see this contrast and perceive the DSLR to be not as good, or faulty even, than a point and shoot they are comparing with.

Comment by McGregNi posted on To trade or not to trade at 03/03/2015 - 13:47

McGregNi
It depends also on what exactly is on our minds when we hear ' point and shoot' ... There's a lot of talk here about size and weight, but to me what I think of first is about automation and getting quick and easy snapshot type images with really no controls to worry about on the camera ... That's what point and shoot means to me really ....

We have that other thread about the K3 where the new owner seemed to be wanting ' point and shoot' type results from his very sophisticated DSLR. For me, I think of the green mode on my camera as ' point and shoot Mode' . The book I have on the k7 describes this green mode as ' the one you set when handing your camera to a complete novice for a few snaps'. In green mode there are almost no camera controls you can change, the decisions are entirely left up to the cameras brain. So this to me is the meaning of ' point and shoot', and even our big sophisticated DSLR's offer it ...(the ultimate versatile imaging machines )

Having said all that I haven't ever actually set the green mode! So I don't even know if its any good ... Maybe I should try it more, it might actually improve my photos

So, my question ... If ' point and shoot' is about automation and ease, would we not get the best results then from our DSLRs on green mode rather than a small sensor in a compact camera ... Or us there something about the very small cameras that must makes their auto output seem better?

Comment by McGregNi posted on To trade or not to trade at 03/03/2015 - 12:22

McGregNi
MattMatic wrote:
As with everything - the right tool for the job

Matt
Yes, and that's why I always promote our Pentax DSLR's .... Extraordinary versatility, both in control options to aid picture taking and image output choices, plus the massive choice in high quality optics of all sizes ... It DSKEs really can be the right tool for every job!

Come on, really, how small does a camera need to be?

I agree with Bills warning above about IQ ... Go smaller than APS-C for sensor and I feel the compromises start to add up .

Comment by McGregNi posted on To trade or not to trade at 02/03/2015 - 17:27

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo