RichardDay

Joined: 19th May 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

RichardDay
Oggy wrote:
I wonder how things shape up ad the object of interest gets smaller/further away and pixel size starts to become significant.
No contest past a 2x crop (equals about 3.6MP on a K20D/K-7 sensor), a longer lens will win due to the reduction in pixel count.

In fact I try to keep below a 2x crop if at all possible, 1.5x gives around a 6MP image which is probably a practical limit, certainly for A3 prints.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 29/12/2009 - 11:26

RichardDay
Daniel Bridge wrote:
RichardDay wrote:
...they do differ due to the...different image content due to the different angular FOV.
If you were shooting from the same place, then cropping the Pentax down, you would get the same field of view (and I would think, the same DoF) as the Sigma. As both field of view is wider, and the background more in focus, I would assume you were actually standing nearer to the sign when you took the Pentax shot. Any thoughts?

Dan
I can see what you're saying about the FOV, but I'm certain I shot from the same location.

I set my tripod in roughly the same place (there wasn't that much room to move in the street outside the shop) and I just switched lenses, but I may have moved more to the right with the Sigma shot. Here are (resized) images of the 2 full shots and you can see that the sign in the Sigma shot is twice the size of the DA shot, indicating that it was shot from a similar distance.

Sigma shot

Comment Image


DA* shot

Comment Image


However, the DOF will definitely be different, it's comparable to using a smaller sensor camera which gives a greater DOF for the same image size. You can check the EXIF in the shots.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 28/12/2009 - 19:30

RichardDay
I usually take most of my gear (K20D, 12-24, 17-70, 60-250, 50 & 100 macros, Metz 54 flash, cards & batts etc.) with me in my "moderately" (:wink large Billingham 307 bag and my Giottos CF tripod plus head lives in the car boot in an old Jessops tripod bag.

Comment Image


I also have a Flipside 300 backpack, the large (huge!) National Geographic shoulder bag, a couple of smaller bags, a top loading holster and some waist bags, but don't use them that much. They are all either up for sale, or shortly will be.

I find that I can fairly comfortably carry the Billy slung across my body for considerable periods and it's very easy to work from, but my tripod bag is less convenient, so I'm considering either some tripod straps for the Billy (but that may make it very awkward), or maybe a tripod sling strap with a soft sleeve to protect it from scuffs and scratches but I haven't found one yet. Any suggestions?

I also have a ThinkTank shoulder harness which I can use if I need to carry the Billy like a backpack, it's ugly but it works.

Comment by RichardDay posted on What do you carry with you when you go out to photograph? at 28/12/2009 - 19:02

RichardDay
iceblinker wrote:
Good, but that's only ISO 200. By "noisier", I was thinking of ISO 800 and above.
I did some more today when we went for a walk at Canop Ponds in the Forest of Dean. I didn't shoot any at ISO 800, but here is a shot of a European Robin taken handheld with my K20D and DA*60-250 at 250mm, 1/640 sec at f4.0 with SR on.

Shot Raw at ISO 400 and pushed 1/2 stop (effective ISO 560) in Silkypix Pro, cropped by 50% to 2336 x 1552 pix (i.e. 500mm equiv FOV), processed to 16bit TIFF Adobe RGB, settings were "Strong contrast" and No sharpness". Further PP in Photoshop CS2 with slight NR with Neat Image Pro+/plug in and Smart sharpened by 150% and 1 pix. Saved as highest quality sRGB JPEG.

Click on the image for a full size version.

Comment Image


Hope you like it.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 28/12/2009 - 16:14

RichardDay
pink wrote:
Thank you
Richard that could of been a costly mistake will do more research today

I am after a 24" monitor

James
Unfortunately, all IPS monitors tend to be more expensive, some of the newer PVA screens are quite good, but again they are more expensive than TN screens. A good guide to the screen type used is that the TN and cheaper screens tend to have a glossy black reflective surface, high brightness ratios and fast response times, typically, a 1000:1, 5ms screen spec will probably mean a TN type, another guideline is the viewing angle, TN screens tend to have a poorer quoted angle, often in the region of 160 deg, in reality it usually appears much worse, the colours falling off rapidly. PVA's are somewhere in between as a compromise to get better viewing angles and colour with a high contrast ratio and faster response times, IMO they still don't compare with a decent IPS screen, especially the latest S-IPS or H-IPS types.

The HP LP2475W is really one of the best reasonably priced 24" H-IPS screens, some of the Dell screens are IPS, but they have been known to mix panels for the same version of monitor.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Monitors for photo work at 28/12/2009 - 09:53

RichardDay
pink wrote:
I have found this monitor, it's an IPS panel link

if this is any good or if any one is running it and can give advice to
sophiecentaur

James

I to am after a new monitor and would like to here your views on the monitor I have listed.
That monitor is a TN panel, read the spec carefully, it says - Panel Type (TN, IPS) - TN (The bracketed types are for guidance as to which types exist, the unbracketed is the actual type).

Comment by RichardDay posted on Monitors for photo work at 27/12/2009 - 21:31

RichardDay
I very rarely shoot at ISO 800 if I can help it as the IQ drops away badly, that's why I prefer a faster, very sharp lens. When I was shooting with my DA 55-300 I had to use f8.0 to get acceptable sharpness and that meant using ISO 800. With the 60-250 I get much better sharpness and micro contrast at f4.0 than the 55-300 at f8.0 (or even F11), so I can use that benefit to shoot at ISO 200.

If I was using the Sigma I would loose at least 1 stop, so that would mean ISO 400 if I used the same shutter speed, which would be pushing it handheld with that lens, even with SR I would probably have to shoot at 1/250 or higher which means another stop or more lost, so I'm back to square one, probably worse!

It's difficult enough to capture small birds with the 60-250 without handshake or blur due to their quick movements at lowish shutter speeds. I don't think that a slower longer lens would be of any help to me at all for the majority of my long lens shooting, what you may gain in one area you seem to loose out in another, sometimes much more than you'd expect. Certainly having the higher resolution of the K20D or K-7 helps when cropping, as they say "every little helps!"

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 27/12/2009 - 21:26

RichardDay
iceblinker wrote:
The cropping wouldn't look so good for a darker and noisier image, would it?

Also I like the shallow DOF of the Sigma shot above.
Well, judge for yourself.

Here's a couple of shots I took about a month ago, both handheld at 250mm, cropped quite heavily from the originals shown, the EXIF is intact in the cropped shots (click on the cropped images for the 100%size).

A pair of Great Tits. - 1/160 at f5.0 ISO 200

Full shot (resized)

Comment Image


Cropped from above (click on image for 100%)

Comment Image


A Nuthatch - 1/160 sec at f5.0 ISO 200

Full shot (resized)

Comment Image


Cropped from above (click on image for 100%)

Comment Image

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 27/12/2009 - 20:54

RichardDay
johnriley wrote:
That depends on what has been done to each image in Photoshop. As regards crispness, the Pentax shot is significantly better. The contrast and saturation can be adjusted to anything we like.
The shots were not photoshopped in any way. They are straight from Silkypix DS Pro output with the same settings for contrast, saturation and sharpness

The Sigma over exposed compared to the DA* (1/8 sec compared to 1/25 sec, it's all in the images EXIF), I adjusted the exposure in Silkypix to give approximately the same histogram spread for each shot, but they do differ due to the difference in the colour and contrast of the two lenses, plus the different image content due to the different angular FOV. The Sigma shot has more initial impact due to the shallower DOF at 500mm compared to 250mm, but is significantly less sharp and has a more muted colour and contrast for the same settings. I agree that contrast and saturation can be adjusted in PP'ing, but I was not trying to do any significant PP adjustments.

For me, I find that the DOF at 250mm and around f5.6 is very shallow, and a shallower DOF, narrower angle of view and increased weight all adds up to make my birding photography even more difficult than it is!

The object of the excercise was to satisfy myself that having a longer, slower lens would not bring any major benefit to my telephoto shooting. With the British light at this time of year I need all the lens speed I can get, as I frequently shoot wide open at f4.0 at a low ISO and use a slower shutter speed than I could with a 500mm lens.

I am not decrying the Sigma in any way, I will say that the performance of the Sigma even wide open at 500mm was excellent, it was very little different than at f8. What continually amazes me however, is the performance of the DA*60-250, it's one heck of a versatile lens and even at the new higher prices can't be considered excessively expensive considering it's superb optical performance.

I do intend to do a similar comparison with the Sigma 120-400 HSM as that is an interesting tele-zoom lens and is not expensive either.

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 27/12/2009 - 20:24

RichardDay
:: In what way?

Comment by RichardDay posted on Cropped DA*60-250 v. Sigma 150-500 results at 27/12/2009 - 16:41

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo