All Forum Comments
Comment by Marky posted on DA 12-24mm advice at 07/02/2009 - 11:34
But most magazine reviews suggest its a soft lens. I'm not sure if the Tokina version is the same as the Pentax version but that also has had some unfavourable reviews when compared to the Sigma 10-20 in other mounts.
That said, all reviews have said that the 12-24 is decent at F8 - F11 though.
I know we are loyal to Pentax but at times I think we are too loyal and overrate some of their lenses.
Comment by Marky posted on DA 12-24mm advice at 07/02/2009 - 10:46
Money would have to be no object to afford some decent lenses to do it justice though.
Comment by Marky posted on If Money was no problem what camera would you buy? at 26/01/2009 - 23:02
... but more people are realising that it's less than super sharp at the edges as they upgrade their cameras from 6 to 10 to 14.6 MP..
Thats a good point, but the 2 mark1 lenses i've tried at 6mp have both been soft at the edges.
Comment by Marky posted on 18-55 kit lens - mk1 v mk2 at 25/01/2009 - 15:10
Comment by Marky posted on 18-55 kit lens - mk1 v mk2 at 25/01/2009 - 10:59
They had some Pentax lens reviews. They were comparing the 18-55II kit lens, the 16-45 and the 16-50.
According to their imatest ratings the markII kit lens was quite a bit sharper across the board (i.e in the 18-55 range and the 18-55's aperture range) then the 16-45.
WDC also reckoned that at 35mm the kit lens (mark1) was sharper than some primes they had tested the previous month.
Comment by Marky posted on 18-55 kit lens - mk1 v mk2 at 21/01/2009 - 20:05
Comment by Marky posted on K200D or K10D at 13/01/2009 - 22:42
Possibly the last new K10D in the country (demo model) with a mk2 18-55 @ £365
Comment by Marky posted on K200D or K10D at 13/01/2009 - 22:35
Comment by Marky posted on K10D for sale with 18-55mm lens at 07/01/2009 - 23:39
I suppose the same goes for shops. If Pentax had more of a presence in the likes of Jessops / Currys etc. they may sell more bodies....
Comment by Marky posted on Canon, Nikon & Sony - a revelation! at 04/01/2009 - 21:55


It would be a mistake to just evaluate sharpness when considering a lens
Colour and flare handling is stunning.
Although I still think we underrate non pentax glass on here. That said, as 2 expirenced members I'll trust your judgement that the 12-24 is a decent lens.