All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly competition #7: Scales at 21/01/2009 - 05:26
related to this topic I am curious about how much extra width can be achieved when comparing the 18-55mm kit lens at 18mm with the 16-45mm at 16mm. I am shooting local chapels at as sheer an angle as possible and am wondering how much closer I can get with the 16-45. It's a lens that doesn't break the bank too.
Go on, treat yourself!
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 18/12/2008 - 09:34
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Metz 48 or Pentax 360? at 12/12/2008 - 11:54
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Missing persons report. at 12/12/2008 - 05:38
I find the shoulder strap sometimes catches on things, with potentially disastrous conseqences. Have dropped my camera twice because of this but fortunately it hasn't sustained any damage.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Wrist Strap at 12/12/2008 - 05:30
I also considered the Sigma 17-70 and opted for the 16-45 principally due to the colour rendition (something Pentax glass is known for), which to my eyes was considerably better judging from photos on flickr and elsewhere. I haven't been disappointed - the colours the 16-45 produces are superb.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on 18-55 II or 16-45? at 11/12/2008 - 13:21
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition #4 at 11/12/2008 - 05:49
I'm surprised nobody's commented on the pic I uploaded, especially in comparison to Richard Day's example.
And thanks Mike - will take a look at those tomorrow when the connection might be faster.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 10/12/2008 - 19:03
I don't know what gives you that impression.
While Photozone.de always rightly finds things to criticise with any lens, they also have lots of good things to say about this Sigma lens, and conclude: "All in all a good alternative to the native Pentax lens".
The distortion and the MTF charts look alright to me too. I would not have bought the lens otherwise.
It's not the review I'm referring to it's the Lens Performance Survey that they have on their website (sorry, don't have link handy) in which users give feedback on lenses. I tend to place slightly more emphasis on user experience than reviews and that is what is so confusing about this lens - people have such divergent opinions on it as evidenced by this survey (where it gets a pretty dire appraisal) and the Pentax Forum one (where it scores 9/10).
As a general lens the 12-24mm would be my choice - the 10-17mm is really a specialist lens with some practical but mainly crestive appplications.
On the other hand, Hefty does make some good points and Richard's FOV chart does demostrate that 12 really does encompass substantially more than 16.
Decisions, decisions. I'll probably only real come to a conclusion after visiting SRS and trying them out, but all the feedback here has certainly given me useful food for thought.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 10/12/2008 - 18:59
I was expecting some dispute over the merits (or demerits) of the Sigma 10-20. It’s amazing how much debate there is over this lens vs. the DA12-24. And not just from users, but also in reviews. I’ve read about the 10-20 winning comparative tests in which the 12-24 has performed poorly; and others in which the 12-24’s performance is lauded in contrast to the 10-20. Which is all very confusing. Though – in the real world – while I’ve come across several unhappy 10-20 users, I’ve yet to read a bad word about the 12-24. Can the variation in opinion over the 10-20 be really put down to variations in quality? As I said, confusing. (To get an impression of how confusing, check out the lens performance surveys at Photozone, where the 12-24 performs very well and the Sigma really poorly; and, by contrast, at the Pentax Forums lens surveys – where the Sigma actually slightly outscores the Pentax, though both do very well).
Unexpectedly, after this post, I’d say I’m now inclining to the 10-17. I was thinking of getting the ultra-wide for both landscape shots and creative framing – but it seems wider landscapes (and 16mm is pretty wide to start with, in any case) might be covered by multiple shots with the 16-45 and as for creative framing the 10-17 probably excels here. I guess the main downside is that the 12-24 is perhaps a more practical lens (both in range and not being fishy) – which would be more likely to stay on the camera (a serious consideration in dusty Ethiopia). And it takes filters. Although the size of the 10-17 is certainly more practical. There is of course the consideration of image quality – how do the 10-17 and 12-24 compare on this score?
Before making a decision, I would be very interested to get feedback on one more thing. How do people use their lenses? When do owners of the 10-17 & 12-24 use one and not the other? Also, when do people opt for the ultra zoom (whether 12-24 or 10-20) as opposed to the wider end of their normal zoom (16 or 18 )? Not having had any experience with these focal lengths it would be very useful to get some further impression of how I might expect to utilize a new lens.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The difference between 10, 12 and 16? at 10/12/2008 - 11:58


Taken in haste yesterday and minimally processed (only got back from hols on Monday).
Exif: K20D, DA17-70 @ 17mm, f8, 1/8 (ignore date data, which shows as 01.02.08 - had neglected to set date on my new camera!)