fritzthedog

Joined: 25th July 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

fritzthedog
I have the 55-300 and the Sigma 120-400. Despite the reverence paid to the 55-300 - and for the price - the IQ is just about impossible to beat - in my opinion - the Sigma 120-400 delivers superior performance in every respect as well as giving you much more reach.

Frankly - to me, other than price - the only advantage of the 55-300-- is weight - although I have no issue hand holding the 120-400 - there is no denying it is a much bigger heavier lens than the 55-300.

If I had the funds to buy either - for me the choice would be a very simple one.

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on worth paying double to get a Siggy 120-400 over the Pentax 55-300mm? at 17/03/2013 - 15:37

fritzthedog
I own the 120-400 and the 150-500. I use the 120-400 when I need to hand hold - e.g. airshows. It is much more comfortable than the 150-500 and I have no issue hand holding it for 2-3 hours which I can not do with the 150-500.

Also worth noting that the 120-400 is slightly faster and in my experience slightly sharper (but not much in it).

As for the loss of range - actually it is not as great as you may think. I sometimes go out with both lenses on different bodies and the 'real' difference when you use both together dos not seem as big as the 20% difference suggests.

I would also point out that in the real world - you will be shooting between min and max - not just at max. So the question becomes - how often do you need 500mm vs 400mm?

Not so easy to answer - I bought the 150-500 believing it would give me significant advantages over the 120-400 but discovered that there are not many times it does. I intended selling the 120-400 - but can not seem to let go of it because it has the advantages listed above.

If pushed and had to lose one - I would keep the 120-400

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Ultrazoom at 13/03/2013 - 09:26

fritzthedog
Mannesty wrote:
fritzthedog wrote:
As that recall was in 2007 - if anybody still has a dodgy one - they have probably discovered the fault first hand by now
Yes, I realised it was an old advisory, but I thought it worth mentioning again as it was related to Pentax. Others might find the rest of the Electrical Safety Council's site interesting though, which of course is not directly related to Pentax, as per the rules of this forum.
Nothing wrong with you posting it Peter - I was merely being my usual irreverent self suggesting that those who had not sent it back during the recall had possibly discovered the fault the hard way

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Electrical Safety - Product Recall at 12/03/2013 - 16:13

fritzthedog
Lenny - are you sure you are not just showing off?

Most of us mere mortals dream of owning one of them - not bothered which one.

Tell you what - send both of them to me and I will do an extensive real world test - say...2 years? At the end of which I will give you my 40 page detailed evaluation and send back to you the winner

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on if you had to sell either a DA*60-250 or FA* 80-200....... at 12/03/2013 - 11:45

fritzthedog
The only issue to me is honesty.

I have no issue looking at the work of a gifted technician - I can admire skill in what ever form it takes.

There are several very good exponents of the art of processing who post on this forum regularly - most of whom are honest about what they do and I can admire their work.

At the same time - I often think it would be good to see what they can do without PS.

I am not going to try to self justify any pp work I do - we all do what we feel comfortable with. In my case - as little as possible - not because I am against it - I just hate doing it. Spending hours on one photograph is my idea of hell. Shear pleasure to me is the rare occasion I download an image to the PC - look at it and think - job done!

Processing to me is only "cheating" if the processor attempts to pass it off as UN-processed. I don't enter competitions and one of the reasons is that I know I am up against "exponents of the dark art".

Is there a way of identifying an unprocessed image? if not there should be and competitions should require submission of original and re-worked image in my view.

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Is photoshop ruining photography at 12/03/2013 - 11:37

fritzthedog
As that recall was in 2007 - if anybody still has a dodgy one - they have probably discovered the fault first hand by now

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Electrical Safety - Product Recall at 12/03/2013 - 11:07

fritzthedog
Please see my previous post for full details.

Basically - free double room inc breakfast - 3 nights - tomorrow wed 13th to 16th March - Beadnell Towers Northumberland

I will hold off cancelling the room until this evening in case there is any interest today-
Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Free Holiday Tomorrow - Final Chance at 12/03/2013 - 09:18

fritzthedog
If I were you - I would just carry it around as a second body. If you are anything like me - you will be surprised at how often you use it. I normally carry 2 bodies these days - with very different lenses attached. So for instance if I am doing some slow shutter speed work - I can play with the other body and lens whilst waiting 2 minutes+ for an exposure.

Regards

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Storage Advice at 12/03/2013 - 07:28

fritzthedog
Well my week off work started today and immediately turned in to a nightmare.

I Have had a 4 day photography trip planned for months in Northumberland from Wed 13 to Sat 16th March - i.e. this week.

There were 3 of us going - all Pentaxians - 2 members - one non member. We have booked a 3 night stay at the Beadnell Towers hotel in Beadnell village, just outside Seahouses (nice hotel - have stayed before).

On Sunday the non member had to pull out due to her Mother being rushed in to hospital critically ill.

Today - due to unforeseen circumstances - the other member of the party has also pulled out.

Unfortunately - Yesterday was the final day to be able to cancel and get a refund.

So - I currently have 2 double rooms paid for. My options are:

1. Don't go and lose a fortune
2. Go by myself and lose on the second room (and I don't particularly fancy 3 evenings of talking to the wall in the bar
3. Find somebody who fancies a short notice photography trip to the beautiful Northumberland coast.

So - can anybody make it? is anybody interested?

A double room (single occupancy) is already paid for and includes breakfast. I would sooner give this away than pay for it and nobody use it.

So - if anybody fancies a FREE trip and joining me (you can buy me a couple of pints if you like) let me know asap.

If you live between North Yorks and Northumberland and do not have transport - that is not necessarily a problem.

It would be great if anybody who I already know could join me - but the offer is open to all members.

PM if interested - it's not every day you get offered the chance of a free holiday!

Given the short notice - I expect interest to be thin on the ground and you may be the only person to PM me.I am not going to make this first reply gets it - I will play as fair as I can but hope you understand that if somebody I know expresses an interest - whether they are first or not - I may decide to give them first refusal based on the fact that I may already know for sure that we will get on

I will give it until tomorrow morning before any decision is made - and even if you can only make 2 of the 3 nights - still worth PMing me - you never know!

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on URGENT - Ayybody free this week - Wed-Sat????? at 11/03/2013 - 20:41

fritzthedog
elfer wrote:
weinelm wrote:
DA 15mm sold pending payment. Thanks!
Thanks to weinelm my search for a 15 is over - I got in quickly enough this time!
Damn - beat me to it

Comment by fritzthedog posted on FS: DA 15mm Ltd & DA 21mm Ltd at 11/03/2013 - 08:49

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo