All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A nice walk at 07/10/2009 - 11:49
Interestingly, I think what caused me to do so much work arose from wanting to capture what I was aiming for when I took the shot - the man on the blower with the dramatic backdrop. When the man came out so small (and I couldn't zoom in further without losing the composition), I resorted to popping and pp-ing to make sure he wasn't lost in the frame. But having absorbed feedback here, I've been converted to what seems to be the consensus view that popping isn't required (I won't remove the man though, as I think he still adds to the composition).
Galoot - your picture seems to meet much better the criteria for popping as set out by David Trout (btw, thanks for your comments David). I'll take your word for it re. the dullness of the colours, but I like the b&w aspects of this most and find the popped areas a bit much. I remember, though, another popped image of yours of New York which you entered in a comp. As I recall, this was an image where popping worked really well. Perhaps you could post that here and see if you can win any converts?!
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Popping - Good or bad? at 07/10/2009 - 11:47
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Popping - Good or bad? at 06/10/2009 - 18:08
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Popping - Good or bad? at 06/10/2009 - 18:08
dr mhuni, the clouds were adjusted slightly in photoshop, but not too much... it's pretty close to how i saw it. Just very surreal light that night.
As for the second, Jackie's right about the border - it is a bit thick.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Rare view at 06/10/2009 - 12:41
Will post the (original) original later. George, you'll be horrified as I've done quite a lot of pp-ing on it!
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Popping - Good or bad? at 06/10/2009 - 12:20
Well said Martin, glad too see we scare them though.
They at least thought about us with the fortynight rules though.
7. The latest winner will select the next theme taking into consideration its practicality for all potential entrants (eg. don’t select ‘Winter’ when it’s summer down under), and will initiate the new competition as soon as possible after the previous results have been posted.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 06/10/2009 - 08:02
Personally, I think that before any drastic action is taken we should see the effect of publishing the rules more plainly. If that doesn't work, then perhaps we need a competition club within the forum, possibly with membership available only to those who have made at least 20 posts.
G
I have to say I haven't been unhappy with the way the weekly comp was going until a couple of weeks ago. I do get more satisfaction from the fortnightly comp - both because of its more intimate and comradely nature, and also as a technical exercise which offers a level playing field for all entrants. However, I think it would be a shame to lose either comp, as they serve a different purpose - one encourages you to work on shots already taken (normally), the other to use your camera.
Hopefully it won't come to this though. As George observes, let's see if giving more guidance to new judges works.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 06/10/2009 - 07:57
I'm not against popping - I find it useful in drawing attention to areas of a photo that otherwise might get lost. Though I've only used it twice (the other occasion can be seen here: link). If it's not overdone I think it can work well. Yes there's an element of artifice, but then you could say the same of framing, angle of view, focal length etc. etc. Anyway, here's my image:

Taken at the Acropolis Museum (again) with the K20D + DA17-70
Apart from the popping I'd be interested in people's views on my b&w conversion - have I overdone the contrast perhaps?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Popping - Good or bad? at 06/10/2009 - 07:38
They're both excellent. The second one has, as Dr Mhuni (a medical doctor, I presume)...
Al
That sky still looks wrong to me - but I'm clearly in a minority.
On the other hand, the second one gets better each time I look at it.
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Rare view at 06/10/2009 - 06:33



There's nothing you could have done about it, though. As usual with street photography, serendipity rules.