All Forum Comments
Comment by George Lazarette posted on LumoPro LP160 vs Yongnuo YN460-II at 07/06/2010 - 13:17
And now, sensible people know that Cameron has to soften up the electorate for a big rise in VAT and other nasties, so he needs to paint a fairly bleak picture.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Another pointless thread at 07/06/2010 - 13:08
Andrew, I am sorry that you have been one of the "victims" of this mini-campaign to encourage more thoughtful criticism, but I do feel that people who post pictures are not best served by the approach of Mowog and Mayday, however well-intentioned.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 07/06/2010 - 12:52
This is where I start to agree with people who say they never use PP. PP is a tool but it's hard to rescue a dud photograph using PP. If it's not sharp then sharpening may disguise it a bit but it will not remedy it. If there is no selective DOF then blurring may disguise it but it's no remedy. Incidentally I am not saying these photographs are duds so I hope no offence taken.
Mike
I have to say that the last image, despite the DOF, is a splendid shot. This is a real character, shown by the pose as well as the face. You can see why Gary might have thought: "Got to have that!", and fired quickly before she changed position.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on images from an istD at 07/06/2010 - 12:30
Andrew and all contributors,
I'd like to contribute to this, in a constructive way, by first saying I agree in principle with Mike's message about the use of 'critique' to help us all improve our skills.
None of this ought to be see as detracting from Andrew's images, neither from these nor from those in any of his many other valuable series. This just seems to be the most recent place where this issue has again become extant.
As a relatively new chum here, I suggest that the more experienced people here who are adept at articulating their judging, all collaborate to produce a C&C 'style template'.
I'm sensing that some structure would provide a means, a vehicle if you like, to facilitate the C&C. And maybe make Mike happy...
People wishing to comment on any images in this forum would then be welcome to:
- use that 'style template' on its own (ie, fill in the blanks),
- use the template as the basis for their own synthesis
- use the template in conjunction with their own C&C and commentary
- ignore the template and provide C&C in their own way.
As you can see above, no-one is compelled to use it of course, so it is not as if a template would become stifling or restrictive.
When completed, the proposed 'style template' could be made into a sticky post in this forum.
So - what say ye?
Mike's original post betrayed a little irritation, I feel, at the uniformly upbeat comments that proceeded his. He was really criticising the critics more than the pictures.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 07/06/2010 - 12:17
Criticised for liking a photo. I never said these were great photos. But I enjoyed them and I think they work together. I don't see much wrong with that. Is this section only for technical experts to comment on photos? I'm a beginner. I have posted my own photos and I have appreciated the comments on them. People have taken their time to do this and I feel I should in some way reciprocate, but I can't talk technically about photography in the way that some people can. There are high standards here and it is quite daunting for a newbie to join a forum such as this - join in competitions and discussions on photos. And I'm kind of getting the message this isn't really welcome. I'm happy to step back and just observe.
The point that Mike and I are trying to make is that this is a forum for people who are striving to improve, and they will be helped more by constructive criticism than they will by uncritical praise.
Anyone who wants the latter should join Red Bubble. But do ask Alice to be ready to pass you the sick-bag. You'll be needing it.
Over the years quite a number of people have joined this site as raw beginners, posted prolifically, and become really quite good quite quickly as a result of feedback they received.
The last thing anybody wants to do is to discourage people from posting pictures.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 07/06/2010 - 12:07
But I am firmly in the camp that believes that Photoshop, like George the Third, ought never to have occurred. One can only wonder, at so grotesque a blunder.
G
With apologies to EC Bentley.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Dreamy Steam over Glenfinnan at 07/06/2010 - 11:47
I think this is a nice picture spoiled (for me) by over-enthusiastic photoshoppery.
Mike
Perhaps I would appreciate it more if I learned to use it myself!
G
PS: Not saying it's been abused here, but I think there are other approaches that could have been used to improve the picture.
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Dreamy Steam over Glenfinnan at 07/06/2010 - 11:45
But I do like the sense of a busy sea road, and the crowded background really helps the shot.
Behind the ferry is the IOM Steam Packet pier, which I know very well.
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on Royal Daffodill (HDR) at 07/06/2010 - 11:29
G
Comment by George Lazarette posted on LumoPro LP160 vs Yongnuo YN460-II at 07/06/2010 - 11:14


The external pack holds a lot more power, having six C batteries. Recycle times aren't usually an issue.
G