George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
Let us apply some rigorous logic to your question.

If the two lenses are exactly the same "quality", then at any given focal length, the results would obviously be the same.

If they are not EXACTLY the same, then they are not the same. So you can draw no conclusions about comparative performance at different focal lengths.

I suspect that lurking behind your hypothetical question is a real one, and that you are weighing up the pros and cons of two similar lenses which are claimed to perform equally well.

If I am correct, which are these lenses?

G
(Who is often incorrect)

Comment by George Lazarette posted on f4 on an f2 / f4 on an f3.5 at 07/08/2008 - 23:11

George Lazarette
Howard,

There is no doubt that a single lens is very convenient, and for exploring a new town on holiday, or climbing a mountain, it might be just the ticket.

But a zoom lens is a compromise, and the larger the zoom range, the greater the compromise will have to be. It's obvious if you think about it.

In addition to lower image quality, zoom lenses will always be significantly slower than prime lenses, and the greater the zoom range, the slower the zoom will be (all else being equal). There ARE semi-fast zooms (not necessarily in K-mount), but they are invariably big, heavy and expensive.

My rule of thumb used to be that a zoom should not have a greater range than three times the shortest focal length, but nowadays four times is probably OK. The excellent Pentax 24-90 is nearly four times, and it's quality almost rivals a prime. But it is, of course, quite slow.

So, for your purposes, why not? Although I would question how often you really need such length in a walkaround lens.

As an alternative, I would consider the new 17-70.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Being lazy at 07/08/2008 - 22:56

George Lazarette
royd63uk wrote:
Hi
I hope i have joined the right forum, I have just purchased a GX-20 and am awaiting delivery.Does anyone here use one and what can i expect as I am changing from sony alpha A700.
Roy
Hello,

Several people here have a K20D or GX20, but not many have come from Sony. Feel free to ask us about your camera, then (once you are familiar with it) tell us how it compares with the Sony.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on GX-20 at 07/08/2008 - 19:06

George Lazarette
Wow, how, and bow (low)!

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on A Fly at 07/08/2008 - 13:58

George Lazarette
Definitely a "Wow!" shot.

Well done.

Come on, Clarky, you've got competition.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on A Fly at 07/08/2008 - 12:54

George Lazarette
That's what I call severe barrel distortion.

It's not a lens for brick walls, or architecture generally.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on How to test new Sigma 10-20 ? at 07/08/2008 - 11:49

George Lazarette
gartmore wrote:
There is an old saying about photojournalism that it is 'F8 and be there' meaning you have to be technically competent and have a foot in the door.
I've always interpreted that to mean that being in the right place at the right time is much more important than technical expertise.

F8 means that the subject will probably be more or less in focus, and any defects in exposure can be sorted out in the darkroom.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Selling Photographs at 07/08/2008 - 09:38

George Lazarette
I have to say, Sockpuppet, that you do illustrate your sale items very well.

Makes a nice change from all those blurred phonecam pic's on Ebay.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Phoenix (Vivitar, Cosina) 100mm F3/5 Macro at 07/08/2008 - 09:25

George Lazarette
If you had meant the newspaper, you would have spelt it: Grauniad*.

I like this shot. The dog's lugubrious expression immediately reminded me of a character in one of my favourite films: Babe - Pig In The City**.

G

* A reference to their famous predeliction for typographical inexactitude.
** Some Like It Hot and Breakfast AT Tiffany's being the others. I don't frequent cinemas, I infrequent them.

Comment by George Lazarette posted on The guardian at 07/08/2008 - 09:12

George Lazarette
I would expect that the criteria for selecting sensor sensitivity would include some or all of the following:

1 The focal length. A longer length demands a higher shutter speed, so either sensitivity or aperture must be changed to compensate.

2 Lens MTF. This information is included in recent Pentax lenses, and tells the camera the "best" aperture to use (in other words, the aperture that gives the best results for the given lens).

3 Depth of field. There might be an attempt to avoid very wide apertures in order to maintain DOF.

There are no doubt others I haven't thought of.

Number 2 provides one reason why a Pentax lens might be treated differently from a third party lens, or indeed from an A series lens.

As for comparative lens sharpness, the clue might lie in the names on the lenses. There is a reason for the Riley Rule.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on K10d and automatic ISO change criterion at 07/08/2008 - 07:56

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo