Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
George Lazarette wrote:


I would say that there has been a decline in standards. At one time, people were in awe of the PPG, and were disinclined to flood it with second-rate pictures. Now every man and his dog seems to think his snapshots are worth submitting. And these photographers get to vote on what gets in.

Quality and quantity are seldom found together. The PPG needs a cull, and it needs to raise entry standards. Otherwise it will continue to be what it has unfortunately become - a huge collection of not very good pictures which do no credit to Pentax, and which I am unable to commend to friends who ask for evidence that Pentax equipment can produce superlative images.

This is a general observation, not aimed at anybody here.

G
I agree. I reckon the decline probably started around the time I started to submit - not sure if there is any connection. Before the revamp I ended up with 160+ images of which perhaps a handful (at best) should really have been in a proper Pentax prestige collection. Since the revamp, I changed my name and started afresh submitting 9 images which all got in, which I took as a bad sign (I might have liked them all to varying degrees but I do realise my judgment is inevitably subjective).

So I shifted my attention to 500px, which for now I'm finding more satisfying. The quality of the shots that rank highly there are usually of a good standard (often gobsmacking). Perhaps a few too many 'glamour' shots, nude and otherwise (but then many would say that's not a problem:wink. The way 500px is broken down into categories means you can get exposure to a community with similar photographic interests to your own, which is great.

If PPG was to become less of a free for all and more of a challenge, I'd probably start submitting again, but an opportunity to do this was missed with the revamp and I can't see it happening now.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Review time in PPG at 05/01/2012 - 03:22

Dr. Mhuni
I guess this thread is made for my input, given I have owned the DA17-70, DA55-300 & Tamron 17-50; and I live in Sri Lanka.

Re. the lenses - I always found the 55-300 a very useful range (prior to upgrading to an f2.8 lens) and a decent performer. And it's remarkably small given the focal lengths it covers. As such it is a good travel lens. Though if you really think the focal length isn't for you, then there's no point having it weighing down the bag. I'd be surprised if you didn't find it useful at some point - even if restricting yourself to landscape and architecture it could be useful for detail shots. BTW don't send it back to Amazon whatever you do - you will almost certainly get more from selling it here or on ebay (assuming you got the offer price at Amazon).

The DA17-70's a great lens and the range is very useful indeed, while IQ wise it's definitely a step up from the kit lens. On my K20 it could occasionally be a bit reticent focusing beyond 50mm, but this was solved by lightly placing your finger on the focus ring.

I ended up getting the Tamron to replace the 17-70, as I wanted a faster lens for throwing b/g's and low light. The Tamron is probably slightly superior in most respects apart from colour (where the DA is a bit more appealing). It's definitely sharper - brutally sharp in fact. I'd say that alongside the DA35 f2.4 it's the biggest bargain among new lenses for Pentax at the moment, punching way above it's comparatively modest price. It's also amazingly compact (smaller than the DA despite the wider max aperture). If I had to choose again between this and the DA17-70 I'd go for this, regardless of price (though admittedly the extra 20mm might make the former a better travel lens, depending on what your priority is).

I'd also definitely take the 50 f1.7 for low light stuff (I'm always shooting low light stuff here)

Re. Sri Lanka - in the Cultural Triangle, my faves are Polonaruwa and Anuradhapura, both extensive abandoned ruined capitals with some phenomenal extant structures among the tropical vegetation. Sigiriya's nice too - though only if you have a head for heights (there's a sheer drop of about 2-300ft with just a metal rail between you and it). Forget Dambulla, particularly if you can go to the similar, more low key and more scenic, Mulgirigalla (near Dikwella on the south coast).

Kandy and the surrounding area is nice.

The tea country around Nuwara Elliya is stunning. Nuwara Elliya itself definitely isn't! Ella definitely is.

The south and west coasts have loads of desirable beachside destinations - and Galle which has a wonderful old Fort area. The east around Trincomalee sounds cool, though I've yet to get there.

The parks can be nice - though don't expect African type experiences.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New walkaround lens for Sri Lanka at 30/12/2011 - 11:11

Dr. Mhuni
Pentaxophile wrote:
Dr. Mhuni wrote:
It just seems so obvious I can't understand why it hasn't been done already. I guess there must be reasons.
I think one of the problems must be the need for a converter to provide the correct registration distance on a NEX-type mirrorless body - this would turn those lovely pancakes lenses into bloaters! Pentax would need to introduce at least some new lenses specifically designed for mirrorless, and sadly the competition is way ahead of them at this point - hence why they went in a totally different direction with the Q. (It was a similar story for Nikon).

Hopefully Pentax can pull something new and surprising out of the bag though!
Aha, of course Pentaxophile - that's why. There goes my dream!

I had forgotten that 4/3 lenses need an adapter to work on m4/3.

Looks like I will have to consider Sony or Samsung then, if Pentax don't get their act in gear. Do the K-mount adaptors for the NEX/NX provide full functionality with Pentax lenses?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A (Very) Fond Farewell to Pentax at 08/12/2011 - 06:15

Dr. Mhuni
lemmy wrote:
Quote:
Imagine what kind of reception a Pentax rangefinder type camera, with interchangeable lenses and the kind of IQ you get with a K5 or KR, would have had
A Pentax rangefinder/ EVF hybrid viewfinder that would take the pancake lenses

What a brilliant idea because the lenses already exist so a ready made market worldwide for such a camera.

Yes please! Where can I pay my deposit?
Lemmy, I think the queue would be pretty long for a compact Pentax aps-c camera. Not only consisting of current Pentaxians either - I think the Pentax primes have quite a good reputation already beyond Pentaxland, and releasing a small camera with which they could be used would draw more attention to them. The 15-70 range of quality primes would look pretty damned attractive to street shooters of all persuasions.

Personally, I hope - if they do finally produce something along these lines - that Pentax go more down the Fuji (slightly larger, with in-built viewfinder) route rather than the Sony/Samsung one. The NEX/NX do seem to be trying to pack too much into too little, and I imagine their handling isn't ideal. I also think that the Pentax would compete particularly well in the enthusiast market that Fuji is targeting. Pentax primes would perhaps be more suited to that end of the market than the consumer end that some of the current compact lenses are aimed at. They would of course need some new zooms, and I guess cheaper primes could be introduced in time (to join the 35 f2.4, which is already cheap and well thought of).

It just seems so obvious I can't understand why it hasn't been done already. I guess there must be reasons. Though how do you explain all the R&D time and money wasted on the Q alternative?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A (Very) Fond Farewell to Pentax at 07/12/2011 - 10:10

Dr. Mhuni
I've got to add to grumblings from others here about Pentax's sluggishness in developing a compact aps-c camera. Anyone with the brain the size of a pea could have worked out that, what with the Pentax range of diminutive primes, this was a wise commercial move ages ago. But from an aps-c point of view their thunder has been stolen by Sony, Samsung and Fuji. Meanwhile, the 4/3 market is really very well-developed by now.

Fuji's X100 has gone down a storm despite having a fixed lens and a high price tag. Imagine what kind of reception a Pentax rangefinder type camera, with interchangeable lenses and the kind of IQ you get with a K5 or KR, would have had. Hopefully they are not too late. Though if I'm not mistaken, they have a (recent) track record of being late - having lost market share to Canikon in the shift to digital.

As Mecrox points out the Q is merely a toe in the water. And a little toe at that.

I quite understand your decision to move Lemmy. I was quite impressed by the Panasonic too. I am keeping an eye on the compact systems, though ideally I want to use my Pentax primes (without an adapter). And tbh the handling of the K5 is superb, and it is itself pretty diminutive - particularly for the amount of control it allows. Look what Pentax can do when they put their minds to it - hopefully whoever was responsible for putting a Q ahead of an aps-c compact has been moved in the recent Ricoh takeover.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A (Very) Fond Farewell to Pentax at 07/12/2011 - 06:16

Dr. Mhuni
Interesting to hear your experience. I have the 15 and 21 which I bought about the same time with a view to moving one on when I'd decided which suited my needs best. It will probably be the 21, because like you I find it a little wide for normal use. Though it's a nice lens, which performs well particularly when stopped down, and it's size is just amazing. The 15 is even wider, of course, but that's the whole point - and f4 isn't so much of an issue at that focal length.

I think you're right about the gaps in the range. I think ideally I'd like something around 24-28 for normal use, which Pentax don't currently make. Something really fast in that range would be great. Are you listening Pentax... or rather Ricoh.

Getting in to the 30s - another lens you might consider is a s/h FA35 f2. I think I'm right in saying this is regarded as the poor man's 31 Ltd. It performs well from wide open, is very sharp, and produces good colours and contrast. The DA35 f2.4 is based on it, and is likewise a good performer I understand (not had one as I have the FA) - though you lose 1/2 a stop (which I'm keen on) and it's a plastic mount. It's a snip at £134. The FA will turn up s/h somewhere if you're patient.

I did the same as you with the DFA100 - sold it and bought a DA70 and haven't regretted it at all. The DFA is a superb lens with amazing colours and sharpness, but it's not the most practical lens for non-macro stuff (my area) and is larger (though not large by macro standards). The DA70 is superb and so compact - I use it indoors and at night and it's a brilliant performer.

I also recently was tempted by the excellent price of the Tamron 17-50 and it has at least met my high expectations based on photos of others I'd admired over the years. If it was smaller I'd consider getting rid of my primes between 15-35 (not my fast 50). It really is an excellent performer, and even remarkably compact for a fast standard zoom.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax Lens System choices: 21 limited 43 limited 100 macro at 28/11/2011 - 04:58

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks for the comments all.

David - I won't get in any trouble if I post the shot and explanation here. I might if it was somewhere that would attract attention. An acquaintance was deported last year for saying the wrong thing to a journalist. You do have to mind your p's and q's - but generally speaking the government's only really bothered if you're broadcasting unfiltered information within Sri Lanka.

The government really got its knockers in a twist about that documentary when it was broadcast in the UK, Pentaxophile. They always do when something even vaguely critical is said about Sri Lanka, and that was a lot more than vaguely critical. It rattled cages even though people here couldn't see it. As usually happens here, in its wake various Sri Lankan experts were trotted out to observe how the war crimes allegations were simply more evidence of a gigantic western conspiracy. The thing these observers always omit is why 'the West' would be so concerned about a tiny spec off the southeast coast of India.

Sri Lankan politics is a nasty business - murderous even without a civil war going on. The paradox is that Sri Lankan people are overwhelmingly friendly and courteous. To outsiders at least - I understand there is a great deal of envy and suspicion in local communities which maybe is the root of the problem.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Loser at 19/11/2011 - 07:47

Dr. Mhuni
Comment Image


This is former General Sareth Fonseka who has been convicted today to a sentence of three years on a charge of ‘spreading disaffection’.

He was head of the Sri Lankan army when the Tamil Tigers were finally, after 20 years, defeated in May 2009. Later in 2009 he left the army and had the temerity to run a strong campaign against the well entrenched Sri Lankan president, Mahinda Rajapaksa, in a December election. Days after losing the election he was arrested by Rajapaksa’s regime, and subsequently court-martialled and stripped of his rank. He has been in jail ever since.

Today’s conviction arose from remarks he had made suggesting that government politicians (including the president’s brother) had been complicit in war crimes towards the end of the civil war. Most people outside of Sri Lanka believe the regime was complicit in war crimes. Most people inside Sri Lanka only have access to state controlled or censored media.

Given that he was head of the army at the end of the war, it is quite possible (probable even) that Fonseka also has blood on his hands, and that he only raised the issue for political ends. Such is the nature of Sri Lankan politics. Although he has been in jail for the past two years and likely will be for many more, Fonseka is at least more fortunate than the political cartoonist Prageeth Eknelygoda who went missing in the wake of the election on 24th January 2010. His wife and children haven't seen him since.

This photo was taken in the days following the election.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Loser at 18/11/2011 - 11:11

Dr. Mhuni
I like 1 a lot. The rest of them are okay, but pretty much what you'd expect from gig pics. But 1 is very unusual, and all the better for it. But then I'm a sucker for dimly lit shots.

Perhaps crop a little off the right?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K-5, FA43 & 77 and a K50 f/1.2 @ a gig at 27/10/2011 - 13:03

Dr. Mhuni
1-6

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Another pointless thread at 24/10/2011 - 06:23

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo