All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Horizon detail at 05/09/2008 - 13:37
Below is a picture from my recent holiday in Greece of Ancient Kassope, with (from left to right) the Amvrakikos Gulf, Preveza and Lefkada in the background. It was taken with the K10D and the DA18-55 @20mm, f9, 1/40. I find myself taking quite a lot of these wide angle panoramas, but am often disappointed with the lack of detail on the horizon (as in this case on the mountains in the distance). From my limited experience, I can come up with the following ideas for addressing this - but would very much appreciate any feedback on my musings:
a. Change the lens. While the 18-55 is a pretty good lens, vignetting is severe on shots like this - and vignetting is the principal reason I am considering upgrading next time I'm in the UK. Maybe I cannot expect such a lens to capture detail on the horizon in a shot like this. The question is would a better lens - say the DA16-45, 17-70 or 16-50, or a Sigma 17-70, do a better job here? Or are other factors involved...
b. Is the time of day the picture was taken an overriding factor? It was shot late in the afternoon. Would the build up of dust in the atmosphere prevent me from getting more detail regardless of the lens or other factors?
c. Would an ND Grad filter have enabled me to capture more detail on the horizon? I understand that this is what these filters are designed for. However, something confuses me re. this. This photo was shot in RAW and when I decrease the exposure in Silkypix this doesn't really have the effect of boosting detail on the horizon. Would underexposing the original picture and then adjusting it in Silkypix so the exposure is correct have helped capture more horizon detail?
One other thing - I've found in a lot of shots such as this (taken around dusk) that the sky comes out a rather featureless grey. Is this simply a result of the direction in which the photo was taken - ie. not towards the west where the sun would be going down, and the sky would have some colour (albeit reddish)? Or is it simply the time of day? Would a polariser work under these conditions? Or is there some other way of getting colour into the sky in shots like these?
Some of the issues raised here might be glaringly obvious to more experienced photographers; or conversely might be painfully complex. As a novice I don't really know, but any feedback would be much appreciated.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Horizon detail at 04/09/2008 - 13:05
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Competition results 2 at 03/09/2008 - 05:55
One other thing. I have to say I find it rather underwhelming on a Monday morning when a judge fails to provide any feedback on pictures. This week there wasn't even any commentary on the winner, never mind an indication of the runners up or constructive criticism and/or praise for the other pics. Isn't one of the purposes of the competition for forum users to get feedback on their photos? Might it be communicated to future judges that they are supposed to consider the merits and/or demerits of all entries in a written judgment?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Competition Results by The Judge at 02/09/2008 - 06:06
Many thanks for the kind offer. I have one battery fully charged, and another on about half - which if I'm very careful might last till early September, so I may take you up on the offer. Assuming your brother-in-law is happy to act as a courier, that is!
Am currently investigating my options - I may well get the ebay one as this is the quickest solution (and I can then check out the Hahnel charger before buying it when I'm next in the UK). It's also possible that a friend of mine will be coming out in mid-Sept., in which case I wouldn't need to put you or your brother-in-law to any any trouble.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Battery charger at 12/08/2008 - 13:23
On the other hand there are numerous cheap options (with spare batteries) on ebay from Hong Kong which will send here. Was thinking I might get one of these for now as a stopgap and get a branded charger next time I'm in the UK.
Does anyone know if using the batteries from HK would pose any risk to the camera? Also would the cheaper charger harm the Pentax battery if I used it once or twice to charge the original D-LI50?
Any feedback much appeciated.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Battery charger at 11/08/2008 - 15:01
Thanks for the judging Martin and congratulations Epithet Man.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition#53: The pleasure of summer holiday. at 14/07/2008 - 08:51
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition#53: The pleasure of summer holiday. at 10/07/2008 - 20:33
My vote would have gone to Galoot - not cause I liked it, but it just seemed to take ugliness to the limit! Yuk
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly Competition #52...."The Ugly" at 07/07/2008 - 12:42
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly Competition #52...."The Ugly" at 04/07/2008 - 10:09




Regarding the time of day - the morning would certainly have been a better time to take the shot, not only from the accumulation of dust point of view but also for the light. Unfortunately, I was only there at dusk.
It's interesting to see what more sophisticated programmes can do with a picture - and thanks Prieni & Martin for taking the time to demonstrate this. Unfortunately my digital darkroom is rather basic at present. I have a partly functional version of Silkypix, in which only the Exposure, WB, Contrast and colour are adjustable (and in which I can't play with the curves). I'm forced to use Picasa for sharpening, and other adjustments (eg. a graduated tint, which I used on this pic), which is rather crude.
I'm hopefully getting a copy of Photoshop soon, so will then be in a position to learn the dark art of digital manipulation! It's tricky getting this kind of stuff in Ethiopia (or to Ethiopia). Although, if I'm not mistaken, Gimp is available as a free download isn't it? Would you recommend Gimp, Martin? (Though if you did, I'd then have the problem of getting a fast enough connection to download it here!:roll
Re. the oversharpening - Using Picasa only gives very basic options and perhaps this accounts for the pics oversharpened state. Out of curiosity, George, do you find the photo below preferable from a sharpness point of view?
For me this seems to be a bit soft - and with Picasa the only option is to hit the Sharpen button again which results in the first shot. Something in between these two would probably be preferable.