McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Well, no , of course not .. there's plenty of other reasons to shoot RAW. I don't bother setting the custom image settings on the camera, or the lens or distortion corrections, because these will only apply to the JPEG ..... (the only software that will actually 'act' on these settings is PDCU) .... other RAW software will ignore these settings and simply apply its own defaults.

But white balance is different ...... as you and Richard have said, this is one camera recorded metadata figure that IS actually 'acted' upon by third party RAW software and applied to the colours of the image when opened. It is simply a camera recorded temperature figure, and this is acted upon by the software through the 'As Shot' WB preset ... this is common to all RAW converters AFAIK.

So, if like me, you find it more practical and accurate to get white balance right on the camera, then this is the one camera setting that it is perfectly logical to spend time setting in the field, especially for RAW.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 01/03/2015 - 00:07

McGregNi
I don't see it as 'software correction' in the camera .... yes, that is what's happening as the controls are changed, but the practical outcome is what matters ... and this outcome is that the camera records and stores in the file for us a specific and precise colour temperature figure. This is then transferred through the metadata into the RAW software, and applied to all the colours. So long as your calibrations though the chain are reasonably accurate you end up with very much the same colours you saw and set at capture.

It is the practicality of this 'in camera' method of recording a colour temperature figure that I find advantageous, rather than work later in post when the reference and memory to the actual objects and colours in the scene are long gone. So I see the camera WB controls (and any practical tools and aids you use to set them) as simply providing the best way to create the correct colour temperate figure ....

For most situations I find the time spent before shooting very valuable, although of course there are times when you need to shoot quickly and you're lucky to get the WB preset right ! In those situations I do not really enjoy fine tuning WB on the computer in RAW I must say, and try and remind myself to practise using the camera controls even more quickly.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 28/02/2015 - 23:47

McGregNi
StephenHampshire wrote:
The original image has a strong gradation from dark (lower left) to light (upper right) The boats are obviously boats without having a mass of distracting detail. The vertical of the head and neck on the left third is balanced by the vertical of the masts on the second right third (using a classical rile of thirds composition) The diagonal of the statue's eye line is married by the diagonal of the rigging (top right)
The wistful look ""in his face expresses the sadness and not being at sea. And you are right, this interpretation is entirely a construct of my imagination, but it is what makes the first picture work for me. But as I said, in my earlier post, each to his own.



... and I'm seeing a portrait of a statue shot at in interesting angle, but marred by excessive contrast and shadow on the face and a very domimant, over-bright and complex OOF distraction behind to the right which just pulls the eye back and forward to no purpose !!!

Comment by McGregNi posted on In his face at 28/02/2015 - 23:16

McGregNi
I'm not shooting colour critical projects or product work, so yes, I've found the co-ordination of LCD monitor colours with the WB settings through to output very accurate in fact.

Don't forget we do have (on the K7 / K5 at least, probably more models as well) LCD Colour Tuning (in the No2 Set-Up menu) .... here we have the normal 255pattern G-M / B-A axes controls.

I have found the LCD factory default very accurate though in matching output as set through the WB controls .... I guess its meant to be ideally.

The main obstacle to LCD reference in the field is ambient brightness and reflections, but yet again, we have a lot of brightness control for the LCD as well, and this can often power through any problems.

We really do have an incredible array of control choices and aids to image capture on our Pentax cameras!

Richard, I'm not saying that the WB cannot be successfully corrected in RAW software, and I accept the theory in it should not matter at capture for RAW ..... but I have found in practice it is easier to eyeball the colours, or use Expodisc and make the adjustments using the camera controls and get it right in camera rather than software tools post shoot .

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 28/02/2015 - 23:10

McGregNi
My point above was really that I find it worth the time to get it right in camera and take advantage of this automatic ' as shot ' setting being carried over when starting the editing.

You have the advantage when shooting of being able to spot specific colours in the scene and match then on the LCD worth fine tuning controls ... Or use a card as Steve said, or an expodisc which I prefer.

I find in practice these tools and controls at capture more reliable than software solutions in post.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 28/02/2015 - 21:24

McGregNi
The problem I see Stephen, it's that you are viewing this as an ' environmental portrait' , ie with a strong emphasis on the connection of the subject to the environment.

But, this is not how the photographer has crafted the photo ... An environmental portrait demands a much smaller aperture and realistic rendering. The photographer has chosen completely differently, with a wide aperture and tight subject framing. This had the effect (I believe) of reducing the background to a much lower supporting role than the relationship that you are suggesting exists.

This is what I'm not seeing as a result of the photographers choices. In this case then, the positioning and dominant lighting on this secondary background element is only distracting, and needs technical control.

I understand how you want to view the photo, but I feel you are superimposing an alternative interpretation that does not exist in the visual reality of the image.

Comment by McGregNi posted on In his face at 28/02/2015 - 20:33

McGregNi
Peter Elgar wrote:
Let me see if Ricoh/Pentax have finally got the flash synch speed up to 1/250th before I think about it !
Peter, I recall a discussion on this sync spec matter a while ago, and I argued for the point that we needed a shorter time value for maximum sync (250th was referred to) , and I must say it was generally dismissed by experienced people on here ... Considered of no significance ....(I mean the difference between 180th and 250th) .

I thought it would have practical advantages, even that little bit, when you're up against the brightness buffer and don't have HSS assailable.

What do you see as the key significance and practical benefit of a shorter max sync time ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax FF October? at 28/02/2015 - 19:57

McGregNi
That's very nice! I like the contrast balancing and the background can still fulfil it's 'purpose' at a lower brightness level. The fill on the statute evens out the contrast on the face beautifully... Sure, maybe a diffuser would reduce reflections more .. But in any case, great job!

Comment by McGregNi posted on In his face at 28/02/2015 - 18:45

McGregNi
I do think that accurate white balance fine tuning on camera is important even for RAW shooting ... This setting is carried through to the ' as shot' default preset on opening the file. No matter what software I've used, it always seems easier to get a good white balance on the camera at the time of taking rather than later in software.

I do sometimes use PS ' colour balance' sliders for small fine tuning, and so long as the ' as shot' setting was good this is very effective. I don't find the same success or consistency when making larger changes, like with white or grey point pickers .... Always seems more hit and miss and I don't find I end up with a quality colour balance generally if the in camera setting was off. I know in theory this should be easy, but in practice I find not.

So WB is always one camera setting that I fuss over and try to get a right as possible even for RAW.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 28/02/2015 - 08:10

McGregNi
Yes, CTE (Colour Temperature Enhancement) is a nice feature, and the obvious example for its use could be sunsets, although indoor with tungsten it can be good as well whenever the tungsten preset removes too much warmth. The good thing about it as well is that it is just another WB preset with its own fine tuning options, in all 4 directions, so you have a huge range of control.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Maybe just me or I have a rubbish K3 at 28/02/2015 - 06:16

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo