Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Hyram wrote:
Dr. Mhuni,

Thank you for posting a shot of the Addis Hilton.

My brother-in-law uses it a lot and we have often wondered what it looks like - now we know
It was the least I could do given your kind offer re. the charger.

As for the weather, Prieni - the patch of blue is rather misleading actually. Look to the left for the real weather. Although it has cleared up since then. Should be blue skies for at least the next three months now. Oh well, somehow I'll cope.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition #2 Product Shot - COMMENTS at 11/11/2008 - 12:02

Dr. Mhuni
Addis Hilton - The place to stay and play!
Comment Image


Could have done with a bathing beauty in a retro bikini or a James Bond type in the foreground but the weather wasn't great and noone obliged!

Taken with the K10D, DA16-45 @ 16mm, F10, 1/40 last Saturday

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition # 2 Product Shot at 11/11/2008 - 05:12

Dr. Mhuni
Cheers Peter - it is much clearer now (though I'm not so sure about the content:lol.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The definitive ND Grad thread?! at 04/11/2008 - 12:03

Dr. Mhuni
I know this is a well worn theme in this forum (and others!). However, in trying to choose which grads to get, I still am struggling to find information from the many threads on the subject which is complete enough for me to come to a final conclusion. So I thought it might be useful to attempt to start a thread which includes ALL (or as much as possible) the info required by someone looking for advice on ND Grads.

First, I will outline what I have gleaned from numerous trawls through this and other forums on and off over the past 6 months. I think I probably have acquired a fair bit of info on the subject, but there are important gaps in my knowledge as set out below (some of which will be obvious), so please fill any gaps in posts below in order for the thread to live up to its title!

Right in ascending quality the ND Grad options appear to be as follows:

1. Circular screw-in ‘normal’ filters.

Pros: Portable and easy to fit on the lens
Cons: Only fit one lens (without adaptor) and more seriously they are compositionally restrictive as the graduation is fixed (in the centre) and cannot be adjusted up and down to correspond with the placing of the horizon.

2. Cokin A System (I haven’t looked at this system really so the pros & cons may well be incomplete)
Pros: Price, filter holder fits all lens sizes (with adaptor), and more adjustable than circular filters (the last two points are true of all the systems below)
Cons: Not truly ND as there is a colour cast (magenta); this system also, if I’m not mistaken, causes vignetting from a narrower angle than more expensive ones (though I don’t know when this begins to be a problem – does anyone else know this?)

3. Cokin P System
Pros: Price, availability, better than A system & more adjustable than 1. Or 2. (as the filters are larger, they are presumably more adjustable than the A system ones?). There are also many accessories available (including a filter holder for very wide lenses - 12mm? & below – and lens hoods, caps etc.). The P system seems to be the most common consumer choice.
Cons: Like the A System (though not as bad?) there is still a colour cast, though this is serious only when more than one filter is used(?).

4. Hitech 85 Filters for the Cokin P fit

Pros: Price (slightly cheaper than Cokin P) and as above in 3. Also I have seen some claims that the colour cast is not as strong as with the Cokin filters (though perhaps these refer to the 100 filters).
Cons: On the other hand I have also seen comments that the cast is no different to Cokin Ps.

5. Kood P Series for the Cokin P fit (available through some ebay sellers – eg. Surrey Photographic Supplies)
Pros: Price (you can get each filter for £6.99 + p & p; and cheaper holders & accessories) & possibly others – though I have found very little feedback on Kood filters. Can anyone help out here?
Cons: See Pros.

6. Cokin Z-Pro System
Pros: Colour cast almost gone; cheaper than 7; more adjustable than 1-5; less danger of vignetting than 1-5.
Cons: Filters expensive at ca. £40 a shot; holder, adaptors & accessories also considerably more expensive than 1-5; colour cast not gone entirely; all filters from 6 on are larger and hence more cumbersome.

7. Cokin X-Pro System
Pros & cons: I’m not sure exactly how the X-Pro differs from the Z-Pro, but they are more expensive and presumably better. Otherwise I think the pros & cons are similar to 6.

8. Hitech 100 filters (not sure which system they fit – on the Teamwork (the manufacturers retail arm?) website they state that they fit the P System but this must be a mistake as they measure 100x120mm)
Pros: Price (set of three = £59 (ex. VAT); as indicated above I’ve seen numerous claims that Hitech filters do not have the colour cast problem of Cokins (though perhaps this is only true when comparing the 100s to the Ps rather than the Z or X-Pros?).
Cons: Don’t know?

9. Lee Filter System
Pros: The first system mentioned which are truly ND with no colour cast
Cons: Price (kits with 1 filter & holder) start at £110; also some say that they are not as good with blue skies as Cokins.

10. Singh Ray System – appears to be the acme of ND Grads but I have found no info on them through Google UK. If I’m not mistaken they’re made of glass, which makes them less scratch prone than all of the above (resin based filters) – but also more cumbersome(?). I assume they are even more expensive than Lee.

11. Digital editing There probably is one final option that I should mention, which happens to be the cheapest of the lot as it requires only time and not money – merging multiple exposures (for static shots with a tripod) or different files acquired from a single RAW shot in Photoshop, GIMP, PSP, Elements etc.
Pros: It’s free; more convenient than carrying around filters and accessories; in cases where the areas that you want differently exposed are not at all straight this is a more viable option than grads (hard or soft – see below).
Cons: Merging exposures can be time consuming; some claim that more detail is retained through the use of ND grads; results readily accessible through camera LCD.

There is one other thing I should mention. In most cases ND Grads come in both Hard and Soft forms (as far as I’m aware this is true of all the filters mentioned above apart from Cokin As). The Hard are for shots in which the transition between the two areas of the shot is a clear line (such as a sea horizon); the Soft are used when you do not want such a sudden transition.

Right, that’s the present state of my knowledge. If fellow Pentaxians can add to this it will no doubt be useful to not only me but also other Forum users. From a personal point of view, I’m particularly interested in feedback about the merits of the Kood P and Hitech 85 (and to a lesser extent 100) systems.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The definitive ND Grad thread?! at 04/11/2008 - 10:17

Dr. Mhuni
I know technically according to the new competition rules as the judge, I’m not obliged to comment on entries, but I do feel the need to provide some feedback so here goes. In fact on reflection, formulating thoughts about the pictures seems so intrinsic to the process of judging that it makes me think perhaps we should have both a separate feedback thread as well as judge’s comments. What do people think?

Thanks to all the entrants - it’s been interesting to see the photos as they’ve come in. I have to confess to being a tad disappointed that there weren’t a few more entries. Don’t know if this was my choice of subject or a more general lack of enthusiasm for a second comp. But hopefully over coming months this competition can establish itself as a valued part of the forum. I’m looking forward to participating myself – and also in particular to posts Lilly might make from her rather photogenic forthcoming travel destination, India (you will keep posting won’t you, when you’re away?).

Right, onto the judging... One of the reasons I set this subject (alongside the fact that ‘vistas’ of one sort or another should have been accessible to all forum users) was the difficulty I have encountered successfully capturing the drama of what might be quite extraordinary landscapes. I’ve often come across the advice to include something in the foreground – but in the case of vistas this is often difficult, and I was looking forward to seeing how entrants handled the subject.

Argee – You kind of get two vistas for the price of one here. A cloud-flecked skyscape and a Thames-scape which reminds me (out here in Ethiopia) how much London has to offer. I like the combination. However, I do feel you’re struggling with exposure on both fronts. Some of the clouds/reflections are burnt out; while the detail on the buildings is rather murky. An nd grad would have come in handy here – or HDR processing from a RAW file (or even – with a tripod – use of the multi-exposure feature in the K10D).

Hyram – Lovely sky once again. This time the exposure’s spot on bringing out the beautiful detail on the clouds. However, I’m not so enamoured of what’s going on terrestrially! Seems to me that while the fish eye works with the clouds it leads to large areas of rather featureless water to the right and left. I’ve never used a fisheye – so may well be wrong – but if you had managed to get something (a boat presumably) taking up a decent amount of foreground this might have resulted in a quite stunning shot (or would the foreground object simply be too distorted?).

Belinda B. – Lovely light on a gently undulating landscape and nice pastel tones. I’d like the sky to have been slightly more underexposed, which could have resulted in a more moody shot. Meanwhile the foreground probably requires lightening a little (though not to the extent that you lose the contrast in light). I’m not sure if this would be possible using a single Raw file to get different exposures – but I’d be aiming to have the sky as dark (or darker) than the foreground. I like the sheep appearing in the bottom corner – though I would have cropped the one close to the edge.

Josh – Compositionally I like what’s going on beyond the wall – the wooded hill leading down to the bay on the right of the picture. However, the bay is rather abruptly cropped which substantially detracts from this. FWIW I would have shifted over to include more on the right and also probably placed the horizon higher in the frame. Meanwhile what’s happening in the foreground does little for the backdrop – there’s too much grass. Also, the pic does come across as rather soft. And again nd grads/HDR/ multi-exposure would have been handy to get more detail from the wooded hill.

Serendipity – Another lovely sky this time over a Scottish glen (does this qualify as a glen?!). Colours are great and exposure seems spot on. A nice photo. I do have a couple of issues, however. First, I think the sky should be cropped lower – nearer to the lower bank of cloud. I think this strengthens the picture – the expanse of blue in the pic as is doesn’t really contribute much in my opinion. The other thing is that the line of trees in the middle/foreground is (compositionally speaking) rather static. If you could – and I understand this was probably impossible – have included a row of trees (or something else) leading into, rather than across, the pic this could have resulted in a stunning shot. Basically, this all relates to the difficulties of shooting landscapes that I referred to in the preamble above.

Hefty 1 – A very pleasing scene. I like the composition in this shot. The contours naturally lead the eye into the picture. However, IMO (very) slightly more cropping off the bottom would have strengthened it a tad, helping the balance of the shot . Also – understandably – you’re struggling a bit with exposure, with the loss of some detail on the dark trees and a (verging on) overexposed halo surrounding the trees. Did you use some means of combining exposures for this? I have a hunch you did – which goes to show how complicated this is.

Pnjmcc – I like the use of the foreground here to frame the vista, and the boat going across the picture gives some added interest. However, there is a bit too much foreground and too little vista as far as I’m concerned. I’m kind of curious about what’s behind the branches that obscure the view.

Galoot – I was initially inclined to discount this as a vista. But the more I look at the scale of the ceiling it I can see why you entered it. I do like the way you’ve captured this scale fisheye style – with the arches curving way up to the ceiling. Also, this seems remarkable to me for an ISO 1600 shot – anything I’ve shot at this ISO has noise all over it! How did you manage this – is it the lens, the pp-ing...? However, I’m not so keen on the stained glass fill ins – and in the end it’s probably a tad cramped to win a ‘vista’ comp!

Prieni – As is usually the case with your pics, Prieni, there’s a lot I like about this photo. I love the detailed silhouette of the boat and the OOF fence/grass/hedge(?) in the foreground. The tones are harmonious and it’s a well balanced picture – with the boat and bird on one side and the buoy on the other. However, for me there’s too much featureless sky – I would have cropped it lower. Also, I’m uncertain about the effect on the water – seems a bit harsh, though the contrast with the fence/grass/hedge is good. Finally, though, I’m not sure if this is a vista – probably needs a little more going on in it to qualify.

Malo1961 – I was hoping for some townscapes and this one made me laugh. One associates vistas perhaps with something uplifting and inspirational – but you’ve demonstrated here that this isn’t always the case! It’s a nicely balanced picture with the flats on one side, the road in the middle, and the sliver of trees on the right (I might have included a little more of the trees). And of course the b&w conversion is entirely fitting for the subject.

Lilly – I love the composition and the colours in this pic. Exposure seems spot on – how did you achieve this? Did you use some kind of multiexposure? Or was it just early/late enough in the day for you to get that kind of detail in the shadows? I have been trying to work out what’s so pleasing in the composition. I suppose it’s the complementary shape of the trees and the foreground vegetation/path – combined with the avenue the path follows between the trees. I guess that what’s beyond this is the vista – however, for me the shot’s a little too enclosed to be a winner in this theme. One other thing, on my monitor the pic seems – ever so slightly – soft. I’m not sure it’s even softness – there’s something almost intangible in the detail that I can’t resolve when I look at it. Perhaps I need new glasses! Anyway, I’d be curious to know what your thoughts are on this, as the Sigma 10-20 is one lens I’m considering getting when I’m back in the UK over Xmas.

GlynM – A nicely balanced shot of an interesting architectural subject (would have been a good entry for this week’s ‘regular’ comp). I’m not sure this qualifies as a vista, however. I like the way the arches lead one into the picture – though I might have cropped a bit tighter to enhance this effect. Well exposed – though the shade on the hedge on the right mars the harmonious balance a bit. Out of interest Glyn (or anyone else), would this be a time when a good flash would be strong enough to illuminate this in the way you might want to? Apologies if this is a rather basic (doh!) query, but I have no experience with flashes and this was something else I was considering getting at Xmas (living in Ethiopia, where there’s little to buy except excellent coffee, all my pent up conspicuous consumption is concentrated into brief visits home!).

MikeW – Another fine sky. The only problem being that the really interesting clouds are the ones at the bottom that take up the least space in the frame. Still, the wisps above do balance the picture out nicely. Once again I think I’d have been a little more aggressive with the cropper – I’d have probably gone up a little closer to the track marks at the bottom, which should lead to more attention on the sky. Isn’t the horizon tilting away to the left ever so slightly – or is this an incline?

Right, now to the judging...

Congratulations Hefty 1 for being our first fortnightly winner! There’s just something about the patterns of the tree, shade and undulations in your pic that I find pleasing to my eye.

Serendipity gets the much coveted second for another attractive pastoral shot.

And third place goes to Malo1961 for a different take on the subject, and for making me smile!

So it’s over to you Hefty 1 – I look forward to dusting off the old K10D!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition #1 Vistas at 29/10/2008 - 18:59

Dr. Mhuni
I don't feel any need to push Acers! It's just that Lilly enquired about one at the start of the thread.

And I don't suppose Lilly is solely getting a notebook for use in India alone - in which case price, reliability etc. come into the frame. In any case if I was travelling in India, I'm not sure this would be the time to take advantage of Dell's WW support! I'd imagine that arranging to get a computer fixed while on holiday would be quite complicated.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Laptop for my trip to India at 27/10/2008 - 12:07

Dr. Mhuni
Lilly,

I've had three Acers over the past five years and they've all been reliable (one was a work comp, one was sold, and the last we've still got). Comments about the (cheap-ish) build quality above are probably fair enough, but generally they're fine - even if they might not look like a Mac. Recently got a Vaio, and admittedly it is aesthetically much nicer to work on! However, I also bought an Acer Extensa for my daughter and that's actually a lot more portable and I have done some (minor) editing on it and it was fine.

How long are you going to India for? My tip is check out the south - much more relaxed and with some major attractions (Kerala's canals, Cochin, Tamil Nadu temples, Hampi, Badami [hardly anyone goes here and it's stunning), Bijapur...) which are as impressive if not as well known as those in say Agra and Rajasthan. The food's better too - southern Indian cuisine is just fantastic. People are much nicer too. My wife (who is black British) and I got tired of all the hassle we got in the north. It's the most bigoted place in the world I have travelled (by a country mile). Constant refrain of 'Black and white, black and white' wherever we went. I snapped and got into a fight (the first time since school) outside the Taj Mahal (that monument to love) because someone pointed at my wife and called me a dirty bastard! The hassle's not confined to race either. On the other hand, the south is a different place entirely. Goa's nice too - though more for the food (which is superb) and towns than the beaches (after the East African coast these are rather underwhelming).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Laptop for my trip to India at 27/10/2008 - 05:33

Dr. Mhuni
This thread is for comments on photos appearing in the parallel Fortnightly competition thread. Constructive criticism (alongside praise :wink is encouraged – the main aim of this competition is after all to get us thinking about how we’re using our Pentax’s. I suggest that whoever is judging the current competition should not look at the thread until after judgment is made (which means me this time).

I do have my concerns about running a parallel feedback thread. Partly for practical reasons – the comments being separate from the images (though this can of course be rectified by opening two windows). But also because it will be entirely reliant upon users actively posting feedback. Anyway, let’s see how it goes. If it’s not working we might revert to judge’s comments.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition #1 Vistas - Comments at 22/10/2008 - 11:30

Dr. Mhuni
I have tidied up the rules section and removed the theme description to here (below). Images should be posted in this thread...

The opening theme is ‘Vistas’ – be it a rural panorama, sweeping townscape or even (for the geographically deprived) perhaps something simulated indoors (playing with scale perhaps?). Hopefully this is a broad enough theme to provide everyone with options. So go out and unleash your wide angles.

Not sure how the parallel comments post will work - but let's try it and see. The fact that the comments are not going to appear in the same thread isn't great, to say the least. If it's not working, though, perhaps we'll just have to revert to the judge providing comments.

I'll start a parallel thread after some images are submitted.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition #1 Vistas at 18/10/2008 - 12:44

Dr. Mhuni
I have posted the following in the competition section:

This fortnightly competition is designed to encourage forum members to go out and capture new images relating to a set theme. The following rules apply:

1. All entries must be images taken within 14 days of the current theme being set;
2. Full Exif data should be supplied with each image, including date/time of capture;
3. Image should not exceed 800 pixels width;
4. Deadline for submission of entries is 1800 GMT every other Wednesday;
5. The competition winner will select winning entries 1-3 (and award ‘Highly Commended’s, if so desired), and post the results as soon as possible after the Wednesday deadline (though this will partly depend on time zone);
6. In contrast to the weekly competition the judge is not required to supply detailed feedback on all entries. Instead, other entrants – and forum members more generally – are encouraged to provide their own feedback on the various images;
7. The latest winner will select the next theme taking into consideration its practicality for all potential entrants (eg. don’t select ‘Winter’ when it’s summer down under), and will initiate the new competition as soon as possible after the previous results have been posted.

Happy snapping

---

The above rules might need some fine tuning before being made sticky in this thread. Please provide any feedback in the ‘New Competition’ thread in the General Digital Photography Chat section, and I will then prepare the final text to be made sticky here…

As it stands, I can see a couple of snags with posting the competition here in the forum rather than the competition gallery. First, Exif data has to be supplied manually. This means we have to take on trust the fact that the shot has been taken within the fortnight. Though I don’t see this as particularly problematic – if people submit archive pics then they’re really missing the point of the comp.

More seriously there is the issue of where the feedback will appear. If this is posted when the competition is current then it will result in loads of text appearing between the images. I can think of three remedies:
a. Starting a contemporaneous competition post in the General Dig Photography Chat section for discussion of photos;
b. Having the competition in the competition gallery rather than the forum section;
c. Reverting to the judge only providing feedback.

If forum members can post their thoughts on the above (before 1300 GMT as my internet access can be problematic after this) in the ‘New Competition’ thread (where I will also copy this post) then I can edit a final rules to appear permanently in the fortnightly competition thread.

I'll set the theme later...

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on New Competition at 15/10/2008 - 06:38

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo