All Forum Comments
Comment by niblue posted on PC Adapter at 26/08/2007 - 16:02
If you're looking wider than 28mm then the Pentax FA* 24mm F2 isn't desperately expensive 2nd hand (I had one but sold it when converting to digital) and perhaps the cheapest way to get an FA* lens.
The Tokina ATX-Pro 20-35mm F2.8 is also an excellent lens, but alas a fairly rare in Pentax fit. I've kept mine despite the focal length range not being quite as useful in APS-C as it was with film.
Unfortunately other fast options are rather few and far between in Pentax fit. I used to have a Sigma 28mm F1.8 and that's a nice lens if you can find one - I think there was a 24mm F1.8 as well but I've never seen one. FA 28mm F2.8's don't tend to be all that expensive when the come up 2nd hand so it might also be worth looking out for one of those.
Comment by niblue posted on Standard lens or f/2.8 zoom? at 23/08/2007 - 20:55
Having said that though one of the other lenses I also ditched at the same time was a 35mm F2 because again I didn't really think it'd be useful enough in the long run (with film I had 50mm primes but never found a lot of use for them). If, unlike me, you found 50mm primes useful with your film camera then the 35mm might well be a decent choice (although it's a little slow) for you but it wouldn't be top of my list.
If I was you I'd be looking at a wide angle zoom (probably the Sigma 10-20) because for my type of photography that would add the most to the lenses you already have.
BTW like John I've had good results with the 16-45 in low light conditions - I don't particularily like ISO's as high as 800-1600 but my experience with the K10D is that in conjunction with the image stablisation I'm getting useable results at quite low shutter speeds hand-held.
Comment by niblue posted on Standard lens or f/2.8 zoom? at 23/08/2007 - 18:17
OUCH........it was the "total crap optically" that made me both wince deeply and almost split-my-sides-laughing in the same breath !! One thing I can categorically assure you about is that my Tamron 18-250mm is certainly not "crap optically" and I've found it's build-quality to be reassuringly solid
It wouldn't surprise me at all if these lenses outperform the Pentax 18-55 where there range overlaps - my 28-200 was a better performer than both Pentax 28-80's I've owned.
Comment by niblue posted on Switch lens or switch camera at 23/08/2007 - 21:48
I've no experience of these 18-250 or similar lenses but unless they're total crap optically then I'm sure they'd serve a useful purpose for the same sort of thing as my old 28-200 did. 250 is probably longer than is really necessary for a lens that slow (you'll probably have to use higher ISO's and even then - if handheld - wider apertures where the lens isn't at it's sharpest) - I'd much rather have something like a 16-150 and if someone makes an affordable consumer spec one of those then I'll definitely consider it.
The 16-45 is a lovely lens and very useful however used by itself it's a bit short at the long end for a fair few shots that'll I encounter as a tourist so I always take a longer lens with it. In my case that's a 80-200 F2.8 (which is heavy) but it AF's well with a 2x TC so I'd rather have it than a slower lens. If those Samsung 50-200's were still available for £50 I'd definitely have take one of those for lightweight days.
Comment by niblue posted on Switch lens or switch camera at 23/08/2007 - 18:06
Comment by niblue posted on is this any good?? at 23/08/2007 - 11:46
1) There isn't a huge price difference (£600 for the Pentax, perhaps £550 for the Sigma)
2) I suspect it'll be significantly easier to actually locate a Pentax lens
As for others - Tamron do list a 14mm F2.8 in Pentax fit (it's on the warehouse express site) but as it's £750 I can't see why you'd go for it instead of the Pentax option.
Comment by niblue posted on wide angle at 22/08/2007 - 19:06
Also tried the 10-17mm fisheye. At 10mm with it you can see the edge of the image circle in frame down both sides plus the little integrated hood at the top and bottom. Both are gone by about 14mm or so - still some darkening of the corners but doesn't look too bad in the viewfinder. Even at 14mm it's still very, very wide.
Looks like both lenses could be useable from about 14mm or so (the Z1p viewfinder is very good but it's not 100% coverage) - I'll try sticking a film though with them at some point and see what the results are like.
Comment by niblue posted on Really Wide Zooms - Opinions at 26/08/2007 - 15:50
Comment by niblue posted on Really Wide Zooms - Opinions at 23/08/2007 - 21:52
A few months later I could have got the Pentax 12-24 for the same price as the Sigma was because my wife was over in Singapore - I did consider getting the Pentax and then selling the Sigma but by then I was quite happy with the Sigma so had her get me a 10-17 fisheye instead.
I did also consider getting a 15-30 because it'd be fun with film however I've read that due to the huge front element it can be difficult to stop flare so the Sigma 10-20 or Pentax 12-24 are probably more sensible options.
I seem to recall fitting the 10-20 to my Z1p and it did work although of course because of the smaller image circle it'd probably only work from 15mm or so upwards.
In my option either the Pentax 12-24 or the Sigma 10-20 are good options and it'd purely down to whether you'd rather pay £600 or so for the Pentax or half that for the Sigma. For me, given that £600 or so would get you the Sigma 10-20 and a Pentax 16-45, it isn't a difficult decision.
Comment by niblue posted on Really Wide Zooms - Opinions at 22/08/2007 - 16:22

