RichardDay

Joined: 19th May 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

RichardDay
A short while back in a discussion about long telephoto lenses I promised to compare cropped shots from the DA*60-250 against uncropped shots from the Sigma 150-500.

I managed to do a short test during the Pentax Day at Clifton Cameras on Dec 12th.

You will notice from my results that the cropped 60-250 shots have greater DOF due to the 250mm focal length as opposed to the 500mm focal length shots from the Sigma. This, the loss of 1.3 stops, plus it's considerable size and weight (I can fit my 60-250 into my shoulder bag, no way with the Sigma! :shock, was enough to prevent me from getting the Sigma as well as (IMO) the better colour and contrast from the DA*. It was also interesting to find that the Sigma's HSM AF system was no quicker than the SDM AF of the DA*60-250.

I know the Sigma is not as expensive as the DA*60-250 (now), but it just shows what an exceptional lens the DA*60-250 is. I must admit that the Sigma exceded my expectations, it is a nice lens, unfortunately the shop didn't have the Sigma 120-400 in Pentax mount for me to try. I hope to do some more comparisons at SRS when they hold their new store open day.

The only reason I can see to get the Sigma would be for shots that would require more than a 2x crop where the resolution drops below an acceptable level for A4 prints (3.6MP from a K20D/K-7 sensor), or for larger prints.

The DA*60-250 shot is a 1800 x 1200 crop from a 100% shot, the Sigma was resized to 1800 x 1200 to make a fair comparison (click on images for full size versions), both taken at f8.0, ISO 100, K20D on tripod with 2 sec (mirror up) delay.

Sigma at 500mm @ f8.0

Comment Image


DA*60-250 at 250mm @ f8.0

Comment Image

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 27/12/2009 - 16:17

RichardDay
simonkit wrote:
JonSchick wrote:
Hi Simon - I came to the same conclusion as you with the Sigma and it lives with another forum member now! I bought a 16-45 which goes wide enough for me, but can see the attraction of the 12-24. Another option might be to buy the 15mm DA Ltd to stick in your pocket for the odd occasion when 17mm is not wide enough?
Hi Jon,

Pity it didn't meet your needs either. I have considered the prime option but having read a few reviews the DA 12-24 seems to be at least of equal quality to the 14/15mm options, with the added flexibility.

One reason I'm considering the 12-24 is that whilst I'm very pleased with the DA 17-70 it does show some distortion around 17mm, the DA 12-24 I believe is distortion free in the 15-20mm range which sounds quite appealing

thanks

Simon
Simon

I've just added the 12-24 (D-Xenon) to my lens collection after having two 10-20 Siggy's and returning both. I tried some Tamron 10-24's as SRS had ten to choose from, but I ended up with a s/h 12-24 which was better than even the best of the Tamrons, as they do have some distortion at all F/L's and the micro contrast was not as good as the 12-24.

I still use my DA 17-70 much more, but the colour and overall IQ of the 12-24 is very similar and I felt much happier with the lens, plus the construction and QS just put the icing on the cake.

Hope you find one at a reasonable price!

EDIT - The 12-24 is very free from distortion from around 14mm up, even at 12mm it's very low and easily correctable.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Considering UWA (again) at 27/12/2009 - 10:56

RichardDay
Lance, you're a cheapskate!

I agree that the K-x has some minor but very important feature ommissions, the most significant for me would be lens AF adjustments. I'm waiting to see what Pentax annouce next in the APS DSLR department.

Hope you had a great Christmas. Did Santa bring you any new goodies?

Comment by RichardDay posted on Gave my daughter a white K-x for Christmas at 26/12/2009 - 12:21

RichardDay
The best CRT's are better, but the average CRT is pretty poor. Unfortunately CRT's are now virtually obsolete and not generally available.

As others have said IPS and some PVA displays are the best for photo use.

For a mid priced high performance 24" 1920 x 1200 IPS monitor I would recommend the HP LP2475 LINK

It has very good reviews LINK, like all monitors, it is essential to calibrate properly.

I use an HP LP2065 monitor which is basically similar but with a 1600 x 1200 20.1" 4x3 screen.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Monitors for photo work at 26/12/2009 - 12:17

RichardDay
Hi Lance.

Raiding your lens cupboard would easily cover the cost of my air fare! Hmmm...

I tried a K-x in direct comparison with the K-7 a couple of weeks back, it certainly produces great low noise images and is easy to use. I wonder how long it will be before you get one to complement your K-7?

Comment by RichardDay posted on Gave my daughter a white K-x for Christmas at 26/12/2009 - 11:41

RichardDay
Phew!

Really pleased that it arrived in time for Christmas! Have a great one.

Comment by RichardDay posted on National Geographic Midi, Medium & Large bags for sale at 25/12/2009 - 10:31

RichardDay
Welcome to the gang!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Hello from the Wirral at 23/12/2009 - 15:08

RichardDay
Welcome to the gang!

Comment by RichardDay posted on Hello from Hants at 23/12/2009 - 15:06

RichardDay
Lance B wrote:
Hey Richard, a macro as well? Wow, you're really splashing out.

Anyway, congrats on the 2 new lenses.
Hi Lance, not splashing out, well not really!

I've wanted a 100mm macro since my istD days to complement my FA50 macro, which, as you know, I've had from my pre-digital days.

Plus, as you know, I only go for primes when they're macro's. The 100mm enables me to step back from the bugs and stops me stepping on the flower beds!

I've resisted from buying one due to the cost, as even the pre-increase price was a bit steep, but this deal was financially acceptable!

A high performing ultra wide has also been on my radar for a similar period. As you know I was dissapointed with the two Sigma 10-24's I had right after we met up in France in 2006. I tried the DA 12-24 very shortly afterwards and even though it was superior in every way, for various reasons I never pulled the trigger on one.

The Tamron 10-24 reawakened my interest, but the 12-24 was again so much better I decided to buy an unmarked s/h D-Xenon from SRS a few days ago. Unfortunately it was more expensive than the new ones Park have on offer at the moment! But then, isn't that always the way?!

Comment by RichardDay posted on New Samsung 12-24 bargain at 23/12/2009 - 15:00

RichardDay
pnjmcc wrote:
RichardDay wrote:
They also have the 100mm macro for £269.99. I just ordered one, I just hope they have some left!
Just rang them, 11 left apparently. One of which will be arriving at my mums house tomorrow

Dam you RichardDay for bring this to my attention
I've been after a macro lens for ages

Has yours arrived yet?

Regards
PaulM
Indeed it has! Very nice too.

Comment by RichardDay posted on New Samsung 12-24 bargain at 23/12/2009 - 14:30

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo