All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on PPG results at 22/06/2010 - 14:25
As you know Tim I have plenty of respect for your photographic ability, and many of your PPG entries are wonderful and fully deserving of their place there. I also know that you are looking for frank assessments of your images which, like me, you find more helpful than unexacting praise.
I'm not sure that a PPG thread, where someone announces their latest acceptances is the place to get critical. However, I've been quite surprised to see some of the images that have got in of late in these threads (alongside others that have been IMO fully deserving). And I don't see why PPG accepted images should be above criticism, particularly when the benchmark isn't necessarily all that high. And, as I'm wont to point out, debate on images is useful (perhaps especially so when someone has a critical opinion of ones that have been deemed worthy of PPG inclusion).
I've read in various PUF threads that the PPG benchmark has lowered of late. I don't know if this is the case or not as I have only really been paying close attention to it since I started submitting earlier this year. Though from memory my impression was that when I did view PPG entries that people announced here a year or so ago the quality was very high. I was under the impression then that only the very best of my own efforts would get in (if any). I no longer hold this view - in retrospect even I am a little surprised by some of my own that have been accepted since I started submitting. If the PPG standard was as high as some have indicated it used to be then one could have real confidence about the exceptional quality of those images you have had accepted, but as things stand I'm not as pleased by my inclusions as I might be. (Another issue is what PPG rejects, which I sometimes find equally curious - but that is another thread).
Anyway, to get back to these photos (apologies for the lengthy preamble above but I thought it was necessary in the context of a PPG thread that are more usually reserved for congratulations).
Rapeseed tracks is pleasant enough image but doesn't have the wow factor that I think PPG ought to demand
Gobi trails I quite like, and at this size (the perversely small PPG vertical size - one of their odd requirements as it results in images not much larger than some thumbnails!) it no longer betrays the image quality evidence that it has been taken through a plane window (an earlier observation of mine). I'm still uncertain about whether it should cut the PPG mustard.
Sunset walk for me is the weakest of the set. I'm sorry but I really cannot see why this image has been included. For starters shots like these (receding pier, evening sky), while perhaps not a cliche, are not uncommon. This isn't enough to rule it out. However, I don't find the elements included in the picture at all compelling either. It's not killer sharp. The sea's insipid. The sky's pleasant enough though hardly dramatic. I don't find the boats particuarly interesting.
Blown out is the strongest shot IM(H)O. It's a great composition. But it's... erm, blown out! I realise this may be a subjective thing.
Glowing lines is a nice idea and well executed apart from the fact that IMO it lacks the killer sharpness that's required in these kind of shots.
Red polly - even allowing for differences over the merits of bird shots, I don't think this is such a fine example. Technically competent and good colours, yes, but again for me it lacks any wow factor.
Forgive me for starting this here, Tim, but I write this knowing that you are big enough to take it. And I do feel that for the good health of the forum perhaps it's time someone responded to a PPG thread in a more critical way.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on PPG results at 22/06/2010 - 06:56
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on DISCUSSION for Comp #44 Food at 21/06/2010 - 06:11
As for my two penn'orth on how to improve it (fwiw), compositionally I think there's perhaps too much water in the f/g which doesn't hold a great deal of interest, and I'm not keen on how the clouds are cropped top right. But these issues could only be addressed by re-shooting.
I'm curious why you opted for b'n'w here, as the colours are quite nice in the original.
As for re-sizing I halve the image size then apply unsharp mask and repeat this until the image is the size I want to post, which generally works well.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 18/06/2010 - 12:18
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Little bridge at 18/06/2010 - 11:52
I also support Mike in both his analysis of the photo, comparisons to AA, and the utility of uncritical commentary. In my view his remarks are highly constructive.
In posting images on public forums shouldn't we be prepared to take the rough with the smooth and, invariably, learn more from the former?
Often i'll see comments I disagree with, but it's not fair to hijack someone's c&c thread to get up on your personal hobby horse re another member or the site in general.
Address the photo!
the edge of the hill is too pronounced, one cloud is burnt out, the hill side is rather dark to no real purpose, the composition has already been questioned. Nor would AA be guilty of using the wrong film (ISO 1600).
I felt my own post was justified because of how Ems interpreted Mike's comments:
a. suggesting the comments were not constructive (see above);
b. that they were rude (blunt perhaps, but not rude IMO, and qualified by the following
All of course IMO only and no offence intended to anyone.
c. apparently making the inference that there is no space for critical commentary here.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 18/06/2010 - 06:20
In posting images on public forums shouldn't we be prepared to take the rough with the smooth and, invariably, learn more from the former?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 17/06/2010 - 18:42
While it has many qualities, something niggles me about the balance of the shot. I agree with Tim about the left hand crop being tight (Dr. Orloff's is an improvement here). As a result of the house being so far left in the frame, the image seems very weighted down to the bottom left corner to my eye. The balance of the shot is helped by the trees to the right, but these aren't very dense (due to the mist) and to my eye aren't a sufficient counterweight. The open sky around the edge of the frame top right perhaps doesn't help here either. Though of course this is an entirely subjective response to the image and most people are quite happy with the shot as is, which I can understand.
What would have made the shot work better IMO? Perhaps the inclusion of a tree or some trees to the left of the house? Possibly some distant foilage appearing at the edge of the frame in the top right corner? Though I realise neither was probably an option for you.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Critique Thread No 3 at 15/06/2010 - 03:52
Good idea this. And I agree with George about the originator posting their rationale after others have commented.
Incidentally, I also mostly agree with George about titles - though not always as a well chosen title (usually ironic) can occasionally make a picture.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Critique Thread No. 1 at 10/06/2010 - 11:14
Gareth it was the DA17-70, so only f4 (the only thing I don't really like about this lens). I think WFP probably prefer people in focus. I know what you mean though, and from a purely aesthetic point of view you're right. You're probably right about the crops too (certainly the last, though I might not crop as much as you suggest off no.3) - I generally try to avoid long and thin, though it may well improve both of these. No problem at all re. your comments.
I do have some shots that I took more for myself than with WFP in mind, though these are yet to be processed.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Walk the world at 10/06/2010 - 10:55


I take your point about the Gobi trails (and to be honest I'm in two minds about that one - at this size in any case), but just because a photo is the best available under the circumstances doesn't necessarily mean it's a worthy image. Though I agree in this case the geography is striking. Where were you on the plane - I always try to get seats towards the back, though I've yet to take an even half decent shot from a plane. You must have been lucky with your window as well as the geography (and light)!
I did spot your off centre composition in Sunset walk, but didn't feel this was enough to set it apart.
In Glowing lines I thought the grain on the blinds seemed a bit soft, but perhaps it's just my eyes as Ralf (the master of this kind of thing) approves. Though I would have thought a tripod for this kind of shot was essential.
Re. PPG entry - is it all based on voting now? I thought the field was winnowed through voting and the final selection arrived at by the Pentax panel.