OldTaffy

Joined: 1st January 2011

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

OldTaffy
Since my recent comment about a good guide to the law, I have come across this useful page on photographers' rights, with a questions-and-answers blog by a legally qualified person.

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on photography is not a crime at 20/07/2012 - 23:29

OldTaffy
dougf8 wrote:
OldTaffy wrote:
Poor chap, he had not done his homework: every law in England is primarily defined by an Act of Parliament, and has been so since mediaeval times....
And you're the bloke trying to photograph outside a court, surprised when accosted?
Touché

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on photography is not a crime at 20/07/2012 - 23:24

OldTaffy
It's a dreadfully confused and unclear area, isn't it?

After my encounter with a security official at the local Crown Court, I wrote to the City Council to ask them to specify what Statutes, etc, regulated what security guards could enforce. After much toing-and-froing, and passing me further up the chain of authority, the City Council admitted that they didn't have a clue!

We are rather in need of an authoritative book or article defining what is legal and what isn't.

There is a fairly good article in wikipedia that outlines the legal situation in Britain and the USA. The Metropolitan Police have a statement on their website, but it's not particularly helpful and other regional police forces may have different interpretations. I have Googled a rather out of date summary on Stirlyn but it's more to do with trespass by photographers.

Having once spent about a year trawling through 18th century Acts of Parliament looking at laws governing fishing, I know that it is not easy to summarise a long series of precedents in common and Statute Law. Are any members of this group practicing barristers, or do you know a barrister or judge who is a passionate photographer and able to write a good outline of British or English law on this matter?

Incidentally, the bloke whose arrest at the Farnborough airshow triggered this thread, can be heard to ask: "Under what law am I being arrested?" and a policeman replies: "Under the Aviation Security Act" and the guy replies "that's not a law, that's an act". Poor chap, he had not done his homework: every law in England is primarily defined by an Act of Parliament, and has been so since mediaeval times....

I've spent too long wading through bound volumes of Acts of Parliament from the reigns of King George II, George III and George IV, in the Official Publications room at my library...

Goodnight!

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on photography is not a crime at 20/07/2012 - 22:03

OldTaffy
I confess! I too used the term recently, in the thread about EV compensation. I had not twigged that Pentax use something else. On checking in my K-x manual I find that it is called Multi-segment.

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on ExpoDisc on a Pentax DSLR at 19/07/2012 - 22:56

OldTaffy
Very good panning in No. 5. What-the-H is No. 13??? Uglier than a Fairey Gannet!

Comment by OldTaffy posted on Sunday Farnborough airshow at 19/07/2012 - 22:45

OldTaffy
Most of us, if put in this situation, have two options: have a calm open discussion, or make a scene/issue of it.

I found myself in such a situation a few weeks ago. I have been photographing 'street furniture' of various sorts - a London cabbie has a very good web-site: Bollards of London and I sometimes send him photos of interest from other places. I noticed some unusual looking ones outside the entrance to the local Crown Court, and squatted down with my K-x to photograph them, when immediately a security guard came rushing out, waving his hands and telling me to stop taking photographs (I have a good image of one of his hands ).

I politely explained what I was interested in. He calmed down, thought it rather amusing, and explained that the 'bollards' were really ashtrays on posts because no smoking was allowed inside the Court. We had an amiable chat for a minute or two, and he merely wanted to be sure that I was not going to photograph anyone visible inside, through the plate glass doors. Fair enough. I then took a few photos of the 'bollards' making sure that I chose a viewpoint that showed no person inside. End of hassle.

I was always outside the building, on the ordinary street pavement, and could have made a big fuss about my rights etc etc. It was just easier not to do so. Was I being compliant with a police state? Well, that must be your opinion not mine.

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on photography is not a crime at 19/07/2012 - 12:58

OldTaffy
Welcome, from a sort of Welshman-in-exile.

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on Hi from Sunny North Wales at 17/07/2012 - 22:59

OldTaffy
Last month my wife was given a bouquet of white roses and lilies, at a family wedding. They were so attractive (and the lilies soon smelled wonderful) that she arranged them in an earthenware vase and asked me to photograph them, while still perfect, to remember them by.

I found the subject a bit difficult, and would appreciate comments and suggestions about just one of the series - below:

Comment Image


This was taken out of doors in hazy sunshine. I took others when it was overcast, and some in full sun, but I found the sharp shadows in the latter distracting. The histogram is odd: a big peak near the dark end of the scale, an even bigger peak in the middle tonal range, and a smaller broader peak at the bright end of the scale. No clipping at either extreme. Apart from cropping and sharpening, I have done no post-processing on this image. (Some of the others needed adjustments to brightness & contrast and a bit of cloning). In all cases the K-x was on a tripod, exposure was bracketed, and I only recorded in JPEG.
Details should be in the exif but were 1/500 at f/11 ISO-800. Exposure comp +1.5, white balance: cloudy. DAL 18-55 at 38mm, Av mode.

Now, some comments please from you wedding photographers, florists and milliners: how could I have done a bit better?

Thanks,

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on Vase of white flowers at 17/07/2012 - 18:31

OldTaffy
To get back to the beginning (ie: the OP's question):

1. When I started using my K-x I thought that it would be best to set it to spot or centre-weighted metering. Then wondered why snaps of a white dog looked too dark overall! On average, my K-x seems to underexpose slightly on 'evaluative' setting, so I have a permanent +0.5 compensation set.

2. I seem to be attracted to scenes that have high contrasts: sunlight with dark shadows, or contre-jour viewpoints. Rather than fiddle about with individual compensation I now lazily have the K-x set to bracket exposures every time. This camera brackets with 3 exposures (am I right in thinking that the 'better' ones allow more?). I find that one stop above and below my +0.5 normal works for me. Errors of less than 1 stop are more easily adjusted with processing software.
It's easiest to leave the camera set to bracketing unless I really need something different. The only side effect is that I am sometimes startled by a triple clack-clack-clack when I'm just taking a casual snapshot

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on EV compensation at 17/07/2012 - 15:19

OldTaffy
snappychappy wrote:
Shoot RAW then correct in post processing, simples.
That's OK if your histogram is fully inside the limits. In extreme cases one might have a lot of pixels in the totally black or totally white bins (or even both). In such cases even RAW won't help.

Martin

Comment by OldTaffy posted on EV compensation at 13/07/2012 - 17:49

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo