All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Wide Angle or Fish Eyes? at 18/08/2010 - 15:56
Simon define oddly?
It fails to focus very occasionally, mainly at the long end, and makes an uncharacteristic noise, as I say it's quite rare so I haven't given it much thought
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on SDM failures horror stories at 07/07/2010 - 18:53
Now to reveal all...
Reassuringly - my judgment hasn't entirely gone to pot - you PUF'ers tended to single out the images that I liked the most, and which IMO were most worthy of a PPG place, but which failed to make it.
I go along with the consensus that 3 and 8 are the best images. Compositionally, I think both have a certain something that sets them apart. However, they didn't make the PPG cut - though I will probably re-submit both.
The other one that stands out for me is no. 6 (On the buses) which many of you selected too. IMO this is probably my most successful street shot - I think the bus conductor is well captured, I love the wad of notes he's holding and the b/g detail is interesting (yes, passers-by are blurred but this kind of thing doesn't spoil many classic street shots). PPG didn't agree and rejected it.
As for the others, they're pretty much on a par for me. There are things I like about all of them, but I don't think they are of the same standard as the three mentioned above. I note that no. 5 was popular here, but it doesn't excite me like 3, 6 & 8 do.
Anyway, to cut to the quick: 1, 4, 5 & 7 are in PPG - and 2, 3, 6 & 8 failed to make it.
What this says about PPG I don't know, though I am often perplexed by the decisions arrived at. I don't think PPG acceptances are a real gold standard anymore (if they ever were). In some ways it would be nice if the bar was set higher, as you could feel a real sense of achievement getting an image in. On the other hand it is nice to have a more comprehensive selection of your better images in one place on the web - especially after the PPG algorhythms (or your mind) have worked their magic.
Anyway, that's it for me (until I get more faves rejected perhaps).
Anyone else fancy starting another round of spot the reject?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Spot the PPG reject (8 images - sorry!) at 07/07/2010 - 17:30
I wouldn't be looking to independent lenses for increased reliablility, nor would I be influenced by the anecdotal tales of failures.
There are a lot of SDM lenses out there and we don't really hear of large numbers of problems. The Internet does mean that those problems that exist are certainly well documented.
So far I have only bought Pentax lenses (and am very happy with them), but in this case I can't help thinking I will opt for the Sigma 50-150. Of course, this lens might have issues too - though I have read nothing along these lines (other than front focusing which can be adjusted on my K20). It's true, though, that there are very few of these lenses about in the Pentax mount because of the dominance of the DA*. I guess I should take a look at some Canikon forums for feedback.
The Sigma does have a 3 year warranty in the UK though (not much use in Sri Lanka, but still). Also - the bottom line - the DA* is about 50% more expensive at current SRS prices.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on SDM failures horror stories at 07/07/2010 - 05:38
David, you should think of entering your photos. Although I don't always agree with the selections (on which more tomorrow), it's good to have a decent sample of your images in one place on the web. And somehow the images seem to look even better once they've been accepted in PPG - I don't know whether this is just in my head or it's got to do with the algorhythms PPG uses on accepted photos. I suspect the latter, though it could of course be the former! Whatever, I'm sure you'd soon put together a great portfolio there.
aliengrove - it can take aeons for images to be accepted or rejected, and having images hanging around for judgment no longer seems to indicate that they will likely be rejected. Judging from others' comments this used to be the case, but since I started earlier this year it hasn't been so in my experience (and others have made the same observation).
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Spot the PPG reject (8 images - sorry!) at 06/07/2010 - 17:57
It doesn't look as though there's a mass of horror stories after all.
There are failures with every make of lens, Pentax included, but as a percentage it seems relatively low.
Surely with Sigma's reputation for poor quality control, and the fact that (with current Pentax prices) many Pentax body owners are buying Sigma HSM lenses, there should be an equal if not greater volume of complaints from Pentax body users about Sigma HSM if in fact SDM does not have worse problems than other brands.
I might still be tempted by the 60-250, but that just seems unwieldy for the (mostly) street photography I'd use it for.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on SDM failures horror stories at 06/07/2010 - 04:09
Quote:
With crisp I mean that the details are too harsh too my taste.
This might be a good read if you want to read more about sharpening www.cambridgeincolour.com/techniques/image-sharpening
Will have a look at this. Thanks, Stefan.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Spot the PPG reject (8 images - sorry!) at 05/07/2010 - 21:26
Have no idea what was chosen but I like 3,5 and 8 - perhaps I should say particularly like as all of them are worth a prolonged view. If I need four then I would go for 1 because of the detail, love the repair to the bench or is it that the concrete has fallen from the supporting wire.
With crisp I mean that the details are too harsh too my taste.
This might be a good read if you want to read more about sharpening www.cambridgeincolour.com/techniques/image-sharpening
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Spot the PPG reject (8 images - sorry!) at 05/07/2010 - 21:21
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on SDM failures horror stories at 05/07/2010 - 21:00
No 8 yes.
No 3 I like but don't think it's what I would expect to find in the PPG.
The others are good photos , just not great photos.
Harsh.....but fair
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Spot the PPG reject (8 images - sorry!) at 05/07/2010 - 20:48


I was lucky enough to be lent a Pentax 10-17 fisheye last weekend by Steve Chasey (thanks Steve) at a meetup. Sure, it's a fun little lens, and I was able to take some really cool 180-degree wide-angle shots in the cafe, and experience the 'fisheye' effect in full. But it was very obvious, very quickly, that this lens was a one-trick pony. It makes 'fisheye' photos - nothing more, nothing less. I would very quickly tire of that effect - even though it's very creative, and lots of fun - because it's so unnatural, and so obviously, er, fisheye!
For more examples of the adaptability and quality of this lens see this thread: link
Having said that, it's not the most obvious landscape lens. But I certainly wouldn't dismiss it entirely.