Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I'm with George here - in fact, to my surprise I might even prefer the colour version of the second one.

Looked again - yes, I do! Nice shot. I'd still do something about the shade in the bottom right though.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on One of the Langdale Pikes from Bowfell C&C please at 06/10/2009 - 05:04

Dr. Mhuni
I too like the second one - a lovely layered composition.

I like elements of the first but not the end result. Have you combined exposures, or done HDR, or used strong grads, because (dramatic as it is) IMHO that sky with what's in the foreground just looks plain wrong.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Rare view at 05/10/2009 - 15:57

Dr. Mhuni
I do see your point of view Mecrox. However, this is an English language forum - and the comp is part of the forum (or is it viewed as completely seperate now?). I can understand if, in the case of someone not having good English, then the comments might be rather basic. Ditto if there are a huge number of entries (not sure there has ever been 75 entries though?!). But I do think the judge owes some sort of feedback to entrants. And as I said earlier, it seems to me that this is a perfectly reasonable qualification for participation.

Moreover, when - as has been the case for the past two weeks - apparently little effort appears to go into the judging, then I view that as mildly insulting to those who have made the effort - such as you did when there was a quite large field of entrants a few weeks back.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 05/10/2009 - 13:05

Dr. Mhuni
Yes, there was something I liked about that one too!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 05/10/2009 - 12:04

Dr. Mhuni
I have to say over the past couple of weeks the comp has descended into farce. #116 is judged by someone insufficiently confident in his English to post comments beyond a few (and I mean a few) words on the winner. At least we have to assume this is the reason, because no alternative one is provided. As it turns out, he chooses a winner that is taken on a Canon. Who, the following week, goes on to pick a winner before all the entries are submitted (indeed, before some were even taken:lol.

Let's hope that some new wording posted on the comp page can sort out any future complications. Thanks for trying to sort this out Ken. Can I suggest something fairly unambiguous along the lines of don't bother entering unless, in the event of winning, you are prepared to select 1-3 (+ HCs, if appropriate) and provide feedback on all entries.

The last two weeks have been pathetic.

On a brighter note, at least we know this week's comp is in safe hands with David.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 05/10/2009 - 11:55

Dr. Mhuni
The second for me too, though I'd crop off some of the bottom and either crop or clone out the shade from the rock in the bottom right.

Not only does the b&w work better, but the sky's more interesting in 2 too, and I prefer the composition.

BTW, don't know if it's my screen, but both images seem a bit soft to me.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on One of the Langdale Pikes from Bowfell C&C please at 05/10/2009 - 07:15

Dr. Mhuni
Looks like you got a good copy, Lidy! I find numbers 2 & 4 the most interesting shots too.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on First pictures with the 16-45 at 05/10/2009 - 07:08

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks Peter, Lidy - though looking at it again, I should probably tone down the saturation a bit.

Actually this type of scaffolding is common throughout East Africa. Into the Middle East as well, I think - at least it was until a couple of decades ago. Have read about mangrove swamps in Tanzania being involved in an inter-regional trade (with mangrove poles being exported to the Gulf) at least up to the 1980s. Don't know if it's still happening - I can't quite see them using this for that luxury sail-shaped hotel in Dubai. Though it may not have been entirely abandoned. Perhaps K10D knows whether this stuff is still in use at all in that part of the world.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Meskel Square, early morning at 05/10/2009 - 06:57

Dr. Mhuni
Cheers Lilly, Paul, Martin, Peter and Lidy.

Shame about the waiter. At the time it was taken I was concentrating on his (real) position in relation to the shade from the overhanging concrete. I'd decided this was optimum - only to find out subsequently that his reflection wasn't. It just goes to show how much you have to be aware of when shooting.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Acropolis Museum at 05/10/2009 - 06:46

Dr. Mhuni
I'm a bit surprised that noone has noticed this before now - though perhaps I've missed a post over the w/e - but the competition appears to have been judged on Saturday afternoon. According to comments under David Trout's entry posted at 1437 on the 3rd Oct. Pentaxian67 chose this as the winner. There are likewise comments under Organicimagery's and flat4's entries indicating these are 2nd & 3rd.

Not sure where this leaves the comp - as many entries were posted after this.

Going on this week's and last week's experience, can I make a request of the convenors. That once a competition winner is chosen a message is sent to the winner indicating what the judging entails - including not only when the competition is closed and should be judged, but also that feedback on all the images is expected from the judge.
Or maybe something to this effect could be included in the spiel on the comps page - then we might get entries only from people who are prepared to fully participate in the comp by posting considered feedback in the event that they have to act as judge. A quite reasonable qualification for participation, IMHO.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #117 - Street photography - Comments at 05/10/2009 - 06:30

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo