Anvh

Joined: 4th July 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Anvh
johnriley wrote:
Nobody needs to go to those lengths when there is a well established rule of thumb that works.
I actually have a serious question about the rule.
If i want for example 8 meters to infinite in focus, then at what distance should i focus?
Call me stupid but i don't know what 1/3th of that is

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 22:23

Anvh
Ah sorry, didn't read it well

There is no rule of thumbs for focusing because there are to many variables.
There is no way you can get focal length, aperture, focus distance, circle of confusion in an easy package.

For most subjects you simply focus on the subject so there is no need for a thumbs of rule.
For landscapes you could use a hyperfocal chart like this one.
(this chart is for APS-C)
Comment Image


It's quite simple.
- pick the focal length at the bottom
- move up till you hit the correct f-number line
- move to the right to read the hyper focal value
- as a rule of thumb, the focus begins roughly at half the hyper focal distance.

I wished the camera had a hyper focal switch that simply put your lens on it.

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 22:10

Anvh
But it isn't a rule of thumb, because it doesn't even come close to what is true or general correct.

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 21:54

Anvh
johnriley wrote:
The point is made that everything would be within the DOF.
But how it is done is simply to crude, it's like trapping a mouse with an elephant trap...

johnriley wrote:
If it didn't work, then generations of photographers would have been wrong.
It simply doesn't work, not even in general.

The one third rule is based on the false fact that 1/3th of the focus is infront fo the focus point and that 2/3th of the focus is behind it but that's never the case.

here is an quote that explains it.

The rear DOF is twice the front DOF.
This is just a very silly statement. In the macro regime the DOF distribution (front:rear) is 1:1, in the portrait regime it is still close to 1:1, and a landscape captured at hyperfocus will have a distribution of 1:infinity. Somewhere in between there will be a scenario that gives 1:2, but you will have to look for it. Perhaps the misconception is due to the observation that a 1:2 distribution represents some kind of average over many photographic situations. So much is clear, every scenario should be considered individually.

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 21:33

Anvh
Algernon wrote:
Aren't Bean Bags Brilliant!
You can also fit a gyro under the camera http://www.ken-lab.com/

This what you get http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtBlrF5s6Is

Comment by Anvh posted on Built in shake reduction. Does this really works? at 22/07/2011 - 20:46

Anvh
dcweather wrote:
Or can we just say that monopods and tripods always produce a different oscillating frequency so always turn off?
I think you can say that but it's still not sure it's the oscillating frequency that's the problem
But with a tripod it's safe to stay it's stable enough that you don't need it so it's safer to just put it off. With a monopod though i would leave it on personally, because the monopod is always moving slightly.

Comment by Anvh posted on Built in shake reduction. Does this really works? at 22/07/2011 - 20:44

Anvh
Thanks John for explaining

johnriley wrote:
This is a simple "rule of thumb" (approximation if you like) for getting as much of a scene in focus as possible.
It's not even an approximation, just do the math with what you just said.
You will need to try very hard to get an example where the rule will work.

If you'll use a 55mm lens at f/16 and you focus on 60 feet to get 30 to 120 feet in focus you're really way off... you can use f/2 if you focus at 50 feet...
With f/16 and 55mm you can get 5,4 feet to infinity in focus if you focus at 10,5 feet.
If you focus at 10 feet the distribution of the dof will be 3/97 so not even close to 1/2.

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 20:32

Anvh
John what is the full offical rule because you state two different things in your comments.

-simply focus one third of the way into the scene-
vs
-using small apertures at moderate distances-

I'm getting a bit lost


ps. a more recent article about why the third rule doesn't work.
http://www.cameratechnica.com/2011/06/12/alternatives-to-the-one-third-rule-for-...

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 19:49

Anvh
With this you can make a hyperfocal distance chart.
http://www.dofmaster.com/charts.html

Banjo wrote:
As you can plainly see, focusing one third into the scene doesn't really cut it.
It's almost never true this rule so i'm curious where it comes from?
With Macro photography for example you actually have a DOF spread of 1:1.

Here is a whole read about it.
http://toothwalker.org/optics/dof.html

Comment by Anvh posted on Focussing a 55-100mm zoom on a P67ii body at 22/07/2011 - 19:23

Anvh
jps wrote:
Has anyone seen Tree of Life?
I've seen it in Orlando at Disney's animal kingdom, it really looked magnification.

Comment by Anvh posted on Has anyone seen... at 22/07/2011 - 17:47

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo