McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
johnriley wrote:
Quote:
and many unintuitive methods and terms ... 'burning, dodging, unsharp mask?'
For anyone who has ever done any film darkroom work, these are very intuitive terms.
No doubt John, but that is part of my point .... we are not talking about darkrooms ... we are talking about a computer software image manipulation effect - this is about the user of a computer programme, and how that user interacts with the process through the 'man machine interface'. From this perspective then physical darkroom practices are 'unintuitive'.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Layer Masking - Its Black & White at 16/11/2014 - 20:53

McGregNi
MrB wrote:
This is a good selection of images to show the beauty of the gardens, Nigel...
Thanks Philip, yes its a beautiful place. I am happy to hear variations on opinions on the colours and lens distortion effects. Regarding colours, there was an intensity about them - its wasn't a true dull day, not at all - there were shafts of strong sunlight boosting tones all the time, but anyway I hope I have struck a fair balance between vibrancy and natural.

Thanks David also for your thoughts on the colours and distortions.

I have not corrected any lens effects on these images at all .. I personally didn't see it as significant as I'm not trying to present a geometrically correct representation. I see the most obvious ones, like the columns, as adding to the wide field of view, sort of a stretched effect, taking it all in. I appreciate it won't appeal to everyone. To correct it would have meant too much cropping and I wanted that big sense of the place ... I could have shot wider possibly for the cropping, but didn't have much space around me really.

Thanks guys for the comments!

Stuey, I'm glad they look good on the tablet ... there's such a variation between all the different devices these days!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Compton Acres, Dorset ... A 14mm Photographic Showcase at 16/11/2014 - 20:44

McGregNi
I want to share some thoughts on Photoshop Layers, in particular layer masking concepts. It seems to me there a good number of quite incomprehensable processes in Photoshop, and many unintuitive methods and terms ... 'burning, dodging, unsharp mask?'

Layer masking has its own peculiar working approach which I want to focus on here ... I like to think things through in a unique way, and share that when I have found a good approach to understanding something - thats why I like doing guides to things.

I'm going to restrict this thread to the use of black and white 'painting' on layer masks. This is really a rather unusual, and not at all obvious method of working I found - certainly I struggled to 'get it' when I started out with Photoshop. Now its automatic, but I realise I had to come to understand it in a different way to the designers of the software!

Firstly, its important to understand that there is a total difference between painting onto an actual 'image' layer, such as the main background layer or a duplicate of that, and 'painting' onto a layer mask. On an image layer, that contains actual pixels, it can be thought of as representing real painting - you choose a brush and colour and the paint goes on top of the image and covers it as you go.

Now on a layer mask this is not the same at all. It should not be thought of as 'painting' paint onto the layer ... but what is it actually then, and why does it still use brushes and colours?

I see it like this .... on a layer mask the process we are applying is actually targeted and controlled opacity settings. Now, the layer with the mask has its own Master Opacity setting, that fades it in and out, and fades its effect on the image below it. But we don't always want the effect to apply to the whole image, and that is the point of the mask ... to allow us to apply the effect to controlled areas of the image and in controlled 'amounts of fade' also.

Say we used a Saturation/Hue adjustment layer, and increased the reds using that ... but we only wanted the reds to be increased on some boats in a harbour ... we didn't want the reds to increase on the sandy beach, because what was good for the boats was too strong for the sand. So the mask is to allow us to fade out, or block completely, the increased red effect over the beach area, but allow it to apply to the boats.

Now this is where masking comes into it. How do we mask? Well, you paint on some black with a brush! What? No, that can't be right! Well, on the surface it is right - but really, no - we're not painting black paint onto the mask. The black and white paint is just a way the software designers have decided to use the available tools to apply selective and controlled opactity settings on the mask ... and its not a very eloquent solution in terms of the concept, but it does work.

So what the paint is actually doing is using a colour range (black through to white) to represent mentally actual percentage amounts of layer opacity settings ... so, black represents 0% opacity, meaning that nothing from the masked layer will come through ... and white represents 100% opacity, meaning that all of the applied effect on the masked layer will come through.

So, take our red sandy beach ... after applying the saturation adjustment layer the beach has gone bright red ... now 'painting' on the layer mask with a 'brush' in black over the beach area tells the software you want to reduce the opacity of the layer to 0% on the parts that you move the mouse over . Thats a more accurate description of what is actually happening. Therefore the beach will go back to its colour before you applied the extra red.

Likewise, using a white 'brush' and 'painting' back over the beach again, tells the software that you now want to increase the opacity of the layer to 100% on the parts that you move the mouse over. Therefore the beach will go back to bright red as the increased red from the layer is now allowed to be applied fully to that area.

So how do we make an effect partly apply, like 75% of its strength? What colour do we have to use then? Well, this is where the whole painting with colours thing falls down - we don't pick some colour that is 75% of black (although we can use 50% grey), but rather we simply adjust the fade strength (also known as opacity) of the brush effect - like applying less pressure on a real brush. This is done on the tool setting itself, not the layer. So its still black to set 0% layer opacity over the area, but then the brush too is made weaker by its opacity setting (eg 75%, in which case it will actually create a layer opacity setting of 25% over the area). Thats the actual computational process going on - its not about black & white at all!

Hope I've kept you with me on this! And I hope its been on interest and a help .. if anything I hope it will stimulate more thinking and discussion right here about layer masking

Comment by McGregNi posted on Layer Masking - Its Black & White at 16/11/2014 - 20:29

McGregNi
walkeja wrote:
Formal gardens bore me to death but these are good especially No 10.
Thanks! Glad you like them ... it is a really interesting place to wander around, even if you're not that into gardens .. it has a sort ot tropical feel.

[quote:3496ace15f="Gwyn"] .... A couple of questions about the lens ...
How do you correct the distortion on it, or do you not find the distortion that bad? ... On the K-5ii it seems I can only set the focal length to 15, not 14. Does that make a difference or not? Is it possible to set it to 14? [/QUOTE]

I find it depends very much on the subject, and the particular elements in the scene. Here for example, the stone columns near the edges are an issue, as would be any building really ... but for general landscapes with mixed elements I don't find it a problem. For example I didn't have any issues with seascapes in Dorset recently. Its only when there's a straight vertical line, particularly near the edges thats it becomes rather extreme.

The main distortion on this lens is barrel type, fairly evenly across the main part of the frame, but with some sudden increase and twisting at the edges (this is known as moustache distortion). The normal barelling is no problem at all to correct using a standard tool, like 'lens correction' in photoshop. Any extreme issues near the edges are more difficult as the rate of correction varies as you approach the edge. I've had various forum discussions about this and have not yet heard of any software solution that would properly deal with this. In practice it would be best to shoot wider and crop.

The lens is not going to be anyone's first choice for serious architectural work, although I have not had problems shooting at Canary Wharf, and I got plenty of straight lines with basic correcting and a bit of cropping. But for general landscape, gardens and buildings where you can leave space at the sides its hard to beat in terms of bang per buck ... its resolution and contrast figures beat all the camera brands equivalents that cost far more, and it was for the detail and 'presense' that I got it.

With the camera SR setting, just use 15mm - the K7 / K5 don't have 14mm, but it doesn't matter - at this very wide angle the SR effect is limited anyway - it won't make any difference set to 15mm.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Compton Acres, Dorset ... A 14mm Photographic Showcase at 16/11/2014 - 18:47

McGregNi
I echo all the comments praising the creativity here ... lots of imaginative techniques that all come off well and evidence of good planning and setup. There is also great use of the location and various 'props' (like the mirror and the bed cushions), and a real sense of occasion. Lovely variety and a happy couple .. what more could you want!

A couple of ideas ... in the first one, the flash looks quite direct with telltale shadows behind (was it held off camera left?) Have you seen the Gary Fong Lightspheres? Great, they turn your flash head into a giant lightbulb pointing up - most of the light then comes diffused off the roof, but they pass through light forwards as well giving catchlights and soft front illumination - would have done a great job in that space!

I find the colour balance in most a little warm - some of the guys faces look like they have some foundation on (maybe they did!) .. but I'm sure a small tweak would improve it.

Comment by McGregNi posted on First Wedding for 20 years at 16/11/2014 - 17:13

McGregNi
Doesn't look like it was much fun at all! I generally stop snapping when the kids are crying and screaming as I don't find it makes much of a photo ... same here really. I appreciate you were there to capture a moment of religous significance, and the mood may have been serious .... but what a pity there is no sense of joy or love from anyone.

Technically, I like the white balance best in the last one which retains a bit of warmth from the tungsten lights and looks quite natural ... the others look a little too cool I feel. The first one loses atmosphere through being very bright, its not entirely clear where all the white light is coming from (it doesn't look to be only from the chandeliers), so maybe I'd have left more shadow around the outer zones and darker reaches. Again, the lighting on the last one is great like the colours.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Orthodox Cristiening at 16/11/2014 - 16:07

McGregNi
This is the beautiful gardens near Sandbanks, Bournemouth .... Compton Acres. I visited in the summer on a good day for photography really, with changeable weather, some cloud cover and a few showers. But there wasn't the glaring direct overhead sun that can make shooting under a 'canopy' difficult, although contrast in these conditions is always challenging I find.

I put into practise one of my little photographic habits, which is try a location with one single prime, and absolutely nothing else ... in this case it was the Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC, a manual focus 'A' type model (although it has the most modern type of optics).

All the shots were handheld (this was a walkaround) at ISO 200 or 400, most at around f5.6 or f8, SR activated, and the camera was the Pentax K7. I will certainly go back one day with a different focal length, but I enjoyed the restriction of the wide angle solely, which I find makes me seek out framings more dynamically.

Thanks for taking a look, and I'd love to hear what you all think of this garden showcase!


1.

Comment Image





2.

Comment Image





3.

Comment Image





4.

Comment Image





5.

Comment Image





6.

Comment Image





7.

Comment Image





8.

Comment Image




9.

Comment Image





10.

Comment Image





11.


Comment Image

Comment by McGregNi posted on Compton Acres, Dorset ... A 14mm Photographic Showcase at 16/11/2014 - 00:10

McGregNi
RussV wrote:
Harlequin wrote:
*Waves from behind the tree* I will make an attempt to post an image or two. Like others, I guess there's that fear of it being perceived as rubbish.... but then I guess you just don't improve
Folks here are always willing to offer some constructive criticism. The worst that happens is no one says anything!
ANY attention is GOOD attention ! Thats always been my motto ... (no doubt some would agree with that )

Comment by McGregNi posted on Silent Members at 15/11/2014 - 19:58

McGregNi
Thats what I understand about Miranda also Russ ... perhaps it was sold as an extension for a kit offering at the time. Its certainly more useful at the long end for close-up work I find, rather than the short end where it struggles a bit in strong lighting with contrast and flair. But a very useful little item to have in the bag! Glad you liked the photos

Comment by McGregNi posted on Some Late Summer Close-Ups at 15/11/2014 - 17:49

McGregNi
Thats a very nice version of the last one Philip, a good improvement .... also your new versions John, bringing up the ground has helped. My own idea was to limit the increase to the highlights only, so not to increase shadows or midtones much at all, to retain the depth this gives.

In terms of specific techniques this seems a classic case for a dose of a Photoshop adjustment layer ...

Here's a way to do it ...

On the layers palette, at the bottom, click on the 'new adjustment layer' button, then on the pop up menu choose 'levels' ....

Now an adjustment layer will appear above the backgound layer on the layer pallette, and this has a layer mask already (this is represented by the right hand rectangle on the layer bar). Also you will have the layers dialogue box floating.

With this method of selective editing there's no need to select - you are simply doing something to the whole image and them blocking the effect by rubbing out on the parts of the image that don't need it (in this case that is the sky areas).

So here on your No3 I would take the highlights input slider (on the lower right edge of the levels graph, a tiny white triangle), and pull it across slowly to the left, inwards ... this will increase the brightness of the highlights, the brightest parts of the image ... it will also cause the midtone slider (black triangle in the middle of the graph) to move to the left also, causing midtones to rise , but once you've placed the highlights nicely then just slide the midtone one back to the right - you can tweak away a bit back and forwards, but try and just raise the highlights without bringing up the mids too much (this is the main grassy areas and the lighter stone parts).

Don't even bother to look at your sky while dong this, or care what is happening to it.

Once you're happy with the grassy highlights, then click on the mask rectangle on the adjustment layer - this makes it active, and now choose the brush tool ... this will be used to brush a black 'mask' over the areas of the image that you do not want affected by your levels adjustment (the sky).

To make the colour of the mask black, hit d (to switch the colour picker to black / white) then use the X key to switch between white and black (you see this changing on the little square near the bottom of the tools palette). You are not actually painting black paint at all - the black is simply a representation of a mask covering, and white is simply a representation of a mask uncovering.

Now with the black selected use the brush to wipe over your image sky areas - you will see the highlights jump back down to the original level as you paint ... also you will see black appearing on the layer mask rectangle on the layer palette.

If you see black paint coming onto the photo, don't worry - its just that the background layer is selected, not the adjustment layer ... simply hit ctrl-z to undo the painting, then click on the adjustment layer mask rectangle again - now the brush movements will appy to the adjustyment effect only.

You won't need to be particularly precise for this sort or masking, a few sweeps around and about, taking more care around the horizon, will sort it quickly. Then you'll end up with your sky as it was originally, and just the highlights on your ground given that lovely extra sparkle!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Eastergate bridge at 15/11/2014 - 17:04

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo