McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I think all of those attributes you describe might more accurately be awarded to the K7 The K5 was merely a copy from that design.

Comment by McGregNi posted on The K5 is no more... at 09/12/2014 - 23:44

McGregNi
All good points Richard .... I'm going to stick with ' input' and' ' output', as I'm restricting this to camera controls specifically .... My camera output controls are not 'post shoot' at all, in fact they are set up prior to taking the shots, just like the input settings ... Both input and output are pre-set at time of capture ... That's why I'm not saying 'pre' and 'post' which would make more sense when talking about the shooting and post processing stages.

My definitions are ways to divide the camera controls into those that directly affect the RAW image data (input) and those that only affect the JPEG output. The output controls all have parallels in computer software, but the inputs don't ... Unless you begin to perform ' manipulations' . This is the point of this theory ... To give us a firmer ground on which to judge the type of image adjustment and how we view it as being an essential component of the process, or rather something that some worked call ' cheating '.

I don't agree with your characterisation of camera jpegs as 1 hour photos ... We do have quite respectable on camera controls for adjusting the shots ...I call these the camera 'output' controls.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 22:47

McGregNi
You could if there's a likely use for both files. Personally I generally decide before starting a shooting session, thinking about the subject type and likely processing approach I'll take, and then stick with one format throughout.

I don't see RAW as a kind of 'get out clause' for making exposure errors in camera ... I believe in fact that the ' input' stage settings (as I defined them earlier) are equally important in determining ultimate quality no matter which format we save the file in. Any limitations become more significant at the 'output' stage, when making those settings on the camera, or with computer editing, if you only have a JPEG ... But this is dependent really on the intended use for the image and the final size required also.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 20:41

McGregNi
It is a useful practical option Philip, I suppose if you suddenly realised for some reason you wanted a RAW .... It is the same on the K7 also.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 19:13

McGregNi
Welcome, and its good to hear you are enjoying both the camera and the image processing! You've done well with the moon, its nicely placed in the frame and the mono works well... i'd say the shots lack a little sharpness ... I'm not sure if this is from the actual capture stage or they just need more software sharpening?

I don't think its right to continue the 'photoshopping' debate here, as its not about your photos .... so I've provided another place for it! .... Check out my new thread ' Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing', which aims to raise the debate .... link

Comment by McGregNi posted on My first images at 09/12/2014 - 18:35

McGregNi
A very good set, and No 1 & 5 are the best for me! Beautiful natural colours and subdued backgrounds are the key components working well together. Good sharpness and detail overall. Well done David for grabbing these lovely images.

I prefer the ones with just natural landing supports, not so keen where there are man-made objects. Also its a pity in No 4 that the focus is slightly off the face .. did you get any more in a burst you could use?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Garden Beauties at 09/12/2014 - 18:21

McGregNi
Yes John, and we should probably all try and make use of the camera 'output' controls as well as use software. It can be interesting to see the effects of adjustments when using the custom image settings.

You will see that I remain committed to my camera control definitions though ! If we restrict the thinking just to an actual camera and its controls, then I think 'input' and 'output' has a logic to it ... input directly affect the optics and the image data captured in a RAW form .... 'output' then adjusts and adapts that 'input' data to produce a JPEG file, the thing we actually view from the camera. By the same logic, then a RAW file would be considered the result of the 'Input' controls, and then its subsequent transformation via a RAW converter into a viewable image format would be considered 'output' .

The actual controls on the camera fall logically (as I have detailed) into these two distict groups.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 18:05

McGregNi
Apologies, I'm sorry ... the correct website is ... www.sagelighteditor.com ...

Comment by McGregNi posted on RAW Converters 2014 at 09/12/2014 - 17:58

McGregNi
I wanted to lay down some thoughts on the recurring theme of 'in-camera' capture and computer image editing. It would be good to set out some goalposts and try and establish some common understanding for these debates, as I feel they are often confused by misunderstanding, termonologies and people actually not talking about the same things.

So, this is the world as I see it .... tell me what you think!

Our Pentax cameras have two distinct types of settings and controls ... and I'll group them according to my newly established definition terms ..... 1) Input Controls ..... 2) Output Controls

1) Input Controls directly affect the 'physical' optical image capture ...how the camera optics perform and the way the sensor records that optical image data.

So these input controls are .... a) Aperture b) Shutter Time Value c) ISO d) The focussing controls, whether manual or using AF points e) Flash use and flash exposure settings

These 5 key input parameters will determine the 'physical' characteristics that are burned into the digital capture. They determine the depth of field, the depiction of movement, the noise characteristics and other ISO related quality issues, the in (and out of) focus zones, and the lighting balance and colour qualities recorded. (Remember that exposure compensation is only a secondary control, as it will cause one of the primary input controls to change in order to make its effect.)

There is clearly one other powerful input factor, and that is the photographer, who chooses where to point the camera, what lens, and what to include or exclude from the scene ....

2) Output Controls act to adjust and alter the results from the input control settings ... ie, they apply computer controlled software adjustments to the digital imput file, which is effectively a RAW file inside the camera.

So these output controls include ... a) White Balance b) All the Custom Image settings ie Preset, saturation, hue, high/low contrast, sharpness, fine sharpness etc, filters for Black & White or other effects etc c) the highlight / shadow corrections, lens distortion corrections d) the HDR controls

All of these controls tell the Prime Image processor to carry out image editing software functions directly on the recorded image file, and then produce a new output JPEG file according to the quality and size settings made by the user. If the camera was set for JPEG only, then after this in-camera image editing has occurred, the stored 'RAW' file is discarded ... if both were set then both are kept ... and if RAW only then an output JPEG is not created, although the editing settings are all applied, but only a very small copy of the JPEG is created and 'embedded' within the RAW file for use as a thumbnail in cataloguing programs if needed.


So, there's my definitions of the two key sets of camera controls .... what do you think? Input controls, and output controls.

Now .... the fun.... how do these controls relate to computer image editing options and choices? My take on it is this .....

1) Input controls burn characteristics into the image in a 'physical' way - With the exception of minor brightness adjustment, any image editing that alters the effects of these input controls would be considered 'Image Manipulation', involving significant changes to the original material recorded by the camera .. eg, focussing, motion and blur, lighting changes and effects applied. Now, none of these are likely to add any quality to an image, so I would concur generally with those who say this is to be avoided ... much better to get this stuff right in the camera.


2) Output controls are simply settings for the camera processing software, so they have their computer software equivalents in almost every image editor. In most cases a skilled and experienced user will be able to improve on the results of this in-camera image processing by editing their images with a quality RAW converter and image editing program. These adjustment processes affecting saturation, contrast, hue, sharpness, shadow recovery, white balance etc etc, are all normal and required extensions to the image capture process .... the output must follow the input or we don't have a photograph.

So because all of these things can be done in more detail, with more control, on a computer, then that act of computer editing should be regarded in exactly the same manner as someone who sets their 'output controls' on their camera, and the same respect accorded to them for that. It will depend on the individual, their experience with either the camera output controls or computer software, as to the final quality of output they can achieve. Some will achieve better by precisely setting the camera controls, others will do better with computer editing.

Here endith the lesson ! I hope this may set the tone for future debates, and I hope these definitions of the 'input' and 'output' controls can help us better understand what we are talking about, and find common terms to use when talking about image editing vs camera capture settings.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 17:46

McGregNi
StephenHampshire wrote:
.... Yes I use Sagelight too,
Great, we can form a most select and elite subgroup here! Anything to counter the constant barrage of the Lightroom Brigade

Comment by McGregNi posted on RAW Converters 2014 at 09/12/2014 - 16:53

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo