Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
K10D wrote:

Well the expense does not come into the equation
If only were we are all so fortunate!

Still, if money was no object - though I would be tempted by the D700's low light ability in particular - I think I would still opt for the K5. What I like about the latter is how it manages to pack so much capability/flexibility into such a small package. Ideal for someone who shoots mostly street photography such as myself.

I do find it disappointing how the K5's merits as a street camera (particularly coupled with the DA Ltds) seem underappreciated - in contrast to, for eg., the ubiquitous X100. But then Pentax seem generally underappreciated by most photographers, so I guess this is just par for the course.

Do they emphasize the size (and its remarkable capability, given its diminutive profile) in K5 marketing? If not, they surely should. Living where I do, I haven't seen any Pentax advertising (just Canon, Nikon, Olympus, Sony...).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Will Pentax (and everyone else too) go Full Frame? at 17/02/2012 - 05:41

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
Not sure about the better pictures though. The IQ from my Pentax's is always excellent.
I hope you are noticing some benefits from your svelt D700, otherwise - as George and Pentaxophile observe - why put up with the expense and bulk?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Will Pentax (and everyone else too) go Full Frame? at 16/02/2012 - 05:21

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
My Sigma 70-200 f/2.8 on my K7 is effectively the same size as my 70-200 f/2.8 VR on the D7000.
But your 70-200 on APS-C is equivalent to 105-300 FF. I think this is what wvbarnes is getting at. As you've observed, it's not (so much of?) an issue with normal or even wider lenses (in fact FF can be beneficial with the latter) but once you start going tele the mass mounts. I'm very glad that one of my most used lenses is a 50-135 f2.8 and not a 70-200 f2.8 which come in at around twice the size (certainly weight-wise). I'm also glad to have a svelt K5 rather than a FF hulk, though FF IQ would sometimes be nice.

Quote:
Am I right in thinking that if(!) Pentax brought out a full frame sensor, we would not have a lot to worry about as all Pentax lenses would work on it. Unless, that is, Ricoh have changed the Pentax philosophy.
I'm afraid not, Walkeja. Although FF lenses made for Pentax film cameras will work on digital K-mounts, the DA lenses are specifically designed for APS-C and most wouldn't work with a FF sensor.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Will Pentax (and everyone else too) go Full Frame? at 15/02/2012 - 15:30

Dr. Mhuni
Pentaxophile wrote:
Aside from the visual aesthetics, some of the designs of the 70s and 80s are still pretty unbeaten when it comes to simple and intuitive controls, and ergonomics. That's why they're still enjoyable to use and a welcome break from more complex menu-driven digital cameras. I suspect that's also partly why the X100 and X-Pro1 appeal to enthusiasts looking to recreate that experience. As well as the nostalgia thing.
I'm sure you have a point. However, I was distinctly unimpressed with the handling of the X100, which I think is a direct result of the slim, retro body. The hand grip of (most) contemporary DSLRs is surely more functional than the old style flat bodies.

Re. styling - I think that whoever made the point (about 20 pages or more back - I don't fancy searching to see who:shock that praising the K5 for its good looks compared to a K-01 is actually quite ridiculous - at least from the perspective of the non-camera enthusiast. Our (ethusiasts) response to a DSLR is probably conditioned by our knowledge of its functions and also by our (subconscious) awareness of the historical evolution of this type of camera. But looked at rationally most, if not all, DSLRs are quite ugly, bumpy lumps of plastic and metal, beside which the K-01 (chimney, boxy top, garish buttons and all) is a model of elegance. This is certainly my wife's point of view.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 11/02/2012 - 08:06

Dr. Mhuni
You're right - not all 80s design is bad, but the OM-D doesn't look good IMO (then again I think the X100 is pretty dumb design wise, which most people don't). Not all 80s music is bad either but I'm mystified by the recent musical trend to refer back to what generally speaking was a pretty awful sounding decade - this looks to me like its photographic equivalent.

Noone said the K-01 would supercede the K5 in any shape or fashion.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 08/02/2012 - 07:20

Dr. Mhuni
Yes, I do reckon the next incarnation of the K-01 (if there is one!) will surely be a more compelling camera. They managed this with the K10/20 and K7/5, though the improvements were all internal, which won't be sufficient with any K-01 successor.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 08/02/2012 - 07:05

Dr. Mhuni
Yes, functionally it will probably be very good - and 2 dials and weather sealing are excellent, though of course you'll pay for these. But that pointy design looks awful to my eye, especially the fake SLR hump.

The K-01 does at least break new ground in camera design - even if, as is evident from this thread, plenty of people think it was ground that didn't need to be broken.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 08/02/2012 - 06:53

Dr. Mhuni
At least the K-01 doesn't look like this: link. Perhaps the OM-D will be a good camera functionally, but grief that 80s styling is hideous (have often been bemused by recent nostalgia for 80s design and culture - it was mostly a pretty dire decade in all sorts of ways IMO). OTOH it does have a viewfinder and an articulated screen.

The look of the K-01 is growing on me. Yes, the chimney stack that ends in the program dial is kind of odd. And from the top it looks very boxy. But in other respects - as long as it's not in yellow - I rather like it. And thank God Pentax haven't gone down the retro route. I understand I'm probably in a (tiny?) minority, but stylistically I find the Fuji X100 a ridiculous camera. It looks like it was made thirty or more years ago - surely design wise thinks have moved on since the days of the classic rangefinders. And its handling seems quite poor to me, partly as a result. The Olympus Pen on the other hand is a more elegant blend of old and new. The K-01 is like nothing else out there (perhaps for good reason:shock - though it does kind of resemble a 21st century take on later Kodak Brownies.

The size of the K-01 is, of course, an issue - it is so much bigger than its competitors. But I imagine that at least this will result in a camera that handles well (like most Pentax cameras). And the thought of being able to use Ltd. (and older K-mount) lenses without an adaptor on a compact(-ish) camera is very appealing (kudos to Pentax for apparently listening here - what with the announcement of long lenses, they seem to have been quite receptive of late). The lack of an EVF and articulated screen are big omissions, but I am increasingly curious about how the K-01 will perform and handle.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 08/02/2012 - 05:44

Dr. Mhuni
I was reserving judgment until I got some idea of size from a side by side comparison with an existing DSLR. It's not looking good:

link

So you have a camera which is only marginally smaller than the K5 (while slightly less tall and wide, the K-01 even looks a bit deeper than the K5) - apart from those protusions on the K5 that contain such useful things as a viewfinder and grip.

Pentax certainly do things differently, but might this be another Q-type mistake? The guy at Imaging Resource seems to think so, and having seen those DPreview images I'm inclined to agree with him (though of course you need to handle it to get a real idea of size).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax K-01 at 02/02/2012 - 13:33

Dr. Mhuni
I know what you mean but it is quite easy to avoid the totty shots if you just opt to go to specific categories rather than all images (other than Fashion/Nude). I spend most of my time in 'Street' and 'Black and white' which are - most of the time - thoroughly respectable!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Review time in PPG at 05/01/2012 - 06:36

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo