mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
I agree a grab shot does not have to be technically perfect but in this case I can't see why the focus can't be correct and the overall photograph sharp. These were static subjects and Kris had some time so personally I would say there is no reason to lower his usual high standards. To some extent we need to define grab shot. IMO these aren't.

I hope I am not upsetting Kris with constant reference to him - there is nothing personal in this we are just using your photographs as a talking point! We can switch to one of my less successful shots if we wish in fact I'll put two shots up later (I am supposed to be working) and we can chew those over to avoid any risk of offence being taken

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 09:13

mikew
I tend to Mhuni's point of view. These shots are soft and for me at least the content does not compensate for this failing. As I recall Capa's shots were blurred for a good reason or for effect this is not what Kris was attempting or so I believe.

These shots need to be sharp to work especially the best of the lot number 3 where we have proper composition and an interesting subject.

I think having focus on the statue was a good decision in the other two I would have chosen a different focus point.

I also agree that some discussion and disagreement is a healthy thing from which we can all learn. The danger is that offence is taken where none was intended and no-one wants to discourage anyone from taking photographs!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 07:18

mikew
Glyn - good judging, thoughtful comments just what we need!

Well done Tony - I hope your model will share in the glory in some way.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 36 - "People" at 03/03/2010 - 18:26

mikew
I have the 21 and also the Sigma 10-20.

As Kris said you do get some wow from the ultrawide but it's not strong on 'conventional' landscapes. That said at the 20 end it's so close to the 21 that it makes no odds although I don't think I have ever used the 21 for a landscape.

The 21 is really tiny and is an excellent street shots lens. It is much better than the kit lens but I find I use my 35mm or 30mm lenses way more than the 21 which surprises me.

I don't think you'll be blown away by the 21 as you were the 35 but it is a workmanlike lens which I would choose for street shots but little else it seems. Think about the Sigma 10-20. I know you said you didn't want a big zoom which it is but you do get blown away by the 10 end and I find it is very sharp once you learn how to focus the thing.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Heart says 15 head says 21 at 03/03/2010 - 17:12

mikew
Sadly none of them work for me.

Common to all I find the copper neither warm enough nor 'solid' enough it seems a bit thin as a colour.

Number 1 - I find the composition a bit odd and I don't like the grey bottom middle with what looks like a dust spot. I think one reason I'm not positive is that I can see the background thing has been cropped as it rises to its apex and that doesn't look right to me.

Number 2 - Why did you include the two buttons on the left? What do they do apart from disrupt things which might have been their role. I don't feel the two shapes work in harmony and the background colour is very pallid.

Number 3 - same sort of comment but added to that the top right must be verging on being burnt out. Anyway it is way too light to be there.

I suspect you're on a hiding to nothing trying to get a good composition from these cushions in their context. What is their strong point? Shape? Colour? Texture?

Oh well bad luck for you I just ended my working day and your post caught my eye! You can tell I wouldn't tackle this subject and that's why I have no suggestions

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Copper cushion at 03/03/2010 - 17:06

mikew
I'm not convinced this really meets the topic but it's all I have from the past fortnight and hey at least I'm showing support!

Comment Image


Taken Saturday 27th K20D, Sigma 50.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 36 - "People" at 03/03/2010 - 13:28

mikew
The point I made badly was that by selecting only the wages of those in full time employment you create a higher average than if you include the millions who exist on part time jobs which are frequently under 16 hours a week to avoid various taxes for the employer. So someone might have two part time jobs on minimum wage at 32 hours a week say but his low wage is not included in these statistics thus raising the average.

Further it takes very few really high earners to skew the average. Bear in mind there are many thousands who earn over £100,000 and they really should be excluded to give a more representative picture of the real income in the UK.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on unbelievable fact about pentax lens prices - cheaper to fly to canada and buy at 03/03/2010 - 12:59

mikew
Spot on JR - those statistics suit various political ends but don't reflect the multitude of people that exist on lower wages and multiple part time jobs probably on minimum wage.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on unbelievable fact about pentax lens prices - cheaper to fly to canada and buy at 03/03/2010 - 11:15

mikew
I find this lens cap to be the least stable that I have. It seems to flip off quite readily.

Comment by mikew posted on Sigma 50mm macro lens cap at 02/03/2010 - 22:19

mikew
I don't like to be negative (but that won't stop me) but I can see no merit in the shot at all. The subject holds no interest, the composition seems arbitrary, the lighting is too harsh. Focus is good and it is sharp but beyond that I am afraid nothing for me.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Ripped Packet Closeup at 02/03/2010 - 21:12

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo