McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Andrew, you're so right about the bigger sensors .... I can't weight (:wink for my photos' to become 1.5x better, and as well I will expect 50% more favourable comments on the forum. Now once I add on the massive battery grip I'll get with my FF camera that will surely push the better photos factor up towards 2x !!!

The fact that my lenses are ready and waiting for it all just makes it so much more satisfying.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Very interesting topic regarding APS-C & FF at 10/01/2015 - 18:13

McGregNi
In practice , whatever the technical differences that lead to higher quality, their significance is really individual. This is broken into two parts .... Firstly, how a person manages and processes that photos (eg do they example them in great detail looking for technical issues) and secondly the required output size.

Whilst pixel resolution will always be the ultimate determiner of maximum size, other IQ factors will be revealed more at later sizes ... So again, a larger format might win out on a very large print where the DR was extreme and any deficiencies were revealed as a result of the large size (ie more visable).

So there is not much point in making these comparisons outside of personal considerations ... It has to be a personal choices as the significance of the differences will only have impact dependent on the individuals particular workflow and output. I continue to hope that we will soon be given more sensor size choice with Pentax!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Very interesting topic regarding APS-C & FF at 10/01/2015 - 16:38

McGregNi
I'm looking forward to using my FF lenses on FF digital ... One day !? .... Meantime they're doing fine service on aps-c. I'm not sure I understand what is not suitable about the focal lengths of my FF lenses for aps-c? And as I said earlier, I've never been told I'd get better images by choosing aps-c specific lenses. I appreciate that with the old glass there might be some optical deficiencies that may 'show up' more on a larger sensor. But if a move to FF can be accomplished with a body purchase only, is that not a financial and planning approach to be recommended?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Very interesting topic regarding APS-C & FF at 10/01/2015 - 09:01

McGregNi
How would you respond to my post earlier then Jonathon, about lens choices suitable for both formats?

Regarding the quote and comment about a larger sensor getting 'more light' .. well the commonly understood meaning of 'more' for lighting is surely 'brightness', or light levels, or 'lumens' (is that a technical term)?

This of course is not affected by a sensor at all. Whether a larger surface area could be said to capture 'more light' is stretching our powers of definition a bit don't you think?

I

Comment by McGregNi posted on Very interesting topic regarding APS-C & FF at 10/01/2015 - 00:16

McGregNi
Brilliant Carl, Really effective how you've metered and caught the highlights which create flashes of interest across the frame. Nice smooth conversion as well.

Comment by McGregNi posted on First Image of 2015 at 09/01/2015 - 21:05

McGregNi
A varied and interesting yearly reflection .... my favourites are (oddly!) the two little birdies, which are both superb - beautiful clarity and colour!

The last one looks a bit blurry ... maybe a focus adjustment needed, or your AA filter simulator was switched on, or you had centre only focus point active ..... or your camera might have a fault

Comment by McGregNi posted on Dr Orloff's Photographic Year at 09/01/2015 - 16:06

McGregNi
Its lovely and clear, and the bright red wheel provides that strong colour contrast. I like the white balance with its very pure white also.

For me I feel you have overcooked the 'depth' in the sky. Now its well known that I often complain of over-moody skies with very dark moisture charged clouds, and its no different here. Its really very dramatic, to the extent of looking unrealistic I think .... it looks like an impending natural catastrophe is coming your way that even Pentax WR will be powerless to resist

I do think some gentle selective (on the sky only) shadow lifting and small midtone brightening, will improve it. By all means hold the highlights as you don't want a glaring bright sky of course, but less contrast overall and a lower black point will help IMO.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Windmill at 09/01/2015 - 16:00

McGregNi
I think that article is utter nonsense. Both 'arguments' are flawed and untrue. Firstly, thinking about and planning a potential upgrade in sensor size from aps-c to FF does not imply ' that is the sole aspiration to strive for' .????. Sorry, what? What fancy of invention did that spring from? A sensor upgrade like that is perfectly logical and has obvious benefits for many, and of course the cost and size issues have to be factored in. That's a personal judgement for each person .... It'll weigh one way for some, the other way for others.

Secondly, it it's also perfectly logical to plan a system and acquire lenses in in advance of a format change, if those lenses can adequately serve your needs on both formats. Some lenses, sure, due to coatings or optical aspects may be not ideal for one or the other. But many are good for both. What is wrong with my 14, 28, 35-70, 50, 75-150, 135, 70-300 mm lenses (all full frame) on my aps-c camera? I have never heard comments on the forums from people telling me I really need to get some aps-c optimised lenses to improve my images ....

Of course, being a fairly budget selection, I know that I may find some aspects lacking when revealed by the bigger sensor ... But I don't expect perfection from one button press, I post process and optimise, so I may have to optimize a little differently. Of course, I may decide its worth it to buy another lens with a FF camera, but at least I don't HAVE to straight away. Financially, planning wise (for an amateur) what on earth is the problem with that??

Comment by McGregNi posted on Very interesting topic regarding APS-C & FF at 09/01/2015 - 15:38

McGregNi
All good points. I think its clear that our own particular needs usually cross over between the categorisation and marketing targets, and also that the cost of higher end camera features has decreased significantly over the last 10 years.

The digital technology itself was so costly then that the maker bad no choice but to keep other supporting specs at a modest level, even on those bodies targeted at the demanding user. Now we demand hugely more! And we get it to ... Look at my first entry into DSLR photography ... k7 + da18-55 al wr , new in 2012 for £499. I got many things that as a Canon film user were only available on their pro-spec bodies. Now of course I can't have any less! Any less to me is no longer a pro-spec / enthusiest model, but falls down to consumer grade, in my perception.

Comment by McGregNi posted on 24-megapixels-the-world-forgot at 09/01/2015 - 09:15

McGregNi
A brilliant set, as Dr O says, plenty of special lighting, plus beautiful colours . 2, 8, 10, 12 are my particular favourites - a great photographic year!

Comment by McGregNi posted on 12 shots from 2014 at 09/01/2015 - 00:28

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo