All Forum Comments
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Critique Thread No. 1 at 10/06/2010 - 10:22
George. I appreciate your advice and it makes sense to a point, but can I ask a question. Would you use your 400mm against your F300 plus the 1.7 converter for wildlife shots?
To a point, the cost is not the issue. Finding a 300mm f4.5 or a F4 is, or any 300mm come to that.
regards Thoramay.
It takes time to master a big, long, MF lens, but it can be done. I would love to have an AF 400mm, but it's not going to happen any time soon.
Genrally, the only time I use the 1.7 T/C is with the 400mm on a tripod, and I nearly always focus manually.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on 300mm M42 F4 lens at 10/06/2010 - 10:03
My own view is very similar to JR's, so I won't repeat what he said, though I would add that, leaving aside the compositional arguments for leaving the original uncropped, I do much prefer pictures to have dimensions close to the golden mean. Whenever I crop, that is an important consideration. So, in this case, I find the dimensions of the final image unsatisfying.
Coming to the concept of the Critique section, I would prefer the originator of the image NOT to say what he was trying to achieve until after the initial discussion had run its course. In my view, a photograph should ideally not need explaining, and should be viewed for the first time without any explanations or interpretations from the photographer or anybody else.
After an interval of, say, 48 hours or so, it would certainly be most interesting and an important part of the process to read what the photographer has to say about his image. But initially, let's see it with fresh eyes and an empty mind. Empty? Well, not entirely, but you know what I mean.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Critique Thread No. 1 at 10/06/2010 - 09:44
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on follow the donkey at 10/06/2010 - 09:15
JR has isolated one centre of interest, the house, and the other is the water to the left. Both are quite lovely in themselves, but when they appear in one picture the eye goes from one to the other.
There is no solution, in my view, other than to take two separate pictures.
But what a delightful spot! And how tempting to try to capture it all in one image.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on My England at 10/06/2010 - 09:12
many thanks does that mean that pc sockets are designed to take higher trigger voltages eg studio flash etc
Do you know the trigger voltage of the flashgun? It seems to be 24v link At least it's not 300v+ It's up to you it's still quite high.
Algi
24V is certainly not high for a Pentax camera, although it has to be said that all Pentax's own flashguns use a much lower voltage.
Peter Elgar, who posts here sometimes, said that he used to use his MX with a high voltage studio flashgun for many years, and eventually the contacts burnt out. But that would have been several hundred volts, and many thousands of shots in a professional studio.
I used my old Bowens Monobloc (200V) for years with my Super A, Z1-P and *ist D with no ill effects, but I wasn't shooting as often as Mr Elgar.
Nowadays I have more modern kit, and if I do get the old Monobloc out I use it with a cheap Chinese slave trigger. Just in case!
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on metz 45 ct4 at 10/06/2010 - 08:48
I find my M 400 1:5.6 quite hand-holdable in decent light, despite its size and weight, and it is sharp wide-open. Shake Reduction is a real boon here.
The only problem is that focussing is a bit slow compared to an AF lens, but probably no worse than using the 1.7x T/C on a 300mm.
So, if you can't afford a modern 300mm, try an old 400mm. Much cheaper, and you can always sell it again if you don't get on with it.
And if you go this route, there is not much advantage to the A version, rather than the M or K. You will usually be shooting wide-open, and if so, you can use Av mode.
But you won't be able to use it with the 1.7 T/C. There won't be enough light to focus properly.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on 300mm M42 F4 lens at 10/06/2010 - 08:31
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Virus at 10/06/2010 - 08:13
Well well,thats interesting, not much of a response, from which I infer there is not general usage of filters any more,I am surprised.
Alistair
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Is there still a place for filters In a digital world? at 10/06/2010 - 08:03
His Steveness is still looking a bit emaciated
Nice link. As one who is interested in the differences between American and real English, I was both surprised and pleased to hear him use the P word with an "off" at the end of it. Usually, Americans omit the "off", which suggests to non-Americans that the speaker is inebriated rather than irate.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Freedom of choice at 10/06/2010 - 07:58


what's your view on image titles? I know some people are against them, as they can give the very explanation or interpretation to which you refer here.
Of course, if you are a great artist, giving titles to your pictures allows the public to identify them. This is not something I have been asked to do with any of my pictures.
G