Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I base my purchases principally on user feedback, however, test results can't be dismissed. The problem with user feedback is you don't know what the user is comparing their lens with. Not everyone has FA ltds! Also, even those who have high quality glass with which to compare performance often won't have experience of the direct competition.

To take the three lenses under review at PF - while many might complain that the DA* is better than the review infers, this could just mean that the Tamron and Sigma are quite exceptional.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Bad review for DA* 16-50mm at 12/10/2011 - 06:06

Dr. Mhuni
Frogfish, I did misinterpret the 'highest quality' reference, however, of their three DA* zooms 2 out of 3 ain't bad, even if it should be improved upon.

Re. the Sigma, in my experience the DA* is definitely sharper at f2.8 than the Sigma. Perhaps this is sample variation, I don't know, but as I stated I tried to avoid shooting wide open with the Sigma, especially at the long end, where the wide open performance dipped considerably - though when stopped down it still produced excellent results. (If my Sigma had performed better wide open I wouldn't have replaced it with the DA*). And while colours can of course be adjusted in PP (Raw or Jpeg), I'd rather have the convenience of a lens that produces them in the first place (though I had no complaints with the Sigma, the DA* is just better IMHO - same with the bokeh). Re. the size, my impression was that the Pentax was quite a bit smaller (I never owned them simultaneously so this was just an impression), but I appear to be wrong here. Having just looked at Photozone this gives contradictory info to that which you give - the DA* star comes out as 1mm longer and wider, but 85g lighter. Perhaps it's the lightness that gave me the impression of it being noticeably smaller. The hood is a pain though - I'm not bothered by its weight, it's just so bloody conspicuous.

Frogfish wrote:


However the biggest point of contention in your post is your ascertion that the 16-50 is best from 24mm onwards. I have to blink and rub my eyes at that (unless I am in turn misinterpreting your meaning) ? Surely the one reason people buy these 16/17 - 50s is for the width and flexibility, otherwise they would buy a 24/28 - 70/75 without any distortion ? A point which PF and other reports have made (regarding more distortion than the competition at 16mm ) re. the 16-50mm.

As for the PF review, the Tamron didn't come out best (though maybe you meant in relation to the Pentax ?), it came out second to the Sigma, though to be fair there is hardly anything in it between all three. There is no doubt however that whichever lens you buy (Pentax, Sigma, Tamron) the majority of people are very happy with their purchase.
Having never had a 16-50 I can make no assertions about its qualities - the comment re. 24mm+ was gleaned from feedback I have read from users in the past. I've read many observations that its particular strength is between 24-50, which compensates for the less stellar performance more wide. I wouldn't choose to buy this lens partly for this reason (but more because of the size and cost), but I know of many owners who are very happy with its performance as an all rounder.

Re. the test, the Sigma scored best due to its superior build quality. Optically the Tamron was a match for the Sigma (better in some respects, worse in others):

Quote:
Though the Tamron ranks second overall in the final scoring, it earned that competitiveness almost solely on the merits of the image quality it can produce. While we'd hesitate to say it's a definitively better lens than the Sigma optically, it does at times exceed the Sigma in sharpness, and roundly bests it flare resistance while edging slightly ahead in other categories as well.
Given that PF make no recommendation in their conclusion, and the fact that the Tamron is roughly half the price of the Sigma in the UK (the disparity being slightly smaller, though still large, in the US), my own conclusion is that the 17-50 has performed best all things considered. Admittedly that ignores the score - but who buys a lens based on a score?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Bad review for DA* 16-50mm at 09/10/2011 - 10:30

Dr. Mhuni
I have to disagree, Frogfish. I think Pentax does produce good zooms - it's just that perhaps the DA*16-50 doesn't match up (in tests at least - I know that in use many owners love its optical qualities, especially past ca. 24mm) to the competition, particularly when cost is borne in mind.

Other currently available Pentax zooms include the DA16-45, 17-70 & 55-300, all of which I have experience of, and are excellent for their class. Indeed, I imagine that the 17-70 would have performed respectably against the other lenses in this test even though it covers a bigger range - but, importantly, it's f4 not f2.8. Pentax also produces what is widely considered the best kit standard zoom, the 18-55. True, the DA18-135 has met a mixed response. But generally I'd say Pentax are no slouches in either the prime or zoom department, and when compared to other 'branded' lenses they're reasonable value at the moment.

Re. the DA*50-135 & the Sigma 50-150 f2.8 - while the latter is a lovely lens that was generally available for at least £150 less than the DA*, the only ways in which it outperforms the Pentax is in the faster AF and longer range (though the quality dips a bit at wider apertures after ca.130mm). The DA* is smaller (though with an absurdly large hood), lighter, better built, produces better colours and bokeh and - my main reason for switching - is noticeably better wide open (I used to use my Sigma a lot stopped down slightly at f4, which I don't feel is so necessary any more). There's no doubting that the Sigma is an excellent lens - it's just that the DA* is even better.

As for the comparative review over at PF - I don't think it's much of a surprise that the Tamron came out best. It represents extraordinarily good value at the moment compared to the Sigma, never mind the DA*. Hopefully this will serve as a wake up call for Pentax - it is about time they revamped or replaced the 16-50, given the mixed reviews it gets in tests and from users. There is a lot more unanimity about the excellence of the other DA* zooms (notwithstanding SDM issues), the 50-135 & 60-250 - so perhaps it is fair to characterise the 16-50 as something of a weak link.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Bad review for DA* 16-50mm at 09/10/2011 - 08:52

Dr. Mhuni
Was just downloading the latest update - should have waited till I had installed this (as the lenses are now there). Thanks Blythman, anyway.

What threw me was the fact that there were 645 profiles - I don't recall there being any Pentax ones when I first loaded LR, but I must have been mistaken.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lightroom profiles at 06/10/2011 - 09:44

Dr. Mhuni
I removed and reinstalled LR. Some Pentax profiles have reappeared, but unfortunately only those for 645 lenses. Can anyone offer any illumination on this?

I used to have profiles for DA lenses but somehow they've gone.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lightroom profiles at 06/10/2011 - 08:33

Dr. Mhuni
mikew wrote:


My great disappointment is that no real resolution has emerged after 14 pages of quite serious and sometimes heated discussion.

I'm waiting for the 7 days that's been mentioned to be up and see if both 'sides' can come to a mutual agreement and a valued member of the forum can return and we can all benefit from his contributions which in the main have been positive.

Good point about the seven days, Mike, though I fear that neither party has any interest in conciliation anymore (even if I hope otherwise).

This is a shame, as the incident has done much damage to PUF. One only has to see the thread on the other Forum started by PUFers announcing their migration there, which includes some extremely longstanding and well respected members, to register this. (I post no link because this might be deemed provocative).

George's point about a constructive lack of censorship in this thread might be valid. However, if all it's producing is hot air then so what?

One can only hope that lessons have been learned by all concerned.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Tim? at 22/09/2011 - 03:39

Dr. Mhuni
I'd also recommend the Tamron 17-50. I have both this and the DA17-70. While I've been very happy with the DA's performance over the last couple of years, I got the Tamron recently because I wanted f2.8, both for low light and to throw b/g's (which was often frustrating with the DA). I also thought as it had gone under £300 it was very good value, and got one with a view to comparing it with the DA and selling one on.

On the evidence so far (only had it a month or so), it is a very sharp lens - sharper than the DA, though I have no complaints about the DA. Colours are different, perhaps not quite as nice as Pentax ones but nothing to worry about and easily adjusted (if so desired). Bokeh was very nice on the DA, haven't really tested this much on the Tamron yet as I have used it mostly at a wide angle, but on the few longer shots wide open I have the Tammy looks good too. The extra stop I find very useful - I use it wide open a lot of the time and it performs well (though go down 1 or 2 stops and it's even better). Also, it's smaller than the DA - both in weight and dimensions. For an f2.8 zoom it's remarkably small - miles smaller than the DA*16-50 (77mm filters:shock, the size of which I find quite offputting.

The DA does have a nicer build and the extra 20mm is very useful. But I think it will be this, not the Tamron, that I sell on my next trip to the UK.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fixed or zoom? at 21/09/2011 - 07:01

Dr. Mhuni
I think the point that several people are making here, Giorgio, is that some things are better done publicly and not by PM.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Tim? at 17/09/2011 - 07:33

Dr. Mhuni
I appreciate that the moderator's role is a thankless one, John, and can even understand your emphasis on confidentiality (though IMO the absence of any proper explanation is self defeating here).

The problem is on available evidence my (and others') impression is that the initial 7 day ban was an over-reaction and has resulted in the loss to the forum of one of its most active and valuable contributors.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Tim? at 17/09/2011 - 05:03

Dr. Mhuni
I'm an optimist by nature, Mike.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Tim? at 16/09/2011 - 12:37

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo