mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
Kind words Andrew but I should have just got closer. They knew I was taking their photograph and I should have just walked up and taken my time. Instead I snatched and spoiled the shot.

The second one was just a complete cock up as I think I used AF.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 19:31

mikew
@ Andrew the 21 is AF but I preset it to where I thought I would shoot which is what I usually do for street shots.

Forgive me but the focus is off on the first two of your shots unless as is quite possible I am mistaken. The exposure in all is good but maybe you could zip them up a bit with some levels and contrast?

@Tim I think we are in agreement!

This one fails because it is simply not sharp enough. Heavy crop and shaky hands.

Comment Image


And I was really disappointed when I saw this one in detail.

Comment Image


One chance and I fluffed it on technicalities.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 18:23

mikew
Oh dang - I'm mr moany here but that area of bright light looks even more odd - as always IMO!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Room for improvement C&C at 04/03/2010 - 17:27

mikew
@ Stefan. Nope that's still got that terrible burnt out area which without some very clever cloning will always be its main weakness. The sky is tending towards funny looking as well.

@ Malo - nice work on the sky etc. but you've lost the point of the composition surely which was the convergence of the triangles.

I wasn't going to say it but I bet Graham was standing up when he took this. Even in my decrepit state I think I would have got lower and either had a lot more sky or a lot less sky. If it was a zoom lens then I blame that as a prime would have got your feet muddy for you

Move on I say!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Room for improvement C&C at 04/03/2010 - 17:10

mikew
Having said I'll do this I better had

1

Comment Image


OK this was taken using a 21mm lens so the one lady was almost on top of me but hey it's sharp. It would be rubbish if it wasn't, it may well pretty poor anyway but at least the technicals are pretty good. I had poor but way better light than Kris.

2

Comment Image


Once again not good light and I was standing in the same place for some time and really did need to grab shots while the subject and local riff raff (and that's being kind) didn't see me.

3
Comment Image


This one was never meant to be sharp although the original is actually sharp enough to see grains of sand. Not a grab shot but one where I decided to manipulate the situation on a really dull day.

4

Finally a really poor shot!

Comment Image


This is comparable conditions to Kris - and the camera was in the bag when I saw the shot I wanted. It was a race against time get the shot I wanted and I failed. I think the exposure was about a quarter of a second hand held. On the other hand look at the straps of the handbag.

I think I have rather lost the plot of the point I wanted to make but basically what I'm saying some shots have to be sharp and some don't. Kris's needed to be (saving his grace) especially number 3.

Naturally you should all feel free to rip into me - nothing like some frank debate.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 17:05

mikew
My fear is that the burnt out area on the right will always prevent you from making this work. You do have two strong triangles and the rectangle of the sky but the sky isn't strong enough as it stands. Have you tried selectively darkening the sky to see if that helps? I suspect it will just end up looking odd. I think you were between a rock and a hard place as the bright sky needed the correct exposure but that would kill the foreground. You can't exclude the very bright area because then you lose the points of the triangles.

Personally I'd move on to something I could make work.

Now watch as someone steps in and does a wonderful job on it!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Room for improvement C&C at 04/03/2010 - 16:44

mikew
Overly complex?

Comment by mikew posted on Discussion on Fortnightly Competition # 37 - "HOBBIES" at 04/03/2010 - 15:44

mikew
As far as I know no rules on nudity - just nothing that could be offensive or pornographic. If in doubt ask JR first I'd suggest.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Discussion on Fortnightly Competition # 37 - "HOBBIES" at 04/03/2010 - 15:15

mikew
Kris - I hadn't realised how far you'd pushed these already which makes the softness understandable but I have moved on a little now in terms of the discussion.

It's my contention that in general shots like these need to look sharp as there is no apparent movement nor reason for it, in fact quite the reverse as they convey the contemplative mood of the context well.

I will return with now three shots which I hope illustrate my point. But I really should be working!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 11:44

mikew
Tell that to the prof at UEA - 'why should I give you the data so you can criticise it?'

Not all academics are equal

Comment by mikew posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 10:12

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo