McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Thanks Richard

Comment by McGregNi posted on At Waddon Ponds at 19/05/2016 - 20:57

McGregNi
A small haven amongst the bustle of Purley Way near Croydon, the 'Waddon Ponds' is home to a fair bit of wildlife, including the more common squirrels and some rather large water rats!

Here's a few I got when passing through yesterday, with the K7 and Tamron AF70-300mm 1:4.5-5.6 Di LD



Comment Image




Comment Image





Comment Image





Comment Image


Hope you like them, thanks for looking

Comment by McGregNi posted on At Waddon Ponds at 19/05/2016 - 13:10

McGregNi
johnriley wrote:
One of the things I don't agree with is the accusation that shooting in JPEG has no merit because all the decisions are made by Ricoh engineers. Notwithstanding that all basic decisions, even for RAW capture, have already been made by Ricoh engineers, it does strike me that if anyone ought to know how to get the best out of Pentax cameras it will be those who designed them.

But the magic ingredient is how we set up the JPEG capture. From a basic style (I use Natural) we can adjust saturation, contrast and sharpness. Then we can choose how we use WB settings. It's just like deciding what sort of film to buy. After that, all the rest of the decisions lie with us and it's up to us to make a great image. We can even post process as well if desired.
I would agree that that there's some logic to the idea that the camera creators could get the most out of the camera they created ..... unfortunately the main message we keep hearing again and again is that the other brands 'do it better' . This is because there is often the perception that the other brands offer up more highly 'prepared' and 'optimised' looking JPEGs that jump out more on the screen and so appeal more to the wider population of customers . That seems to be the most common point made around here regarding camera JPEGs.

I do accept that our camera JPEGs are high quality in IQ terms, especially if your lens and settings have allowed you to take advantage of all the automatic corrections available. However, ultimately, in dynamic range and tonal range plus colour depth terms, then they are a step down from the RAW output available.

Thats not to say I don't like and use camera JPEGs .... I do. The're a great way of carrying out easy batch processing of a lot of very similar shots. I agree with John that its important though to spend the time to set up the custom image controls properly for each particular situation .... eg landscapes, portraits etc in order to be sure that the camera processes its output as best as possible and to reduce any further adjustments needed later. ...... (stu ... you didn't tell me your saturation and sharpness settings

John himself is a good example of someone who gets good looking, 'optimised' JPEGs out of the camera, with a bit of work in Photoshop usually I think ...... also MrB (Philip) produces optimised high quality images from camera JPEGs with a few tweaks in Paint Shop Pro. To be honest (and I'll gladly be corrected with other names) there are very few others around here shooting camera JPEGs who I would put into the same category ...... most of the other high quality output shown here is by members who use RAW.

Comment by McGregNi posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 10:49

McGregNi
Dingo, I thought you were just being prepared for the disintegration of civilisation .... Don't forget to check your tin opener works though

Stu's harmless enough, and of course he just wants to provoke for some discussion in a devils advocate sort of way, as John said. I don't recognise this accusation of 'trolling' in this context here .... Wow, I was called a troll here as well, just for some point I made about Lightroom ....I wonder who made that accusation as well? Nigel, the Pentax User troll. .... That's ridiculous!

There are sometimes real trolls on Pentaxforums.com, usually of the type that starts off moaning about something he can't do with his camera or flash, and ends with a statement that he is going to leave Pentax and go to Canon or Nikon .... And it's often one of their first posts!

Comment by McGregNi posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 09:43

McGregNi
That was a once in a lifetime opportunity spotting that drink Richard! Well done, and an amazing coincidence that the little boat in the glass looks very much like the OP's photograph at the start here! I guess that's what separates that real photographers out from the pack ......

The only issue is that these sort of image composites play into the hands of those who see 'Photoshopping' as nothing more than trickery and fantasy. We probably just need some levels, curves, highlight correction, colour balance and saturation control demonstrations

Comment by McGregNi posted on this will be intresting at 19/05/2016 - 06:22

McGregNi
Sorry Stu, can't play ball too much I don't personally see the value in those particular 'out the camera' aims ....

To me the camera is the tool I use to try and capture the most quality image data the sensor is capable of .... With the most dynamic range, best exposure value and sharp where needed. I want to compose and frame up nicely of course, but I try and shoot a little wide for leveling and cropping purposes later, as there may be different shapes and amounts of each edge I want to keep. The best time to make those choices is quietly on the computer when that's the sole thing to worry about.

Nice pic ..... What saturation and sharpness settings did you use ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on this will be intresting at 18/05/2016 - 21:03

McGregNi
But Rob, you gave a poor impression of your results in another thread recently. It sounded like you were disappointed and images were a bit soft. I was not particularly impressed by the examples shown in that other thread either ... They had a sort of 'kit lens' look to them. (if that's a 'look' !) ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on K-1 Lens Bundle Decision (for mainly low light work) at 18/05/2016 - 19:02

McGregNi
They all need more of what I term 'high tone contrast ' ..... In PhotoShop terms that could be a curves adjustment with a steeper shape in the top third of the curve in order to bring up the highlights without losing the depth in the blues of the sky. The effect should be to increase contrast in the higher tones only.

If you use a programme with sliders for highlights, brightness and shadows, then try just the highlights one. It your programme has a ' white point' slider then move that downwards mostly and the highlights one upwards a bit less.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wrest Park today at 18/05/2016 - 17:13

McGregNi
It's near enough twice the price as well, so I'd be expecting some more bite! So the best value for now is likely to be in the bundles with camera.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K-1 Lens Bundle Decision (for mainly low light work) at 18/05/2016 - 17:07

McGregNi
With ISO performable such as the K-1 offers then I don't think the 'light gathering' aspect of a wide aperture is important. So the 28-105 is more versatile for your purposes.....

However, so far I am seeing more evidence of good image quality from the 24-70 than from the 28-105 ......

You may not feel that 70mm is long enough on FF .... However you could crop out , say, 1/4 of the frame I'm sure with little loss of quality in order to make things look bigger.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K-1 Lens Bundle Decision (for mainly low light work) at 18/05/2016 - 15:09

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo