MattMatic

Joined: 2nd July 2002

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

MattMatic
I found it very hard to find a review for this little beastie... there were a couple, but not that many test shots. And then I made the mistake of reading Rice High's blog on it

Still, SRS did a splendid job of shipping this to me (thumbs up again for SRS and the team!). With the cash back and the currently low price, I thought it was time I tried this out (even if it's succumbing to the dreaded LBA!!).

I've only just stuck it on the K20D and already it's "wow!".
Initial thoughts:
* A substantial lens! It's heavier and "fatter" than the 16-45, but not by much. Mounted on the K20D with grip the whole thing is pretty weighty!
* Zoom ring seems heavily damped, but not a problem.
* Centre pinch lens cap is a welcome addition - especially with the petal hood.
* SDM focus is incredibly quiet. (Am I still using the same camera???!)
* Bokeh looks delicious. Not quite up to the 50/1.4, but very similar to the 24-90
* Zoom range is a nice compromise. I often use the 90mm end of the 24-90, but having the 17mm end may end up being better still.

(EDIT: Yes, there's distortion, but it's not uncontrollable. Easily corrected in SPDS3. Vignetting - maybe, but again not a problem. Close focus on 17mm is excellent, though not quite as "whacky" as the 16-45.)

I've taken a few test shots, and the resolution looks stellar!
Will be off at lunch (weather willing) to take a few test shots... but this could very well end up being a main lens (I certainly could have done 98% of a recent wedding with this zoom range!).

If you need any questions answered, just let me know and I'll do my best!
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on SMC-DA 17-70 f/4 A:[IF] SDM at 23/12/2008 - 11:54

MattMatic
It's where it says "Category: Music" that is odd

Maybe it's a song... "Flash, ah-haaaa, flash for a Pentax with a case"
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on Anyone fancy their chances with this one? at 23/12/2008 - 10:05

MattMatic
I would have thought it was more down to the limits of the metering system. Although you can do longer exposures, the meter cannot accurately measure very, very low levels of light (you'll notice the flashing values - indicating out of range).

However, on "M" mode it would, I suppose, have been possible to increase the available shutter speeds... though when you get longer than 30seconds it doesn't matter if you do 60 or 63 seconds! (Remember each "stop" is a doubling of time - so from 30 to 60, to 120, to 240 are all one stop).

As John says, though, beyond 30 seconds and the CCD can get very warm - introducing all kinds of noise, and uses quite a chunk of power (so the batteries can get quite hot)! The K20D is better in this respect - having a CMOS sensor rather than CCD.

Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on 30 seconds max, why? at 23/12/2008 - 06:46

MattMatic
Are you sure that was the URL??
The one you gave sort of worked... but badly...

Try the proper one:
http://www.shortcutinc.com/cms/index.php

(notice "dot PHP" at the end, not "slash PHP")
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on Problem on silkypix website ?? at 21/12/2008 - 08:16

MattMatic
Just to correct Peter's histogram explanation...

It doesn't matter how high the histogram graph is - that just shows there's lots of pixels at that particular intensity. What matters is where the "hump" (or "humps") sit.

The areas to watch are the extreme left and extreme right
Ideally you don't want anything touching the far left or the far right - that means information has been lost as either too dark or too bright (respectively). However, in practice this isn't always possible.

Cameras have a certain "dynamic range" - the variance of dark to light they can handle. The human eye has a phenomenal dynamic range (in part backed up by the brain's ability to seamlessly join dark and bright regions while adjusting the eye to compensate). Cameras have limited range - they cannot, for example, record direct sunlight at the same time as pitch black! (Photographers will often use filters, multiple exposures, even "HDR" photography to capture wide dynamic range situations.)

In the OP's original situation, pointing the camera directly at the light source is essentially saying to the metering system "The light source is important - please record it for me". Consequently, the rest of the image has to plunge into darkness (because the range of bright to dark is outside the range) - the camera is trying not to "clip" the part of the image you are saying is important.

When looking at the histogram you have to also take into account the subject - for example, when taking images of stained-glass windows, or subjects that are mainly black, or mainly white - you need to use some discernment when interpreting the histogram

The Pentax dSLRs have a couple of things that help in those situations:
First, there is the "AE-L" button. You point the camera more towards the lighting level you wish to be "normal", and press AE-L. Then, when you reframe with the light source more in the frame the camera will "ignore" it - taking the original reading.

Secondly, you can use "M" mode. Again, here you can carefully examine the range of light levels and use your brain (!) to work out the "correct" exposure - based on what you want shown in the image.

Thirdly, there is the exposure compensation.

Don't forget that the metering system aims for mid-grey. So, if you are taking a shot of a black cat against a black wall you will have to adjust the exposure to make it underexpose by 1 or 2 stops (otherwise you'll have a grey cat against a grey wall!). Conversely, taking a shot of a white tree in a snow covered hill will need over-exposing by 1 or 2 stops (otherwise, again, you'll have a grey tree against a grey hill!).

As John mentioned, the beauty of digital is its immediacy. You can always check straight away and adjust. Additionally, you have some latitude when you get back to the PC - you can adjust exposure somewhat there (especially when you use RAW to shoot).

Hope that explains things a bit better!!
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on Dull photos / Dim User at 19/12/2008 - 12:10

MattMatic
Thanks Jim - I checked on Monday and that wasn't there.
Certainly looks a fine replacement for the 16-45... doesn't help my LBA and wallet one bit!!
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 18/12/2008 - 14:18

MattMatic
Quote:
not so long ago people were happy to pay over £300 for this lens
I did £325, IIRC. Still worth it though
The current price is a steal! (Though I'm still fairly tempted by the newer SMC-DA 17-70...)
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 18/12/2008 - 10:39

MattMatic
Fascinating! We've visited Dover Castle many times (being EH members).
Thanks for sharing!
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on An interesting experience at 18/12/2008 - 10:35

MattMatic
DNG is RAW - you are correct.
The Pentax adds "PEF" RAW format as well - which is a compressed RAW. It only really means you get more shots per card - that's all.

Some reviews have indicated that the JPG images out of camera are better from the Samsung... who knows! They both take the same lenses, the same flash guns, and have nearly identical features. The only difference is in the molding - and the grips are consequently different shapes.

No one is really sure how the two companies shared the development. Certainly the K20D CMOS sensor was developed by Samsung.

Either way it's no problem being here The features and way-of-working are identical - so you can always ask and (generally ) get a sensible answer.

Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on Samsung and Pentax Difference at 17/12/2008 - 12:51

MattMatic
When you use the Extreme III cards, especially with the SanDisk "Micromate" reader, the download speed onto the PC is ballistic. That's where you'll gain the most improvements

Given the crazy cheap price of the Extreme III cards, I've stuck to them (4Gb from www.picstop.co.uk )
Matt

Comment by MattMatic posted on SD-HC card speed at 17/12/2008 - 12:47

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo