All Forum Comments
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 14/12/2014 - 17:23
Comment by McGregNi posted on Five in a row - Russ at 13/12/2014 - 23:46
I reduced brightness and applied very hefty extra contrast and colour to bring back detail here, pulling this out of what was a total cyan washout! I like the result because it exaggerates the close perspective effect as most of the haze has gone (I left the furthest hills just before the horizon as a 'washout' to add amore realism.) This contrast boost I think makes it seem like the spaces behind the castle are much closer than they really are.
I appreciate it may not appeal widely, but it seems to bring out the point of the images, which was to set the castle within the wider space .... the haze had the opposite effect really.
Comment by McGregNi posted on Corfe Valleys at 13/12/2014 - 09:52
I'll be there shortly Gary
Comment by McGregNi posted on Saturday afternoon into Saturday evening. at 13/12/2014 - 09:43
Comment by McGregNi posted on Saturday afternoon into Saturday evening. at 13/12/2014 - 09:41
K7 and SMC M75-150mm f4, shot at ISO 200 f13


Comment by McGregNi posted on Corfe Valleys at 12/12/2014 - 16:19
In fairness, I'm hardly the most committed HDR evangelist ... I too have not fired up Photomatix lately, although many of my recent landscapes have involved blending of two exposures (mainly sky / ground). Here I find the transition can be most successfully made natural with minimal effort. My main concern with the church windows was the blend issue, and I still think it has to carried out with some subtlety and much care to create a realistic effect of the light bleeding though and tapering into the interior.
Now, getting back on track ..... ( I have to keep doing that ) ... now you guys are really testing my powers of definition ! Richard, I'll admit to some swaying on the category for in-camera HDR .... you make some persuasive points about the 'baking-in' of the HDR into the JPEG, and of course there's no going back from that, it can't be reverted to a non HDR image on a computer .... so.. OK - HDR becomes an 'Input' camera control ! I think the K3 can in fact offer up the 3 HDR exposures as RAW files, am I right?
Andrew, my original definition of the Input controls does address the ISO setting in the last part ... 'and the way the sensor records that optical image data.". . That was supposed to encompass aspects of sensor performance and its effects depending on changes to ISO. I'm not trying to say the ISO affects the amount of light reaching the sensor, which as you say remains the same regardless (that is only affected by the aperture & time value) .. but rather I am saying that there are inherent IQ matters, or characteristics that change as the ISO changes.
Clearly these differences depend on the camera and the quality of its ISO performance, but in general increases in ISO cause more noise plus a reduction in dynamic range and colour intensity. I'm saying that these aspects are 'baked in' effectively at point of capture ... really, any software manipulation to alter these things later would not likely produce a better result than if the ISO had been set 'correctly' on the camera. So like aperture, time value, AA filter, flash power etc etc, ISO should also ideally be set to the best setting on the camera at capture - that's why I class it as an 'input' control.
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 12/12/2014 - 13:47
Although I accept that post-processing brightness adjustments can be very successful in creating a similar result to actual ISO differences shot by the camera, this depends heavily on the individual camera, and this is still an image manipulation that leads to some loss of quality - as you said it was necessary to apply secondary corrective processes .... not really ideal. So for this reason, by my definitions, it falls firmly within the 'input' category.
Did you see that thanks to petrochemist we now have the AA filter controls as 'inputs' also (although HDR remains 'output' ).
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 12/12/2014 - 00:29
I included the camera HDR controls in the 'output' category because, as I see it, this too is a software process applied by the camera processing ... sure, the camera takes the bracketed exposures, and it does this according to the input controls set up by the user ... but the significant point is that the HDR feature merges these using software to produce a single JPEG. This process equally could be performed on a computer if we took the brackets manually. So within the parameters of my definitions here, HDR is an 'output' control.
The AA filter is an interesting one also! You're right that its effect would be really embedded into the image data, in much the same way as the effect of the ISO setting would be. It poses an interesting academic challenge though, because you could argue that the effect of the AA filter (ie the amount of blurring added or not added) could in fact be adjusted in post processing by additional fine sharpening or blurring filters. But, my theory goes that anything that could cause quality loss in post processing should best be left to the camera at capture ... so, thanks ... from now on the official designation for the AA filter controls are as 'inputs' !
Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 11/12/2014 - 21:50
I'm in two minds with your shot .... I love the jetty itself, clean and simple, and the composition (really the placing of the jetty in the frame) is perfect! Perhaps a lower viewpoint would have added more depth and detail in the foreground.
Its the sky and water I'm unsure on ... the tones are nice, but its looks rather ... unearthly ..... I know thats what you wanted and you've done a great job capturing and processing it, but my own tastes are for much more realism. Will be interesting to see others thoughts. Well done with this image and thanks for posting it
Comment by McGregNi posted on Swanage Jetty at Sunset at 11/12/2014 - 21:23


Andrew, regarding the subjective terms, I guess 'later' is the easy one That just means anytime immediately after pressing the shutter button ... the others are more difficult, I accept, at least where ISO is concerned. I am coming from the standpoint that ISO is the equal (in certain ways) to aperture & time value, and therefore any 'later' adjustments to the effects of ISO should be thought of in a similar way to any later adjustments to the effects of aperture & time value.
So, for example, we generally set a higher ISO in order to allow (given other constraints such as lighting levels and lack of tripod) a higher time value, or smaller aperture (or combination of those) ... thats the most common use of it I think. So, say a shot should ideally have been shot at ISO 1600 (the lowest setting that gave the required other settings), but was not actually shot at ISO 1600, but rather at ISO 200 ... well then, you probably end up with camera shake. Now, this would not be easy to satisfactorily correct 'later', not something we'd be wanting to try and correct in Photoshop. It is unlikely to lead to as good a result than if we had actually shot at ISO 1600 on the camera, and therefore did not have camera shake.
That is how I'm coming at it .. that is why I'm classing it as an 'input' control, because just like aperture and time value and any flash lighting, it is most likely to produce better results if done correctly on the camera in the first place ... later image manipulation is not likely to be ideal.
Similarly, if we did have a tripod, but decided to shoot at ISO6400, when we could have used ISO 100 successfully ... well, then as well, correcting the effects of using ISO 6400 on the computer later is unlikely to produce as good results than if we'd actually used ISO 100 on the camera.
There may be some exceptions, although rare .. eg, say with aperture, a very cheap lens versus a very skilled Photoshopper ... but in general, the optical and sensor 'input' at camera source is most likely to produce the better results. The same does not apply, necessarily, to 'output' settings, such as saturation, sharpness, HDR etc ... here there's good reason to believe that the skilled image processor could improve on the results of the camera controls.
Remember, the point of all this is to give us common grounds for taking attitudes towards specific types of image manipulations and adjustments. But it also can help to clarify the relative importance of specific camera controls and settings depending on our intended onward workflow.