Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Great, thanks for that Colin. No need to upload images for me - I was just curious about whether or not the AF would work with HSM.

I would certainly recommend this TC in that case, Luka. From what I understand, the Tamron is at least the equal of the Pentax 1.7. It's also considerably cheaper (half the price of the Pentax) - though it is shorter of course. Still it would convert your Sigma 50-150 to 70-210, which is handy.

Judging by users' feedback, these two TCs stand out from all others IQ wise.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Any advice on choosing a AF teleconverter? at 14/09/2010 - 08:27

Dr. Mhuni
Luka,

I got a Tamron 1.4 TC recently. I've used it with my DFA100, but tried it out with the DA17-70 to see if it worked with SDM. It did.

As long as you stop down slightly (past f4), the image quality remains excellent (with the DFA100). (If I'm not mistaken - a problem with TC's is that the EXIF only shows the lens' focal length - my entry to last week's DoF comp was taken with this combination - link).

I also got it in the hope that the focusing would work with the Sigma HSM (I am picking up a 50-150 at Xmas). However, I'm not sure it does - I recall reading something that cast doubt on this (that it worked with SDM but not HSM). Welding Blues - have you actually used yours with a Sigma HSM lens?

The Tamron comes up periodically on Pentaxorums - I got mine for $180 inc.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Any advice on choosing a AF teleconverter? at 14/09/2010 - 06:02

Dr. Mhuni
pentaxian450 wrote:
Dr. Mhuni wrote:
but there's still quite a gap in this regard between the K7 and, say, a D700 isn't there?
There's also quite a gap in the price. When shooting RAW, you can easily position the K-7 low lights capabilities beside a Nikon D300. And with the money saved, you can buy a more than decent lens.
I know the K7 isn't poor when compared to other APS-C cameras (and it's not only cheaper than a D300 but also a lot smaller). However, some comments had been made playing down the difference between APS-C & FF - high ISO performance is one significant difference as far as I'm aware.

The kind of high ISO performance available in the D700 is not going to be accessible to Pentax SLR users until they release a FF camera or APS-C performance improves considerably.

That said, all things considered, I think Pentax are probably right not to try and compete in the FF market.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5, Kr, full frame (?) it's all to little too late at 13/09/2010 - 03:27

Dr. Mhuni
Fair point. But it was a shame the K7 didn't represent much of an advance (if any) when compared to the K20D in this area.

As for the K5 I'd be happy to lose some megapixels for improved high ISO performance, though I realise this isn't going to happen.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5, Kr, full frame (?) it's all to little too late at 12/09/2010 - 17:54

Dr. Mhuni
That's interesting Mike, but there's still quite a gap in this regard between the K7 and, say, a D700 isn't there?

Any idea how the KX shapes up against FF at high ISO?

As I said, I'm hoping the K5 will at least match the KX.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5, Kr, full frame (?) it's all to little too late at 12/09/2010 - 17:36

Dr. Mhuni
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the high ISO performance of FF cameras seems to me to be pretty desirable when compared to APS-C. Particularly when the K7's performance in this regard marked a step back from the K20D.

This is the area I most hope is addressed in the K5. Given the KX's ability in this area one expects it will be - though it would be nice if this time Pentax advanced high ISO performance further still in its top of the range body instead of its entry level one. The K7 is clearly a great camera, but it was a little odd to see so many people pining for the KX's low light ability when this was released shortly after the K7.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5, Kr, full frame (?) it's all to little too late at 12/09/2010 - 17:26

Dr. Mhuni
Nice shots Unlocker. What impresses me is how close you must have got to get these with the 10-17 (I presume). And the fact there are no stray fingers in shot!

Looking good, Ken!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fisheye on the wedding dance floor! at 03/09/2010 - 16:58

Dr. Mhuni
I feel somewhat uncomfortable differing with JR & Don, who have much more expertise than me - and they certainly have a point about the quality that can be extracted from a zoom. However, in my use of primes I have found that (depending on the lens) the difference between them and a good zoom isn't confined to the 4 points outlined by Don above. Primes can have a quite distinctive character in the way they render a scene which makes them preferable to zooms for the quality of the image produced.

As far as which prime I'd recommend - the DFA100 is certainly pretty special for its colour rendition especially (apart from perhaps the DA*50-135 I think you'd be hard pressed to find a zoom performing this well), but for a first prime I'd go for a Pentax 50 macro which has more scope as a general purpose lens than the 100 IMO (though is admittedly not so good as a macro). I have an old version - the A50 f2.8 - and it's been my favourite lens since I acquired it.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Venturing into the World of primes at 29/08/2010 - 18:20

Dr. Mhuni
I'm confused by all the comments indicating that PUFers' 10-20's have replaced their 10-17's. Never mind the distortions (which can be nice), surely the fisheye offers a dramatically different perspective by including SO much more (which seems to be borne out by Smeggypants' stats above)? Certainly I notice a big difference between the 10-17 and 12mm on my 12-24. I don't think the extra 2mm on the Sigma includes that much more does it?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Sigma 10-20mm Lens for Pentax K20D at 27/08/2010 - 19:03

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
I've still had no satisfactory explanation as to how to make my 12-24 focus - even on infinity (which isn't that far away on that) in anything other than bright sunshine.
I've always found the 12-24 to be very good at AF (on a K2D). So perhaps your KX theory is right, Flossie. Though it sounds rather strange - surely JR's hunch that there's a fault with the lens is much more likely?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Rumours or fact? at 23/08/2010 - 14:25

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo