Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I assumed that some would have been purchased at the SRS Pentax day. It's a disappointing result for Pentax if none were.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-01 user feedback at 22/03/2012 - 11:38

Dr. Mhuni
You're right, Robin - the 12-24 is a very practical walkaround lens. Very versatile in situations where you might be walking in, out of and around streets/buildings. It just lacks the zing of the DA15 IMO - and, to a lesser extent, the 21.

What I tend to travel with is a DA*50-135 and several primes from 15 to 50mm. One large zoom is all I want to carry around and I wouldn't want to leave the DA* behind. In addition, I can fit the K5 with a smaller prime in a case strapped to my belt when I want to go out unburdened.

I actually can't recall a time when I've felt the need for 12mm - though perhaps this is just because I've tuned my eye to what's available.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Would you swap a 12-24 for the DA15mm? at 21/03/2012 - 13:25

Dr. Mhuni
Yes, Mike, the thought had crossed my mind. Still I would have thought someone would have posted their first impressions of the K-01, if only to address its video capability.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-01 user feedback at 21/03/2012 - 13:02

Dr. Mhuni
My problem is that the DXO assessment doesn't seem to reflect either my experience of the lenses I have or the testing/user feedback I have seen for all the lenses.

For example, they complain about the resolution of the DA15, yet in my experience it is brutally sharp when stopped down (probably even sharper than the DA12-24, which is always praised for this characteristic) - a fact widely observed by both users and reviewers. With the DA40 they complain about lack of sharpness wide open - and yet this is directly contradicted by Photozone test results and by photos I have seen and by user feedback. I don't think you have to be a Pentax fanboy to wonder how DXO came to their conclusions?

But of course the bottom line is that mille19 and Jon are right - the test results only give you some idea about how a lens will perform in real life. The DA21 is a case in point - for a prime it generally gets lukewarm reviews. Vignetting, distortion, softness wide open are all problems. However, despite these failings, in practice it does produce very nice images.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on DXO test some Pentax Lenses at 21/03/2012 - 12:55

Dr. Mhuni
Sure, we know that we can expect a lot from the sensor, however, given that this camera represents a radical departure for Pentax (in all sorts of ways) I am surprised that there has been no new user discussion on PUF as yet.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-01 user feedback at 21/03/2012 - 11:59

Dr. Mhuni
I'm surprised that there has yet to be any feedback from any early adopters here at PUF. By this time in a Pentax product's life a lively discussion on its merits and demerits would usually be well established here. Is the lack of discussion of the K-01 an indication that the doubters were right?

Given that I would prefer to use my Pentax glass (small Ltd's in particular) fully functional - ie. without having to resort to an adapter - I really want to like the K-01, as a slightly smaller, more discrete (other than the yellow) alternative to the K5 for street shooting in particular. However, I'm far from convinced - so would be very interested to hear owners' impressions - particularly on size and handling, AF speed and LCD useability.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-01 user feedback at 21/03/2012 - 10:57

Dr. Mhuni
I agree - the DXO 'scores' do seem odd when compared to other tests (eg. the 40 produced high and even resolution from wide open in the Photozone test) and user feedback. I have the 15, 21 and 70 and have been very happy with the images produced by all three.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on DXO test some Pentax Lenses at 21/03/2012 - 10:22

Dr. Mhuni
I've got the 12-24 the DA15 & 21, and to answer the OP's question, yes.

The 12-24 is incredibly sharp and has a really useful range. It's a great zoom lens. But the CA is poor, and the colours aren't up to other Pentax lenses, as you've observed yourself Simon.

Both the Ltd's are very nice. Neither is as sharp as the 12-24 wide open, but both sharpen up a few stops down. I do find the wide open performance a bit disappointing (particularly when compared to the 12-24) - though the 15 in particular is at least sharp in the centre at f4. However, the colours from both are superb and the images they produce (if you get it right) also have that Ltd pop - which is lovely. Stopped down, the 15 in particular can produce amazing sharpness and 3D feel. The 12-24 images lack the distinctive character that both Ltds produce. The 15's reputation for shooting into the light is also well deserved - it outperforms the 12-24 (which can produce severe PF) substantially in this regard.

Alongside IQ, the key determinant must be useage - and the 15 (or 21) trumps the 12-24 here too AFAIC thanks to the diminutive size. Since getting the 15 & 21, I've hardly used my 12-24. Really, given the amount of use it currently gets, I should probably sell it - though I am loathe to offload what is in itself an excellent lens.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Would you swap a 12-24 for the DA15mm? at 21/03/2012 - 10:16

Dr. Mhuni
rparmar wrote:


What it "pretends" to be is a small, stabilised, weather-sealed body with two-dial ergonomics, IBIS, and optional grip... everything the K-01 isn't. The fact it's styled to look like an actual camera and not some sort of industrial accident is hardly detrimental. I'll assume from your dismissive comment that you don't realise the hump houses an EVF in exactly the right position, in line with the lens. It is a perfect example of form follows function.

You may well be right that the OM-D is the more functional camera (though might the larger size of the K-01 result in better handling?), but to my eye it's an ugly retro (little) beast. Aesthetically at least, the K-01 is refreshingly different from anything else out there. The more I see it the more I like it. Clearly beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-01 - Black Version? at 28/02/2012 - 06:38

Dr. Mhuni
I've had a DA17-70 for over three years and a DA*50-135 for almost one and have had no problems with either. In fact the 17-70 works better than ever on my K5.

I thought it was the older DA* lenses that had a serious problem with their SDM failing, not the 17-70? The latter can sometimes be hesitant - though as Mattmatic has noted, this is easily solved, and isn't really an issue on my K5.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on SDM Lenses at 26/02/2012 - 09:55

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo