Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
This fortnightly competition is designed to encourage forum members to go out and capture new images relating to a set theme. The following rules apply:

1. All entries must be images taken within 14 days of the current theme being set;
2. Full Exif data should be supplied with each image, including date/time of capture;
3. Image should not exceed 800 pixels width;
4. Deadline for submission of entries is 1800 GMT every other Wednesday;
5. The competition winner will select winning entries 1-3 (and award ‘Highly Commended’s, if so desired), and post the results as soon as possible after the Wednesday deadline (though this will partly depend on time zone);
6. In contrast to the weekly competition the judge is not required to supply detailed feedback on all entries. Instead, other entrants – and forum members more generally – are encouraged to provide their own feedback on the various images in the parallel feedback thread in the competitions section;
7. The latest winner will select the next theme taking into consideration its practicality for all potential entrants (eg. don’t select ‘Winter’ when it’s summer down under), and will initiate the new competition as soon as possible after the previous results have been posted.

Happy snapping

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition Rules at 15/10/2008 - 06:38

Dr. Mhuni
See below a picture of the replacement battery charger I got recently from China – to take the place of one I lost on holiday. I was initially a bit anxious about what this might do to my batteries, though after reassurance from other buyers (and because of the complications of getting branded chargers from the UK here to Ethiopia) I took the plunge and ordered one.

Am very pleased I did. There is no noticeable change in battery life. Meanwhile, it’s much more compact than the original charger (having a fold out US-type plug built-in, to which you can connect an adaptor). It also has a lead for charging from a car jack – which is actually very useful (particularly here in Ethiopia). I don’t know if it will have any impact on the long-term battery life, but so far I am very happy.

So if you’ve lost your original charger – or even want a more compact option - do consider one of these.


Comment Image

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lost your charger? at 14/10/2008 - 13:07

Dr. Mhuni
Any other opinions on the location of the comp?

I will go with the majority view!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New Competition at 13/10/2008 - 13:09

Dr. Mhuni
Okay, a fortnightly comp it is then. Theme set/judging due every other Wednesday. Unless anyone objects, I will set the theme this Wednesday and post judgment in two weeks time. There are a few outstanding issues, however…

First, practicalities – where should the new comp be sited? The easiest option would be in the Gallery competition area. This facilitates posting and I do think the way the images are organised here is an improvement. However, perhaps adding a fortnightly comp here would detract from the existing weekly one. Alternatively, we could just have a thread in the competitions section of the Forum Home – in which pics could be posted in the old style from websites such as flickr, photobucket etc. Would appreciate your thoughts on this.

It would be a good idea to have a short explanation of the comp/rules permanently at the head of each fortnightly thread. Does anyone know how this can be achieved?

Regarding rules, these wouldn’t be too complicated: a picture taken within the two weeks; posted image size no bigger than 800 pixels (though I’m not sure how this would be policed – as JR did in the old comp; might we all agree to remove larger images and inform the entrant of this rule? [I would offer, but my internet access is intermittent]); theme chosen by last winner paying attention to its practicality for all potential entrants (eg. no winter shots when it’s summer in Oz etc.); otherwise choice of theme (or brief – I don’t see why both can’t be accommodated) open to the winner’s whim – from the technically-driven to the subject-based; deadline midnight GMT every other Wednesday; judgment to be posted as soon after this as possible; winner to set theme as soon after this as possible. Let me know if I’ve missed anything out.

Regarding judging, as indicated in my previous post – the format could either remain the same with an assessment of each photo by the judge and his/her selection of 1-3 or 1-3 + HCs; or the judge could just decide the latter and leave the feedback to fellow forum members. I would suggest the former – it may be more onerous for the winner, but the latter option might get complicated and even perhaps interfere with the final judgment.

As stated above, I don’t think this should adversely affect the existing competition. I for one intend to continue entering this too if I already have an appropriate photo – or even to go out to take pics for this too (I need all the practice I can get!).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New Competition at 13/10/2008 - 09:48

Dr. Mhuni
Thought I’d wait for as much feedback as possible before posting a reply – to gauge opinions. Seems like the suggestion has got a mixed response.

Regarding a new competition undermining the existing one. Would this be the case? I’m not sure. At present, my impression is that generally the bulk of competition entries are not ones that have been taken that week. So if there were an additional comp with this as a stipulation, I doubt it would impact on the number of participants. In any case, I’d imagine that many people could easily enter an archive pic (or if desired a new shot) to the main comp and shoot something for a pic of the week one too. I know I usually could – and as a newbie my archive must be pretty small compared to most forum members. Also, I wouldn’t anticipate as many entries to a pic of the week comp as there would be to the main comp – but hopefully there would be enough of us who might regard it as a bit of fun, as well as a useful exercise, to make it viable.

Regarding Unlocker’s suggestion to have something more like a game. I agree, the fun aspect should be at the forefront. However, there would be the problem – if a winner wasn’t being judged – of who would set the topic/brief? I like the structured quality of a comp, too – it’s good discipline I think to being required to take a pic of something within a time limit.

The feedback through the judging is another good feature of the existing comp. Though perhaps in a new comp the judge could be expected to pick a winner (or 1,2,3 and/or HCs) – while other participants/members could be encouraged to provide feedback. This would not only differentiate it from the existing comp, but it would also make the judging less onerous – though on the rare occasions I did win the old comp, I actually found it a useful exercise to spend time considering the merits of each entry.

Another way of differentiating it from the existing comp might be to have a different timeframe. Say a fortnightly or monthly comp. My preference would be the former – a month is a little long as far as I’m concerned. Two weeks would be perfect actually, giving people a little more time to contemplate and capture their entry.

What are your thoughts? I’m inclined to do as John Riley suggests, and simply start a new fortnightly comp – just to see if this will fly. As outlined above, I don’t see this being any real threat to the existing one – though if anyone feels particularly strongly on this score do let me know. Perhaps interest in a new comp will be so negligible as to render it pointless – but then why not try it and see?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New Competition at 11/10/2008 - 14:41

Dr. Mhuni
Yes, I've seen a lot of gripes about QC of the Sigma 10-20 - but when people get a good one, everyone seems very happy with it. I was thinking about getting a super-wide lens when I'm back in the UK at Xmas and was looking at this and the DA12-24. Unusually, from the photos on Flickr I actually liked the colour rendering of the Sigma better. Generally, my impression is that Pentax excels on this score (another reason I opted for the 16-45 over the Sigma 17-70).

I'm finding the 16-45 just great, by the way - a big improvement on the kit lens and it has fantastic colour rendering (though the kit wasn't bad either on this front). Thanks John (amongst others) for continually singing the praises of this lens (which also played a part in my getting it - alongside the current price, which made it irrestible!).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lens QC at 10/10/2008 - 09:43

Dr. Mhuni
I was wondering if anyone would be interested in a new forum competition. I understand that many people are unhappy with the way the original has gone since the re-organisation of the website in July. Although this appears to have improved of late (at least recent judges have been giving feedback), some former regulars have sadly given up on it entirely. Rather than replacing the existing competition what I envisage would simply augment it. Hopefully it might also tempt back some of the old competition regulars.

It seems the existing competition mostly draws entries from users’ archives. While this was/is often true with my own entries (especially when I have a particularly relevant photo, or when I haven’t had the time or inspiration to shoot something that week), I have always found the competition much more interesting when I made the effort to go out a get a picture on the week’s theme. So my idea is this – to have an alternate competition which would only be open to entries taken in the week after the theme was set. Clearly potential entrants would not always be able to obtain relevant photos (same with this week’s competition theme for me – never much sign of autumn in evergreen Ethiopia!), or even have the time to go out looking for them (or pp-ing them), in a particular week - but it strikes me that this would be a useful way of exercising our photographic imaginations (and testing technique). The number of entries might be significantly smaller than the main comp, but then so what – and in any case the judge might welcome this!

Regarding practicalities. Could this simply be set up as a thread in the competitions section, along the lines of the old comp? Meanwhile, the rules would remain the same as the other comp – theme set by previous week’s winner; deadline of 12 midnight GMT on Sunday; judge provides feedback on all entries; awards places 1-3 and HCs if so desired.

Anybody else interested in initiating this?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New Competition at 09/10/2008 - 12:24

Dr. Mhuni
Interesting that in all the responses so far, noone has had to return a lens. Likewise with my 4 lens (though the kit lens does have a mild FF tendency). Perhaps - like crime - the 'problem' of rogue lenses is magnified by understandable complaints by an unrepresentative sample of people who have actually suffered one.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lens QC at 09/10/2008 - 06:01

Dr. Mhuni
I have recently taken delivery of a new lens brought out by a friend from the UK – the DA16-45 – which from first impressions seems to have matched my high expectations, given its reputation. One reason I opted for the 16-45, as opposed to the DA or Sigma 17-70, was its reputed greater QC consistency. (A factor which becomes especially important when you are based in a country distant from where the lens is bought, and are therefore not in a good position to replace a defective lens). I have got the impression from various forums (including this one) that erratic quality control is a real issue with regard to lenses.

Anyway, to get to the point, I was wondering:

a. What forum members experience of quality control issues was? Have they had to return lenses often? If so are some manufacturers (or even lenses) particularly bad (or good) in this regard? From what I have gleaned it seems that Sigma has the worst reputation for QC; though some lenses from Pentax, notably the 16-50 and also perhaps the new 17-70, don’t appear to shine here either. Interestingly – given that, if I’m not mistaken, it has in the past had a reputation for producing rather cheap quality lens – I haven’t come across criticism of Tamron on this score, though this may be just coincidental (I can’t claim to have done in-depth research).

b. What do people do to check newly purchased lenses? I came across a thread on another forum that recommended the following test for focusing (http://www.focustestchart.com/chart.html); and for de-centered elements, taking pictures of a contrasty wall at varying apertures and (in the case of zooms) focal lengths. Does anyone have other suggestions?

It strikes me that having feedback on this issue here would be useful for forum members (not least me!).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lens QC at 07/10/2008 - 12:42

Dr. Mhuni
Many thanks for the kind offer, Martin. The postal service is actually pretty reliable here, but I'll see if I can download it before bothering you for a CD rom. Will try to get a day when the connection is fast.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Horizon detail at 07/09/2008 - 10:21

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo