McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
A picture perfect postcard for No 3, and a candidate for a popular postcard at the station shop with No 4! I like the mono for the train, and the colours are very well judged and natural for No 3.

The railway from Swanage to Corfe (well just past Corfe!) holds many special memories for me with the family in years past ... this time, after a break away from Dorset for a few years, we didn't do the railway, but the haunting sounds from the trains cast a spell over the camp site just up the hill, an ingrained memory.
Yours is a nicely timed shot with its steamy puffs and our man leaning out the cab. Well done!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Five in a Row - Stridey at 11/12/2014 - 20:08

McGregNi
In terms of IQ bang per buck, it is surely extraordinary value. The problem is though, that to realise all of that IQ potential requires wider photographic and technical skills also, and generally a set of supporting camera features that enable quick and efficient exercising of that skill ... and these are the things that are found on the flagship bodies .... so does this mean that much of this high IQ potential could be wasted?

Comment by McGregNi posted on K-S1 Wins The Camera Store TV worst camera of the year at 11/12/2014 - 19:17

McGregNi
andrewk wrote:
McGregNi wrote:
1) Input Controls directly affect the 'physical' optical image capture ...how the camera optics perform and the way the sensor records that optical image data.

So these input controls are .... a) Aperture b) Shutter Time Value c) ISO d) The focussing controls, whether manual or using AF points e) Flash use and flash exposure settings
I am not quite sure yet where you are going with this thread, Nigel, but my understanding of what happens in the camera is rather different. Unless I am mistaken, the ISO setting does not affect what is captured by the sensor. ..... Andrew
I'm finding these sort of threads can go their own mysterious way Andrew! I try to keep things on track as best I can, but usually the extra points are useful and add things into the mix.

The purpose of the 'input' / 'output' classification of camera controls is to lay down some firm guidelines, and help in how we consider post processing actions, and hopefully achieve better agreement on the appropriatness of specific types of 'photoshopping'. To me there is a clear division between those camera controls that operate physical camera functions, or 'burn' in certain characteristics ... (this would include ISO I'd say), and those that are effectively 'post processing' options, the sort of things that are the normal part of image adjustment (and these are in the main the custom image settings).

There's been some debate about white balance here .... the consensus seems to be that, at least for RAW files, it is a variable that can be changed in processing without quality loss ... therefore by my definition it is an 'output' control.

Now, as an example, an 'input' control (or its effects) could not be adjusted in a routine manner without quality loss ... this includes aperture, time value and ISO. These settings are really 'burned' in at the point of capture. You cannot change the aperture, or time value, or the ISO after the shot has been taken. You might mimic the effects of doing so by image manipulation, but thats unlikely to create results that are as good as if it had been done on the camera at capture ... thats the 'input' controls.

So my theory says that if we are dealing with something that was created by an input control, then its likely any 'photoshopping' to change it could more fairly be seen as less acceptable by most ... a manipulation that some might term 'cheating'

But, if what we are changing is the result of one of my 'output' controls, (eg a change to sharpness, or saturation), then that is something that is a normal and expected part of digital image processing, and should not be critisised as wrong in any way.

Everyone will still have their own opinions of course, but we have a clearer way of identifying the source of the effect that is being adjusted ... was it from a camera 'input' control ( in which case it ideally should have been set right at capture), or was it from an 'output' control (or its computer software equivilent), and therefore its is a personal matter of taste and judgement for the photographer.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 11/12/2014 - 18:36

McGregNi
johnriley wrote:
... If you shoot RAW then you can choose the WB setting after the event, certainly in ACR. ...
Yes, thats true, and we have the same WB pre-sets in PDCU. The question is, does making this adjustment in Post Processing actually result in the same colour quality than if we had chosen the setting on the camera? Or will it cause some degradation by being the result of a software manipulation? Its about the issue of whether this colour toning is 'Baked In' to the RAW in some way?

Philip, I find those white balance corrections very successful! So does this in fact suggest that we need to leave the White Balance settings as classified as an 'Output' type?? An output setting is something that can be easily and normally adjusted on a computer, and can't be labled 'cheating'

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 11:32

McGregNi
Yes, I see your point .... it actually is recorded and its effect takes place, true. The difference is that WB is one setting that is often claimed to be variable after capture in RAW, without quality loss. I'm not sure myself why this would be the case in technical terms? It depends on whether that is true I guess.

I have actually found in practice that it is not always easy to correct White Balance issues, even in RAW, if the setting was wrong in the camera. Sure, minor colour balance tweaks are OK, but I've never had much success with major white balance settings that were wrong.

Perhaps I should re-classify White Balance as an 'Input' Control ..... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 11:05

McGregNi
walkeja wrote:
richandfleur wrote:


conceptualising
read "conceiving", we are British not American. Another bugbear of mine.
Glad to have you joining in What do you think of my classification of the camera controls ....? will it help with the issue of 'photoshopping' when we debate it?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 10:32

McGregNi
richandfleur wrote:
.... Like I say, I'm not looking to derail this conversation with the 1 hour lab comment, ....


No worries Richard, frankly these sort of debates tend to take on a life of their own .... certainly I, as the instigator, usually find it's hard to keep the troops in line! Look, already just above its morphed into the RAW vs JPEG quality debate

Getting back on track, let me refresh that I am limiting my definitions and the thinking behind it entirely to the camera controls ... the things we set in advance to pressing the shutter .... so everything should here should be considered as entirely at the capture stage. This is not about post processing. Both the camera 'input' controls (which affect the optical system and sensor recording and any artificial lighting involved) , and the 'output' controls (which affect the in - camera processing and the image adjustments carried out by the camera) are all set up on the camera itself. I am creating a division between these controls, grouping them in this new manner, in order to aid understanding and agreement on their potential effects as they relate to any later 'photoshopping' .....

Let me repeat the category divisions and listing here ....

1) Input Controls directly affect the 'physical' optical image capture ...how the camera optics perform and the way the sensor records that optical image data.

So these input controls are .... a) Aperture b) Shutter Time Value c) ISO d) The focussing controls, whether manual or using AF points e) Flash use and flash exposure settings



2) Output Controls act to adjust and alter the results from the input control settings ... ie, they apply computer controlled software adjustments to the digital imput file, which is effectively a RAW file inside the camera.

So these output controls include ... a) White Balance b) All the Custom Image settings ie Preset, saturation, hue, high/low contrast, sharpness, fine sharpness etc, filters for Black & White or other effects etc c) the highlight / shadow corrections, lens distortion corrections d) the HDR controls


To follow from John above and further answer Nigel's question, its correct that in fact none of the Output controls listed will apply ( I mean 'be applied') to a RAW file. However, even if your are shooting RAW only, all of these settings are in fact active, and the processor does apply them .... but only for the image review on the rear LCD and to create a tiny embedded JPEG inside the RAW for catalogue thumbnails. For this reason, if you shoot RAW only, then you should switch off those Output controls that cause a longer processing time ... these are the shadow / highlight corrections and the lens corrections.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 10:30

McGregNi
You don't think it could just be a fault with his camera ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Garden Beauties at 10/12/2014 - 00:49

McGregNi
Agreed MrB ... let me give two practical examples of how I see this theory proving useful ...

Say we had an image that was shot at f8, but the photographer realised later that it needed less DOF, and should really have been shot at f3.5. But he's got a RAW file of it, so he uses software to create a blur effect and works at applying it in a natural way with brushes and masking etc ... its OK, but not really totally 'natural' .. what we might have expected had it been shot at the required aperture in the first place.

Now this is an example of an 'input' control not being set correctly at capture. The editing work required could be described as 'manipulation' , and indeed some people might call it 'cheating'. But at least we all understand the definition and can apply our own standards to the matter ... we have a level playing field for discussion .. ie that an 'input' control was wrong, and it has been put right in software. Now most would agree that is not the ideal way to work, that it would be better to 'get it right in camera' ....

Next example, we have a camera JPEG file where the photographer feels the saturation is not enough ... when setting her 'output' control for saturation (in the custom image setting) she left the slider on plus 1 ... it should ideally have been on plus 3 for the particular image.

Now, in software, our photographer uses a saturation control to boost the colours, and the result looks much better. Now, we can also agree surely, that this is a positive and 'OK' example of image adjustment using the computer ... because it apples to one of my camera 'output' settings (see the definitions in the OP). These are things that generally are duplicated both on the camera and in computer software. Again, we an understand the acceptability and simple extension this step makes to the normal photo creating process... and hopefully more understanding and agreement!

So, this is the rule ..... 'input' control faults corrected in software ...equals not too good, should have been done on the camera ....

'Output' control faults corrected in software .... perfectly OK types of adjustment, normal to do this to every image ... Now surely we can all agree to adhere to this new rule

Comment by McGregNi posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 00:41

McGregNi
The connection between these images is that they are all taken from a similar position, on the grassy headland near the south-west tip of Swanage Bay, known as Peveril Point. But there are many different angles and focal lengths deployed in the set, and shots that look in different directions, all to show the diversity to be seen from one fairly small viewpoint.

All with the K7 and lenses as detailed with each photo ...... Shooting technique is my standard landscape approach, tripod mounted, mirror-up and remote control, ISO 100 ..... apertures between f11 and f16.


1) SMC 28mm f2.8


Comment Image





2) SMC M75-150 f4


Comment Image





3) Samyang 14mm f2.8


Comment Image





4) SMC M75-150 f4


Comment Image





5) Samyang 14mm f2.8


Comment Image





6) Samyang 14mm f2.8


Comment Image


Thanks for your interest and all comments

Comment by McGregNi posted on From Peveril Point at 10/12/2014 - 00:25

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo