Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
As people have said, for the price it's excellent - and what hasn't been mentioned yet is that both its size and range make it very attractive when comparing it to superior glass such as the 70-200 f2.8's or the 60-250 f4.

However, I have found myself getting frustrated by its' performance a little of late. It's just not capturing the detail that my other zooms (DAs 10-17, 12-24 & 17-70) are, even when using a tripod. I guess this has something to do with the demands of the telephoto range. However, I would expect (not having had experience of the other long range lenses) that the faster lenses would perform better, and not only because of the wider aperture.

Unless a secondhand bargain arises, I anticipate my next new purchase will be something faster in this range to partly take its place. However, I'll definitely hang on to the 55-300 for both the convenient size and range, and the more than decent results when all things are considered.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on smc DA 55-300mm f/4.0-5.8 ED at 22/04/2010 - 17:23

Dr. Mhuni
I wouldn't be so concerned about payment, Kris. If educational publishers were anything like academic ones (well certainly those publishing on Africa, with which I have experience) then they're budget will be extremely tight. Perhaps you should make enquiries first, though, to see if there's a possibility of payment. Other than that I'd be happy with the credit and the free book - and of couse your contribution to Danish education!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Advice required at 19/04/2010 - 03:06

Dr. Mhuni
I think Gareth's onto something - I like the bottom part of the first. The verticals (trees, people) and horizontals do work well, and the people wandering about and sitting on the embankment are great. For the whole image to work, I think the buildings above would have to be directly facing the camera - as it is they slant away and spoil the symmetry below (or apparent symmetry - I see from the stairs that the embankment is really sloping away too).

I'm afraid I don't like no. 2. Partly because it seems over-sharpened - as people have mentioned. But also - and I seem to be in a minority here - I don't think the composition works at all. What is the shot of? The trees are there as a framing device, which is fine. However, in the middle there's a bit of a void - an empty path. And Notre Dame, for me, is peculiarly close to the edge of the frame. Of course it's good to try to frame subjects in unusual ways (particularly much photographed ones such as this), but this doesn't work IMO. Ironically, on the vertical plane, I feel the cathedral is a bit central - I'd probably place it lower, cropping off some of the bottom of the image. I do like the people included in the frame - they give a sense of scale and add interest.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A couple more from the Seine. at 19/04/2010 - 02:26

Dr. Mhuni
The Cloudspotter's Guide (forgotten the author) is an excellent, and entertaining, place to begin.

The Rough Guide to the weather is also excellent, and a more thorough overview - though not solely UK focused.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on weather for photographers at 09/04/2010 - 15:29

Dr. Mhuni
I like that too. It's weird how those lines going out to the right seem to converge a lot.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Night train at 06/04/2010 - 02:01

Dr. Mhuni
A Pentax 10-24, now that would be hard to resist!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on which 10-20 - if at all? at 05/04/2010 - 18:57

Dr. Mhuni
womble wrote:
In that case I am glad that my last major bout of LBA led me to the 12-24 then, as I would be very unhappy with that degree of barrel distortion. How does it compare to the 16-45 or the 17-70?
Those Photozone tests that Stefan posted don't lie! The barrel distortion is the one disappointing thing I've found with the 17-70. Other than that it's optically slightly better than 16-45 (whose distortion is the best) and a country mile ahead of the kit. Not used a 16-50, but I think it compares well especially at the wider end, and the extra 20mm is very useful. Other than the distortion (and to a lesser extent the slower aperture than say the 16-50 or more competitively priced Tamron 17-50) the 17-70 is excellent - I'd wholeheartedly recommend it (although it's expensive now!).

BTW can someone explain why people are quoting f nos. when they're comparing barrel distortion. The aperture has no impact on this does it?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on DA* 16-50 question. at 05/04/2010 - 09:10

Dr. Mhuni
Nice clouds in 3 & 7. I think 4's potentially the most successful as an image - though, I think I'd play around with different crops either taking off some sky or some ground, and some off the left. Kris is right about the lightness; & i-berg about the sharpness.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Some from a Walk round the South Downs at 05/04/2010 - 07:49

Dr. Mhuni
The Prada and the Butchers shots are the ones that stand out for me. The latter in particular I really like, and with a bit more pp-ing (more careful cropping, straightening lines, bringing out the light contrasts) it could really be made to sing.

The monks shot I think would benefit from a conversion - I find the green rather busy.

Love the expression on the monk looking at the camera. Shame about the other monk looking away - or is it? I can't make up my mind.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Hong Kong street shots at 05/04/2010 - 05:19

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
Now if only it was F2... I really want something fast AND wide, for work shots, but don't want to be tied to a Prime... (Plenty of affordable options at the 17-50 range fortunetly!)
The thing is fast and ultra-wide don't really go together. The only fast wide lens I can think of is the DA14 f2.8 and that has the bulk of the 12-24 with no better image quality (I think) and without the extra 2mm wide & 9mm long. You only start getting faster at 16mm up.

On the other hand, even with just f4 I've noticed my 12-24 is a very good performer in low light. This is partly to do with the detail that it captures. But also, I think, any wide lens is going to perform better in low light due to the amount of light it is letting in (correct me if I'm wrong - I've a feeling I might be).

BTW - £529, if you can get it for that, is an exceptional price for a new DA12-24 - in fact, I'd say that was a good s/h price these days.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on which 10-20 - if at all? at 04/04/2010 - 04:07

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo