All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Users mag... review of the 100mm macro at 02/04/2010 - 11:10
BTW are you working for Qatar Airways now? They've become my airline of choice from here - due to the high standards and reasonable price.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Museum of Islamic Art at 02/04/2010 - 07:41
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on St. Martin's Through the Glass at 01/04/2010 - 17:56
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 38 - Genius Loci at 01/04/2010 - 03:13
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on PPG Submission and Voting at 31/03/2010 - 16:56

Stupa offering
Taken Sunday morning ca. 730, K20D, DA12-24 @ 16mm, f9, 1/125, ISO 100
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 38 - Genius Loci at 31/03/2010 - 16:45
Misfuds have a used Sigma 70-200mm f2.8 APO EX for sale (£399) and I would seriously consider this. The non HSM, non Macro version (the MKI) is the sharpest of all the 70-200mm lenses Sigma have made, I have one and it is far sharper wide open than the new version. I also have the 50-135mm and although a lovely lens never gets used because the 70-200mm is so good.
The older 70-200mm will also take the Sigma 1.4x converter with very little IQ loss.
However, what really puts me off the Sigma 70-200 is the size. It's the heaviest (1345 grams) of all the lenses above and also heavier than the Pentax 60-250. Am I right in assuming a lens of this size and weight is just not a viable option for use as a handheld, walkabout lens?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New lens advice please at 30/03/2010 - 16:24
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on West Somerset Railway III: A cavalcade of BR Standards at 30/03/2010 - 07:27
My real point is that far too many shooters spend far too much time agonising on forums as to which is the 'best' lens...thats like saying which are the best tyres for my car? ...
In the case of the lenses under discussion here, I haven't had the chance to use both, so it is hard to say whether or not the difference will be so apparent. Given the quality of the results the 12-24 (which I have) produces (and comparing it to other zooms), I would guess that there would be a real difference between that and the Sigma - probably in terms of resolution (the 12-24 is a remarkably sharp lens) and distortion (it has the least distortion of any wide angle I have used). However, I can't say that with any certainty because I haven't used the Sigma, and I have certainly seen that this lens can also produce excellent images such as the one above (though - to take another example - so can the DA18-55, but give me the DA17-70 any day).
The other argument for the 12-24 is that it's a more practical range - necessitating fewer lens changes. 4mm at the wide end is a lot. And I've found that 24mm often comes in handy (and with the 12-24's excellent resolution you can also crop quite severely before serious image degradation sets in). I often use just the 12-24 when wandering around historical sites, towns (taking shots of people, buildings, context shots etc.), and I reckon that I'd find 10-20mm a lot less practical - though, to be fair, the extra 2mm wide would occasionally be nice.
Still, having said all that, if I was getting a new ultra-wide now I'd almost certainly opt for a Sigma (though a second hand DA or Samsung would be tempting). The current pricing of the 12-24 - given that it's a consumer grade zoom (allbeit optically excellent) - is ridiculous. I was lucky enough to get one before the recent rises and with £50 off.
I am curious about the Sigma though. I wish someone would do a direct comparison which could put this debate to bed - the 12-24 vs. 10-20 dispute seems to be never ending with both sides convinced of 'their' lens's merits!
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on which 10-20 - if at all? at 30/03/2010 - 06:37
Re. the rules against PP-ing - these strike me as nonsensical. First, because they aren't consistently applied - some PPG images have clearly had digital manipulations not available in the traditional darkroom (HDR images to take one example). Second, how do you judge when PP-ing has been in excess of the PPG requirements and how can the judges, except in obvious cases (though even this isn't necessarily enough to prevent an image entering - see point 1), identify whether too much has been done to a particular image? Third, what might be considered an acceptable technique of digital manipulation such as use of filters, sophisticated use of layers & blends, can have substantially more impact than a technique which is explicitly not allowed such as the healing brush or the correction of lens distortion. Finally, this is the digital age and the majority of shots are taken with digital cameras, why not open it up to embrace all great images regardless of how they have been processed. The distinctions they currently make seem absurd and out-of-date, and also more or less impossible to apply consistently.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on PPG Submission and Voting at 30/03/2010 - 06:07

