McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
BruceStrachan wrote:
Bullshit aside.... Abstract etc is fine but like the op said post the original as well... What have you got to lose?
I don't really do 'abstract', but I believe my images require my computer processing in order to achieve two aims ... 1) extract the full potential of the sensor (especially for demanding situations, high DR, high detail etc) and ... 2) to ensure that the image reflects my feelings and intentions about how I want to represent the scene and subject (thats my personality / style etc) ....

I do generally want reasonably 'true to life' , but I mostly look to create a good looking image, not necessarily a 100% re-construction of what a person standing there at the time would have seen (I don't really understand why that is a valuable aim really ?)

Also Bruce .... could you define what exactly you think of as 'the original' ? Not sure what that could be exactly?

Here's one definition and a comparison ..... I suppose it could be argued that a RAW file, un-adjusted and simply converted to JPEG for web viewing represents 'the original' as the camera 'saw it' ?

OK, so here's a shot of mine at the Haytor Rocks, firstly my final edited version and then the unadjusted RAW .....


Comment Image




Comment Image


Which one is preferable and which represents the scene more accurately ... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on this will be intresting at 25/05/2016 - 10:54

McGregNi
Ha! Yes, can't argue with that! And glad that you care as well

Comment by McGregNi posted on Zebra Spider at 24/05/2016 - 21:34

McGregNi
Ahh, Critique of the critique ! That's something interesting Mark, a chance to analyse why things are said .... However the photographer here hasn't responded to any further comments, so perhaps he doesn't care? (but equally I also know that he may not have been able to check the forum for some time and might be intending to soon).

I try to be sure to balance my comments, so that means looking to the positives first, then observations and suggestions .... Here (as you also say) there's a highlight exposure issue, so probably a closer eye on the histogram and more control over the flash would help.

I am naturally biased towards positive feedback regarding peoples flash work, because quite frankly, there's far too little flash photography shown here, so I want to encourage it and promote it (there are plenty of people who ' like to work with natural light ... ) .

Comment by McGregNi posted on Zebra Spider at 24/05/2016 - 17:42

McGregNi
Very strange and interesting images! Without particularly 'liking' them (you know, as we might like a close up of a flower or a nice looking girls portrait) I appreciate the set-up skill and techniques in getting the captures .... The processing is effective also. The reflection in the last one is very spooky. I wonder if you could have reduced the flash exposure a little, as the white highlights look a bit washed out .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Zebra Spider at 22/05/2016 - 13:13

McGregNi
Thankyou Maria, I'm really glad you saw them.

Comment by McGregNi posted on At Waddon Ponds at 21/05/2016 - 17:00

McGregNi
Just to elaborate on my perspective with this. ....

Not looking further than a particular era and lens type can be photographically limiting, not just IQ wise but subject matter as well, and environments available to you .... Think ultra wide angle for dramatic architectural /urban images ..... Low light events where you can't see enough to focus ...... P-TTL automatic flash on-camera for high quality bounced soft light in dynamic situations for portraits , well you can forget that with any SMC M series lens.

It's about where you set your own limits, what you see are your possibilities.

Another angle is the capabilities of specific lenses. For example, my macro solution is an old Tamron Adaptall 135mm f2.8 (from the early 1970s) plus manual extension tubes ... Great super budget plus high IQ, all manual operation but its slow and enjoyable to do it in those situations. It's good for portraits too in soft light, but get any high contrast backlight in behind or the sun in the 'wrong' position and the colours go purply and the bokeh turns nasty and speckled.

It's about pairing specific lenses to their strengths and taking advantage of their possibilities, otherwise we limit ourselves.

Comment by McGregNi posted on SMC M lenses at 21/05/2016 - 12:44

McGregNi
philstaff wrote:
...... But wonder if there might be any benefit in upgrading to the newer models.

Regards Ian
That was the question. ..... Reading here the main response seems to a clear 'no' .... Does that actually reflect the real world photography situations faced by a range of people, and is it a fair perspective on things ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on SMC M lenses at 21/05/2016 - 11:31

McGregNi
Yes, it was all so wonderful it's hard to understand why any company bothered to design any new lenses after 1979 ...(deliberate sarcasm. ).

This could have been a good opportunity to compare pros and cons of old and new, not just another gushing session for ancient lenses. We all know and love some old lenses, and that commitment may well be the whole reason for using Pentax for some, but a dose of perspective and reality is surely needed!?

I'll give some .... I love going out with the old M75-150 F4 in the City or Croydon and shooting architecture, taking time to focus, green button metering, aperture adjustments on the ring, shutter adjustments for exposure ... Good fun .....but ..... It's utterly useless for family shots, even static portraits (supposedly static ) as the whole palaver of using it plus the focusing/zooming difficulties just screw everything.

So the F35-70 or Tamron 70-300 are the only choices there because of what their more modern designs offer.

It depends on who you are and what you do as well. For the unwary poor quality old lenses can produce low contrast, greeny/purply faded looking shots that need a lot of processing, and frankly the unwary are mostly the ones who can't do the processing anyway. There are some gems of course .... But its about knowing about them .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on SMC M lenses at 21/05/2016 - 08:00

McGregNi
Yes, plenty of benefits. Autofocus is the obvious one. Newer coatings and optics are generally better at controlling flare, aberrations, give better colour reproduction and micro-contrast.

Some older lenses are of course super-sharp and will outperform cheaper modern ones, particularly cheaper zooms in that department.

Comment by McGregNi posted on SMC M lenses at 20/05/2016 - 15:49

McGregNi
Thanks also Mike, David and Terry .... Not my usual thing, but isn't it great when you head off to a location and don't really know what's going to come out of it? It was good light for the white swan ... Sunlight can be a real problem with that.

I'll be hard pushed to put the K7 down for very long though .... The only thing that would cause that would be getting a new K1 ... Unfortunately the K7 cannot retire just yet....

Comment by McGregNi posted on At Waddon Ponds at 20/05/2016 - 06:41

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo