All Forum Comments
Comment by Anvh posted on K-r magnified live view screen at 24/07/2011 - 10:57
Read the manual is all i can say.
Comment by Anvh posted on K-r magnified live view screen at 23/07/2011 - 22:31
Comment by Anvh posted on Built in shake reduction. Does this really works? at 23/07/2011 - 18:28
I've not done the math but it could be that it will work very well for that, so it might work when you use 1/3th of the way of the focus scale instead of focusing in the scene.
But still this rule isn't to calculate the hyper focal distance and i can not believed it was ever advertised that way, but nobody claimed it was here though, but it was what the OP was asking for.
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 23/07/2011 - 18:20
Since the rule of thumb doesn't work i find it wrong to give the rule of thumb as a fact or good bases to beginners, it's better to learn it correct or not at all then learning the wrong thing.
If the rule of thumb gets close then it's indeed useful but this never come close.
I'm actually very curious which books and articles actually give this as an rule of thumb, do you've some examples because i never came across one, well i did but i won't count them as reputable.
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 23/07/2011 - 18:10
It's for deep focus landscape shots. Who would ever use this for portraits? I'm usually more worried about too much dof there, not too little.
As for the landscapes 1/3th is simply too much.
If you want a rule of thumb use this one for hyprefocal distance for lenses below 20mm
focal length / aperture = roughly the hyper focal distance (or at least you will go over it)
With lenses over 20mm this formula will fall too short so you can't use it for those
Don't you thrust me, do the calculation with 20mm and it will be bang on
Also a warning, this is for APS-C and also roughly for 135formatt but with medium formatt lenses you should check it first.
For the 55-100 lens this is at least not usable, sorry.
ps. For 55mm you could maybe just use it if you use 1/3th or 1/2 of a stop smaller aperture.
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 23/07/2011 - 17:30
I know, if I don't pop up the flash, it won't fire, but is there a setting where you can tell the camera to keep the flash off and bump the ISO/slow the shutter.
You may get a warning that the camera wants to use the flash but if you don't pop-up it it will meter like normally.
So there is no need for an off setting.
When the flash is down the flash is off.
If i've read the article correctly, the third rule will result in too conservative (too close) a hyperfocal distance. However this is better than merely focussing on or near infinity, and definitely better than focussing too close.
Like said the rule only works when focus is 1:2 but with portaits it's still almost 1:1 so the rule should be that you focus half way into the scene then.
Look here under DOF versus distance
http://toothwalker.org/optics/dof.html
The more perfect you want your hyperfocal distance to be, the more care and precision you would need to take or you might end up focusing too close. That would mean charts and calculations which wouldn't be appropriate for most of up in the field. Therefore as a belt and braces 'rule of thumb' approach, it still seems to be more than reasonable.
The most times you want to use hyperfocal distance you'll be working from a tripod meaning that the objections for putting time into finding the hyperfocal length become less severe.
Also the rule doesn't sate which aperture to use so if you want to know that you need to look it up...
Or we just be very practical and use the optical preview
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 23:27
You're at variance with sixty years of photographic experience Stefan, so the weight of decades of literature is not with you.
You've done nothing to support the 1/3th rule you say is true so is it therefore wrong for me to question it?
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 23:07
Thanks for the math John but you didn't use the rule of thumb.
So when will you use the 1/3th rule, give us an example because all the examples i gave don't work.
Also what f-number is there to be used, it isn't giving by the rule and to use f/16 for eveything is a bit over the top...
Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 22:35


Now I've looked in the manual and can't see anywhere about the focus confirm symbol/bleep in live view with manual focus. Same with catch-in-focus, both only seem to work with viewfinder.
The contrast AF used in liveview might be the limiting factor here.